The Pie Plate
A charming family-run bakery since 2003, renowned for scratch-made pies, pastries, gourmet pizzas, and unique sandwiches with local ingredients.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
The Pie Plate
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A charming family-run bakery since 2003, renowned for scratch-made pies, pastries, gourmet pizzas, and unique sandwiches with local ingredients.
"The Pie Plate is an absolute must visit for its unforgettable pies and creative pastries!"
Visit during Harvest Season
Experience Niagara's famous peaches in pie form, made with the freshest seasonal ingredients.
Consider Off-Peak Times
Limited indoor seating during winter; visit during less busy times for a more comfortable experience.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Bakery & Cafe
Price
Mid-range
Phone
+1 905-468-9743
Address
1607 Four Mile Creek Rd, Virgil, ON L0S 1T0, Canada
Website
thepieplate.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Renowned Butter Tarts
Indulge in their highly recommended butter tarts, hailed as some of the best ever tasted. A must-try!
Seasonal Fruit Pies
Savor homemade pies crafted with seasonal ingredients from local orchards, featuring favorites like pumpkin and cherry.
Gourmet Pizzas & Sandwiches
Enjoy unique thin-crust pizzas and hearty sandwiches, perfect for a delicious lunch or light dinner.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit during Harvest Season
Experience Niagara's famous peaches in pie form, made with the freshest seasonal ingredients.
Consider Off-Peak Times
Limited indoor seating during winter; visit during less busy times for a more comfortable experience.
Embrace the Artisanal Quality
While prices may reflect artisanal quality, reviewers find the taste justifies it. Try small versions to sample more.
Pair Drinks with Your Treats
Enjoy their cocktails, local craft beers, and wines that perfectly complement the pies and pastries.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit during Harvest Season
Experience Niagara's famous peaches in pie form, made with the freshest seasonal ingredients.
Consider Off-Peak Times
Limited indoor seating during winter; visit during less busy times for a more comfortable experience.
Embrace the Artisanal Quality
While prices may reflect artisanal quality, reviewers find the taste justifies it. Try small versions to sample more.
Pair Drinks with Your Treats
Enjoy their cocktails, local craft beers, and wines that perfectly complement the pies and pastries.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
The Pie Plate is consistently praised for its exceptional homemade pies and tarts, especially the butter tarts and seasonal fruit varieties. Diners also rave about the delicious sandwiches and pizzas made with quality ingredients. While the food receives high marks, some mention occasional service delays or limited seating, though the friendly staff often makes up for it.
"Have been coming here for a number of years. I know pastry is a personal taste, but in my books, The Pie Pate makes the best pastry and one I hope to be able to copy some day. This plus well filled pies and tarts make these items the best I have ever had. This expertise and attention to detail can be found in their other baked goods, including the breads. We had a late lunch and got sandwiches. I had the turkey avocado, and my husband had the Italian deli on Ciabatta ( if not, it was focaccia). These did not disappoint, and both could have been shared with another - saved for lunch the next day - and were just as good. Local wine and beers/ciders are available. We have bought their frozen goods to take home and was not disappointed. Almost forgot...coffe is great as well. My only fault this las
t visit was having 3 gentlemen who came in after me were served before me... not unusual for me as I am short and often not seen behind glass and deli counters. Staff are very friendly and helpful. If you like baked goods, then this place needs to be on your list."
sheena ewen
"Tried a few different slices here — grape pie, chocolate cream pie, and strawberry rhubarb — and they were all excellent! The standout for me was definitely the strawberry rhubarb pie. Unfortunately, the coffee was a letdown. It was much too bitter for my taste, and I couldn’t finish it. That said, I’d definitely come back for the pies... they’re worth it!"
Rachel K
"Absolutely loved our visit to The Pie Plate in Virgil — what a gem! From the moment we arrived, Lola’s warm and thoughtful service made us feel right at home. She welcomed us with a smile and a refreshing glass of cucumber water, which was the perfect touch on a summer day.
The food was fantastic — the pepperoni pizza had a perfectly crisp crust and bold, savoury flavour. The salmon croissant sandwich was buttery, fresh, and beautifully balanced, and the quiche was light, creamy, and full of goodness. Every bite tasted homemade and full of care.
The iced coffee was also a standout — smooth, bold, and refreshing without being too sweet.
Between the cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and Lola’s incredible hospitality, it was one of the best stops we’ve made in Niagara. Highly recommend!"
Bill Dandie
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Highly recommended are the butter tarts, seasonal fruit pies (like peach and strawberry rhubarb), and sandwiches such as the turkey avocado or Italian deli.
While not explicitly stated, they offer a variety of pies and pastries that may be adaptable. It's best to inquire directly about gluten-free options.
As a family bakery, they likely accommodate special requests. It's recommended to call ahead to discuss custom pie orders.
Visiting during harvest season ensures the freshest fruit pies. For best selection and less crowds, consider weekday visits.
Yes, they offer great coffee, cappuccinos, lattes, hot chocolate, and smoothies, as well as cocktails, local beers, and wines.
They offer a variety of pastries and sandwiches. Some reviewers have noted non-dairy latte options, but specific vegan options should be confirmed.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
11 Best Niagara-on-the-Lake Restaurants Right Now, By A Local
Right next door to Silversmith Brewing Company, The Pie Plate is paradise for those with a sweet tooth. This is the best way to try Niagara’s famous peaches around harvest time: in pie form. Fruit-filled pies and house-baked pastries are made from scratch using seasonal ingredients from the surrounding orchards.
Best Dessert Spots in Niagara-on-The-Lake
Founded as a humble family bakery in 2003, The Pie Plate has grown into a vibrant local hotspot. Their homemade pies, bread and baked goods initially sparked local interest, and the business began partnering with nearby fruit farmers, cheese artisans, and meat suppliers to craft unique sandwiches on our signature baguettes, gourmet thin-crust pizzas, and an ever-changing selection of small plates. Their menu now also features distinctive cocktails that pair perfectly with local craft beers and wines.
10Best Restaurant & Bakery Reviews
If you're looking for a spot that offers its guests only the very freshest and local desserts, than you certainly have come to the right place when you venture off to The Pie Plate Bakery & Cafe located on the way to Niagara-on-the-Lake. This place serves up some of the very best and freshest pies you will ever taste. And of course they don't just offer up a few good tasting pies, but have an abundant pastry menu which changes every season.
Niagara-on-the-Lake: Grain in the land of grapes - The Growler – Ontario's CRAFT BEER GUIDE | ON Craft Breweries | Breweries In ON
Everyone will tell you that if you’re on Niagara Stone Road, visiting Oast House and Silversmith, a walk across the street to The Pie Plate is mandatory. All of their creations are pretty dynamite, but the small-size versions are my favourite because they let groups smaller than a hockey team try a variety of the flavours like unexpected grape pie or the iconic peach.
Where to eat in Niagara-on-the-lake, Ontario, Canada
This restaurant is small, cozy and still owned by a local family. They are located off the main Niagara Stone Road that you’d likely be driving on to the old historic town. Here they grow some of the berries, herbs or veggies that they use in their menu.
36 Hours in Niagara-on-the-Lake | Girls’ Road Trip with Buick Canada
Beechwood Donuts – located in St. Catharines, this is the place to go for scratch-made donuts, which are also 100% vegan. When we visited, the line stretched out the door and we unfortunately didn’t have time to stick around.
Getting a Great Cup of Coffee in Niagara-on-the-Lake
If you’re in the mood for an early morning coffee with the perfect breakfast sandwich, look no farther than The Pie Plate. Imagine homemade ice cream sandwiches with fresh Ontario strawberries. What could be better?
Our Favourite Ontario Takeout: Niagara-on-the-Lake
Cafe lunch menu including one-of-a-kind sandwiches served on housemade baguette (think porchetta and brie), gourmet thin crust pizzas, salads and baked treats made from locally sourced ingredients.
A day trip to Niagara On the Lake with street food, canola farmers and a winery
Then with our bellies still full, Suresh we insisted we make a quick stop at The Pie Plate, a cozy family operated pie shop with fresh seasonal ingredients like peach in their peach pecan pie.
One Day In…Niagara-on-the-Lake
At wineries like Inniskillin, restaurants like the Old Winery Restaurant, or pizza specialty shops like The Pie Plate. Thin sweet crust, savoury tomato, and a garden of
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit