Antica Trattoria Comes
Polignano a Mare's oldest trattoria since 1926, serving authentic Pugliese cuisine and fresh seafood with genuine family warmth.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Antica Trattoria Comes
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Polignano a Mare's oldest trattoria since 1926, serving authentic Pugliese cuisine and fresh seafood with genuine family warmth.
"The best restaurant in Polignano hands down! Food was so good, very local, everyone was Italian. Not a tourist trap."
Reservations Recommended
Secure your table in advance, especially during peak times, as demand is high.
Must-Try Dishes
Don't miss the prawns and the cavatelli with seafood – true highlights of the menu.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian (Pugliese)
Price
Mid-range
Phone
+39 080 424 8888
Address
Via Pompeo Sarnelli, 14, 70044 Polignano a Mare BA, Italy
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Pugliese Cuisine
Experience traditional, homemade-style Pugliese dishes crafted with passion by a family-run business.
Fresh Seafood Specialties
Savor high-quality seafood dishes, including renowned prawns and cavatelli with seafood, bursting with ocean flavors.
Historic Charm
Dine at Polignano a Mare's oldest restaurant, operating since 1926, offering a genuine local experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Reservations Recommended
Secure your table in advance, especially during peak times, as demand is high.
Must-Try Dishes
Don't miss the prawns and the cavatelli with seafood – true highlights of the menu.
Beat the Crowds
Consider visiting during off-peak hours or on weekdays to enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.
Embrace Local Culture
Experience authentic Italian dining where locals frequent; a true family restaurant feel.
Tips
from all over the internet
Reservations Recommended
Secure your table in advance, especially during peak times, as demand is high.
Must-Try Dishes
Don't miss the prawns and the cavatelli with seafood – true highlights of the menu.
Beat the Crowds
Consider visiting during off-peak hours or on weekdays to enjoy a more relaxed dining experience.
Embrace Local Culture
Experience authentic Italian dining where locals frequent; a true family restaurant feel.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Antica Trattoria Comes is celebrated for its authentic, traditional Pugliese cuisine and incredibly fresh seafood, served at fair prices in a warm, family-run atmosphere. Many diners rave about the delicious pasta dishes and the genuine hospitality from owner Giuseppe. While overwhelmingly positive, some reviews mention it can get busy, suggesting reservations are a good idea.
"The best restaurant in Polignano hands down! I came here multiple times during my trip, food was so good. Very local, everyone was italian. Not a tourist trap."
E P
"We went for dinner at Antica Trattoria Comes on a recent evening and were pleasantly surprised by how quickly it filled up right after opening at 8:30 PM—a clear sign this beloved spot lives up to its reputation .
Despite the busy scene, service was great. There was just one waiter on duty, yet he remained friendly, attentive, and efficient throughout the evening—an impressive performance under pressure .
To start, we had the seafood salad, simple yet expertly fresh—letting the natural flavors shine. Next up were the seafood cavatelli and seafood risotto, both bursting with authentic, briny “flavours of the sea.” They were beautifully executed and deeply satisfying. We finished with a chocolate mousse, velvety rich and decadently deep, yet never too heavy.
What truly sets this place apart is its commitment to simple local dishes made with locally sourced ingredients. If you’re in Polignano a Mare and craving honest, flavorful seafood in a charming, lively trattoria, this is a must-visit."
Christopher Kalff
"This was one of the best experiences that we had in Polignano a Mare! Giuseppe was the best waiters we have ever had the pleasure of meeting! The food was amazing, the braciole and the mussel pasta were our highlights, we would 100% recommend this restaurant to anyone visiting! Thanks for a fabulous evening."
Bianca Albanese
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
It's known for its authentic traditional Pugliese cuisine, especially its fresh seafood dishes, and its long history since 1926.
Yes, it is highly recommended to make a reservation, as the restaurant is very popular and can fill up quickly, especially during peak hours.
Diners frequently recommend the prawns and the cavatelli with seafood. Other popular choices include various seafood pastas and antipasti.
The restaurant has accommodated requests for vegan options, with at least one review mentioning a made-to-order vegan pasta.
The atmosphere is described as cozy, local, and family-run, offering a genuine and lively trattoria experience.
To avoid long wait times, consider visiting during off-peak hours or on weekdays. Some were able to get tables by arriving shortly after opening.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
10 Best Restaurants in Polignano a Mare, Italy
This restaurant is said to be the number 1 pick among the Polignano a Mare restaurants. It is also the town’s oldest, having continued to operate incessantly since 1926. Antica Trattoria Comes is truly a gem.
Polignano a Mare Food Tour
On this tasting of typical products tour in Polignano a Mare, we'll taste the most delicious recipes of the Italian region of Apulia in a typical trattoria.
Polignano a Mare dove mangiare bene spendendo poco
Quasi tutti i ristoranti, trattorie ed osterie di Polignano a Mare propongono una cucina tradizionale e una cucina a base di pesce davvero prelibata.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit