Seafire Steakhouse
A premier steakhouse at Atlantis Resort, offering prime cuts, Bahamian-inspired dishes, and stunning marina views.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Seafire Steakhouse
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A premier steakhouse at Atlantis Resort, offering prime cuts, Bahamian-inspired dishes, and stunning marina views.
"Experience the best of both worlds with exceptional steaks and attentive service amid beautiful marina views."
Book Ahead
Reservations are recommended to ensure your preferred dining time.
Outdoor Seating
Patio spots are first-come, first-serve; arrive early for outdoor dining without a reservation.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Steakhouse
Price
$$$
Phone
+1 242-363-2000
Address
3, One Casino Drive, Paradise Island, Bahamas
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Prime Cuts of Meat with Marina Views
Indulge in expertly prepared steaks like the Tomahawk or New York strip while enjoying stunning views of the marina.
Bahamian-Inspired Starters
Savor local flavors with appetizers such as creamy Bahamian conch chowder and Andros crab and lobster cake.
Exceptional Service from Staff
Experience attentive service from knowledgeable staff like Rodney and Ricardo, who offer great recommendations.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Book Ahead
Reservations are recommended to ensure your preferred dining time.
Outdoor Seating
Patio spots are first-come, first-serve; arrive early for outdoor dining without a reservation.
Server Recommendations
Consider requesting specific servers like Rodney for excellent recommendations.
Beat the Crowds
Opt for early reservations for a quieter dining experience.
Tips
from all over the internet
Book Ahead
Reservations are recommended to ensure your preferred dining time.
Outdoor Seating
Patio spots are first-come, first-serve; arrive early for outdoor dining without a reservation.
Server Recommendations
Consider requesting specific servers like Rodney for excellent recommendations.
Beat the Crowds
Opt for early reservations for a quieter dining experience.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Seafire Steakhouse offers a mixed dining experience, with some guests praising the excellent quality of steaks and attentive service, particularly highlighting staff members like Ricardo and Rodney. However, other reviews point to inconsistencies in food preparation and service, with some experiencing under or overcooked steaks, and issues with side dishes. While many find the atmosphere lively, some criticize it for being excessively loud.
"We had a reservation on a Wednesday night for two. The immediate inside of the restaurant with the meat freezer is a little run down, but the inside of the restaurant is nice. The bread was warmed and delicious. We had the Tomahawk for two. We asked for medium rare, and it was a little more red than I’m comfortable with, but the texture was great so I didn’t mind. The steak was cut table-side, which was really cool. We also got the mac and cheese, which was a smaller portion than expected but delicious. For drinks we got the pineapple rosemary smash and a blueberry cocktail with mint. The flavors were great and they were very refreshing. We would definitely return!"
Madeline Dunsmore (Maddy)
"Wanted to love this place but it was sub par compared to all the other places we went in Paradise Island. My drink had to be remade. We had 2 servers and one was decent and the other dropped the ball with every request. Both my steak and my husbands steak were cooked wrong - mine under cooked and his over cooked. Plus they were Luke warm. Even maestros makes the steak sizzling hot …🤷♀️We ordered the peppers and the not so good server said they were sautéed bell peppers when they were actually shishito peppers. We sent them back. The creamed spinach was more like artichoke dip - over the top cream and Parmesan. Not what was expected. Mozzerella heirloom salad was bland and they were cherry tomatoes🤷♀️. The crab cakes were ok not great. Very forgettable experience. Won’t go back."
Gillian Goldman
"Ok let's be real with this place. The service was mediocre. The first appetizer, the steak tartare was delicious and the high point. Wife had a wedge salad also delicious after that it was all down hill. My wife ordered the grouper seasonal catch and she said it was good. I chose the burger, wanted to try a wagyu burger. My burger was supposed to be medium rare and wasn't even close. It was so over cooked and dry. The brioche was over toasted and dry. No mayo, mustard ketchup, lettuce tomato to speak of with this burger when It came out. Had to ask for stuff. Didn't even finish the bun just ate the meat. The fries were ice cold and truly inedible. The burger was flavorless, nothing special. Needed even a small pinch of salt and pepper to help it out. It just was so sad of a meal for the price we paid. If I'm paying 36$ for a burger better be way more flavorful and not overcooked. I don't recommend this place. It's over priced and under delivers."
Gil Barnes
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Seafire Steakhouse is known for its prime cuts of meat, including steaks like the Tomahawk and New York strip, as well as Bahamian-inspired starters and a lively atmosphere with marina views.
Reservations are highly recommended, especially for securing a specific time. For outdoor seating without a reservation, arriving early is advised as it's first-come, first-serve.
Some guests find the atmosphere to be very loud, particularly during peak hours or for birthday celebrations. Others enjoy the lively ambiance.
Yes, the menu includes some vegetarian dishes such as salads and sides like sautéed green beans and creamed spinach.
Yes, Seafire Steakhouse offers halal-certified beef, lamb, and chicken options. It's recommended to contact the resort in advance to ensure availability.
Popular dishes include the Tomahawk steak, New York strip, surf and turf, and Bahamian conch chowder.
Yes, the restaurant offers outdoor seating on its patio, which is available on a first-come, first-serve basis.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Atlantis Paradise Island, Bahamas - Hotel Review
For a lively atmosphere and tender cuts of steak, Seafire Steakhouse is a popular option– so plan ahead with a reservation. A raw seafood bar and grill station serve up Bahamian conch, a citrusy hamachi dish served with passion fruit, pearl onion and cilantro, and for larger dishes not to be missed try the whole branzino grilled over wood fire with roasted leeks, a mussel-saffron cream, and tarragon oil.
Bahamas-Paradise Island
This plan offers a choice of full American or continental breakfast daily at Seagrapes, Murray’s Delicatessen, Plato’s, Coral Lounge, Marketplace, Voyager’s or Mosaic and dinner daily in Seagrapes, Marketplace, Atlas Bar & Grill, Murray’s Delicatessen, Seafire, Marina Pizzeria, Café Martinique†, Carmines, Chop Stix, Bimini Road, Bahamian Club, Casa D’Angelo, The Pointe Restaurant & Bar, Mosaic, Mesa Grill, Courtyard Terrace or Dune. Dinner includes a choice of an appetizer or soup or salad; one entrée; a selection of one dessert; coffee, tea and sodas.
Seafire Steakhouse Restaurant Nassau The Bahamas Reviews
Seafire Steakhouse, located at the Atlantis Resort on Paradise Island, is a good fit for diners looking for the comforts of a contemporary cosmopolitan restaurant. High ceilings, lots of tile work and a display kitchen add drama. The steakhouse menu features some locally inspired starters of creamy Bahamian conch chowder and Andros crab and lobster cake alongside classics such as Caesar salad and beef carpaccio.
best family restaurants in nassau bahamas
INVITING RICH SMOKED SEARED GRILLED FLAVORSHigh-pitched ceilings and large chandeliers are paired perfectly with rustic brick illuminated amber glass and eclectic artwork at Seafire Steakhouse. Internationally known chef Nobu Matsuhisa has acclaimed restaurants in world-class cities such as New York City. Plan Your Trip To Nassau.
Eats for Everyone in The Bahamas
Savour halal-certified beef, lamb, and chicken options at a wide variety of restaurants, including Lagoon Bar, Fresca, Seafire, Carmines, Nobu, Fish, Café Martinique, Bimini Road, Murray’s Deli, Silan, and Shark Bites. Be sure to contact the resort at least two weeks ahead of your arrival to ensure availability.
Things to Do at Atlantis Paradise Island Bahamas with Kids
Seafire Steakhouse: This is another family favorite for when you want a meal that everyone will enjoy. We found the service to be attentive and the food, delicious. Go for the surf and turf with the Bahamian lobster tail and filet mignon if you want to best of both worlds.
Allergy-Friendly Nassau Guide
As a tip, it is first come first serve on their patio, so if you get there early enough you don’t need a reservation. Chef was great, and kids loved their steak and mashed potatoes. My food allergy kid had a plain burger (no bun) and steamed broccoli the first night.
Where to Eat in Nassau Bahamas? 25 Top Best Popular Restaurants
Seafire Steakhouse, located in the Atlantis Resort on Paradise Island, serves traditional American cuisine with a Bahamian twist. With its high-quality steak and classic sides, this restaurant offers a dining experience like no other.
The 17 Best Restaurants To Try in Nassau, Bahamas
All it will take to get to the Seafire Steakhouse is a quick ferry or boat ride from Nassau. This restaurant is located at the Atlantis Resort on Paradise Island. The ferry from Nassau to Paradise Islands takes around 15 minutes.
Marina Village Restaurants on Paradise Island
Sumptuous meals full of rich, smoke, seared and grilled flavors are the highlight of your dining experience at the Seafire Steakhouse. Find the perfect wine to complement your meal, or choose from a variety of signature drinks.
The Cove at Atlantis Bahamas: The Guide
Other notable options include a Chinese-Pacific fusion restaurant called Chop Stix, Seafire Steakhouse, Olives by chef Todd English for Italian fare and the Bahamian Club for local seafood and steaks.
Bahamas Restaurant - A Flavorful Paradise
An American steakhouse that seamlessly blends contemporary decor with traditional flavors. Families are welcome to enjoy the warm and friendly atmosphere. However, the dress code is smart casual.
Atlantis Bahamas Dining Planning | Atlantis Paradise Island
Venues include Lagoon Bar & Grill, Ocean Club Clubhouse, Seafire Steakhouse, Carmine’s, Sip Sip, Frezca, Bimini Road, Murray’s Deli, Chop Stick, Perch, Poseidon’s Table, Village Burger Shack.
Ultimate Guide to Restaurants at Atlantis Bahamas
: Seafire Steakhouse offers a sophisticated dining experience with a focus on high-quality meats and an extensive wine list. The decor is elegant, with dark wood accents and a warm ambiance.
best steak restaurants in nassau bahamas
From Japanese sushi bars and Italian restaurants to seafood and steakhouse dining Nassau covers all of the culinary bases and this lists points you to the best in each genre.
best steak restaurants in nassau bahamas
Baha Mar Just Opened Its First Steakhouse And They Got The Best Butcher In The World To Oversee It Foodie Baha Steakhouse
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit