
Café Hitchcock
A sleek neighborhood cafe on Bainbridge Island offering house-cured meats, hearty sandwiches, and quality coffee with a farm-to-table ethos.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Café Hitchcock

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A sleek neighborhood cafe on Bainbridge Island offering house-cured meats, hearty sandwiches, and quality coffee with a farm-to-table ethos.
Avoid Weekend Crowds
Consider visiting on weekdays to avoid potential weekend crowds, especially on busy Saturdays.
Beware of Hidden Fees
Be aware of potential hidden fees or surcharges added to your bill, as noted by some reviewers.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(206) 201-3369
Address
129 Winslow Way E, Bainbridge Island, WA 98110, USA
Website
cafehitchcock.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Signature Sandwiches
Indulge in rave-worthy grilled cheese and flavorful pastrami sandwiches on perfect rye bread.

Farm-to-Table Philosophy
Experience locally sourced produce and seasonal dishes from Chef Brendan McGill's commitment to sustainability.

Quality Coffee & Cocktails
Savor high-quality coffee and expertly crafted cocktails, including delicious matcha lattes.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Avoid Weekend Crowds
Consider visiting on weekdays to avoid potential weekend crowds, especially on busy Saturdays.
Beware of Hidden Fees
Be aware of potential hidden fees or surcharges added to your bill, as noted by some reviewers.
Communicate Dietary Needs
Clearly communicate any dietary restrictions or preferences; they are known to be accommodating.
Embrace the Local Vibe
Take your time and linger at this spot; it's designed to make you want to stay a while.
Tips
from all over the internet
Avoid Weekend Crowds
Consider visiting on weekdays to avoid potential weekend crowds, especially on busy Saturdays.
Beware of Hidden Fees
Be aware of potential hidden fees or surcharges added to your bill, as noted by some reviewers.
Communicate Dietary Needs
Clearly communicate any dietary restrictions or preferences; they are known to be accommodating.
Embrace the Local Vibe
Take your time and linger at this spot; it's designed to make you want to stay a while.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Café Hitchcock is celebrated for its high-quality sandwiches, farm-to-table ingredients, and excellent coffee. Diners praise the flavorful food and the commitment to local sourcing, though some mention slow service and higher price points. The atmosphere is modern and upscale, making it a delightful lunch spot on Bainbridge Island, with a particular nod to their outstanding matcha lattes.
"Lovely lunch spot for a day on Bainbridge - high quality sandos and salads. Love a lunch place that also has a quality wine BTG list and cocktails and friendly service!"
Andrea Ikata
"This place was great but aptly rated.
Pros:
- flavorful food
- good Irish coffee
- great atmosphere
Cons:
- slow service
- over cooked eggs
- Shakshuka should come with bread and not need to be ordered on the side
- took just as long to serve the coffee as it did the food
I would go again if I’m in the area but not a place I’m running back to. Over all, I wasn’t disappointed."
Marco
"Lovely little spot on Bainbridge Island. I stopped in for a drink during my day on the island, and I got an Aperol Spritz. Very nice drink, good service. That one drink was about $20, though, so be aware of the prices before you order anything."
Calla Bjorklund Jarvie
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The pastrami sandwich and grilled cheese are highly recommended. The kale salad and farm-to-table dishes are also excellent.
Yes, it's a popular spot for weekend brunch and weekday breakfast, offering options like sandwiches and smoothies.
Absolutely! They serve high-quality coffee, with many praising their excellent matcha lattes and espresso drinks.
Yes, they offer a quality wine BTG list and craft cocktails, including seasonal options.
Yes, they are accommodating of gluten sensitivities and offer gluten-free options on their menu.
The cafe has a modern and upscale feel with a clean, industrial interior and a welcoming ambiance.
While the food is high-quality, some reviewers note that prices can be on the higher end.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
A Guide to Bainbridge Island: The Nantucket of the Pacific Northwest
Hitchcock, with its locally sourced meat dishes and a “name your price” tasting menu, was named to Eater Seattle’s best-of list and draws foodies from well beyond Seattle. Aside from Sunday brunch, they only serve dinner, though, so if you just have a day, hit Hitchcock Deli, the affordable sandwich outpost where a steelhead trout tartine or turkey-breast bánh mì will keep you full all day. For sweets, don’t miss Mora Iced Creamery, a Washington state institution where the best flavors are made from local ingredients—think lavender, green tea, and blackberry.
6 Bainbridge Island Dining Stops for Your Next Day Trip
Hop off the ferry for a dinner of oysters, salmon tartare, and superlative roast chicken at Brendan McGill’s original restaurant. A recent upgrade befits the food—nice bathrooms, custom ceramics, user-friendly menu categories—and thanks to a new extruder, pasta dishes like twisty gemelli in a sauce of stinging nettles and cream are more consistent than ever. These days, McGill serves pork only from his own Shady Acres farm; the charcuterie plate might come layered with lonza, coppa, or a dollop of rillettes made from his Mangalitsa hogs.
Bainbridge Island & Bremerton
Chef Brandon McGill packs a one-two punch with his casually upscale Café Hitchcock (129 Winslow Way E) and celebrated seafood restaurant Seabird (133 Winslow Way E). Dine on modern versions of Vietnamese food, like pork wontons in spicy truffle oil, at trendy Ba Sa (101 Winslow Way E). Head to the convivial Harbour Public House (231 Parfitt Way SW) for tasty gastropub fare and views of the water, and Madison Diner (305 Madison Ave N) for a meal inside a stainless-steel retro diner with comfy red booths.
Foodie Finds
The Hitchcock mini empire of food experiences catered by award-winning star chef Brendan McGill are destinations of their own. Hitchcock is the 10-year old flagship restaurant offering inventive and creative Northwestern fare with cozy seating in a warm atmosphere. Have a delicious seasonal handcrafted cocktail at The Burgerhaus, where the record player mixes retro vinyl, the lounge area has a fireplace, and books and board games are readily available (open late).
Where To Eat & Drink On Bainbridge Island
Your fancy dinner options on Bainbridge Island aren’t exactly endless, but there’s always Hitchcock. It’s a simple, dimly lit American restaurant that works well for important moments, like when you need to break it to your parents that you quit your office job and moved to Mount Vernon to open your own kombucha brewery. Order some cured salmon, beets, and pasta – there’s nothing like carbonara by candlelight to soften an emotional blow.
A guide of things to do, places to eat
Café Hitchcock is a casual café offering breakfast, brunch and lunch along with organic espresso, kombucha on tap and winning salads. Ingredients are locally grown and sourced whenever possible, as the restaurant prides itself on working with local purveyors and farmers. Check out the avocado toast or breakfast skillet and save room for its famous cast-iron cookie topped with vanilla ice cream.
9 Best Restaurants in Bainbridge Island | Blog
A true gem in Bainbridge Island's dining scene, Café Hitchcock is a celebration of farm-to-table philosophy. Chef Brendan McGill's commitment to sustainability and locally sourced produce is evident in every dish served at Café Hitchcock. The ever-evolving menu reflects the seasons, ensuring that each visit brings a new and exciting culinary adventure.
Bainbridge Island Has Become a Restaurant Haven
Pre-COVID, he operated Hitchcock, then one of the best restaurants in town. COVID nearly shut him down, but he stayed open by serving take-out and inviting excellent chefs from far and wide to cook their best gourmet food at outside grills on weekends, attracting long lines of masked customers who ordered from a tent and ate outside.
5 Best Restaurants on Bainbridge Island You Can't Miss
website | directions | best for: all-day, well-executed eats. Seattlelites might recognize the name Hitchock because there used to be a Hitchcock Deli in Georgetown. Brendan McGill closed that offshoot, but Cafe Hitchcock is still kickin’ at its the original Bainbridge Island location and a new spot in downtown Seattle.
The 5 Best Bainbridge Island Restaurants For Breakfast
Cafe Hitchcock: For one of the best brunches on the weekends and midday breakfast on weekdays, this hip spot on Winslow Way is a great place to start your day. For some, that might mean a spicy bloody Mary or a bright citrus mimosa. The breakfast options include overnight oats, deluxe sandwiches, and smoothies.
There’s more nightlife in Kitsap County than you might think
Others that offer music, mostly on weekends, include: The Bar at Cafe Hitchcock, Weave shows at Rolling Bay Hall, Bainbridge Brewing Alehouse, The Ravine, Pegasus and Fletcher Bay Winery on Winslow Way, which offers rooftop seating along with music.
Hitchcock WebReviews on Family Restaurant in Bainbridge Island, WA 98110 - The Streamliner Diner, The Madison Diner, That's A Some Pizza, Green Light Diner, Bruciato ... Best family restaurant near Bainbridge Island, WA 98110.
Your Ultimate Guide to Living on Bainbridge Island
Ba Sa is a favorite for Vietnamese dishes, while Hitchcock is known for its elevated Pacific Northwest menu. If you’re craving seafood, Harbour Public House offers stunning waterfront views along with locally sourced meals.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit