Beer Church Brewing Co.
A historic Civil War-era church transformed into a vibrant brewery and pizzeria, offering unique craft beers and artisanal wood-fired pizzas.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Beer Church Brewing Co.
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A historic Civil War-era church transformed into a vibrant brewery and pizzeria, offering unique craft beers and artisanal wood-fired pizzas.
Avoid Summer Crowds
Visit during the off-season to avoid crowds, especially during the busy summer months.
Beer Selection Focus
Most beer offerings are stouts or IPAs; if you prefer variety, be aware of the brewery's focus.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Brewery, Pizza
Price
$$$
Phone
(269) 586-3864
Address
24 S Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117, USA
Website
beerchurchbrewing.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Historic Church Ambiance
Dine inside a charming Civil War-era church, offering a unique blend of history and modern brewery culture.
Artisan Wood-Fired Pizza
Savor incredibly flavorful, thin-crust pizzas made with homemade dough and fresh ingredients.
Craft Beer Haven
Explore a diverse selection of craft beers, especially IPAs and stouts, with creative flavor names.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Avoid Summer Crowds
Visit during the off-season to avoid crowds, especially during the busy summer months.
Beer Selection Focus
Most beer offerings are stouts or IPAs; if you prefer variety, be aware of the brewery's focus.
Embrace the Theme
Be prepared for playful, snarky church references throughout the restaurant's decor and theme.
Tips
from all over the internet
Avoid Summer Crowds
Visit during the off-season to avoid crowds, especially during the busy summer months.
Beer Selection Focus
Most beer offerings are stouts or IPAs; if you prefer variety, be aware of the brewery's focus.
Embrace the Theme
Be prepared for playful, snarky church references throughout the restaurant's decor and theme.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Beer Church Brewing Co. offers a unique dining experience in a historic church, lauded for its delicious wood-fired pizzas and creative craft beers. While many praise the atmosphere, food quality, and friendly service, some diners have noted high prices and occasional issues with service responsiveness or accommodations.
"What a great place to just hang out with the spouse, friends, whoever. A lot of snarky church references so if you are touchy about that keep it to yourself or don't go. The service is good. The food? The best wood fired pizza I've had. The 🍺 is tasty. Everything about the place is fun."
Kevin Werner
"This was our 2nd time here, and it didn’t disappoint. The pizza crust is the best. Seriously I wish all pizza had this crust. Everything else was tasty. Some things feel a little higher priced than they would be other places and the menu design takes a bit to figure out. Stephanie was a phenomenal server - knew the menu and had opinions - helped guide us the right direction."
Toph Carter
"Great brews! The atmosphere was excellent... the staff... well...
I parked in the back parking lot because that was the closest available. I recently had a significant foot injury and just got out of my boot. ( I didn't fly with my crutches, my fault, but this was the only place it was an issue)I hobbled my way inside because I really wanted to visit this location! I sat at the bar and then was advised there was no bartender and I would need to go to the upper deck. I asked if I could order in the main indoor seating area and have my flight brought there and explained my situation. The answer was that wasn't possible! Had my flight, great beers, love the flight board and the unique names.
After struggling my way back down ALL the stairs and back up stairs to get out, I asked the hostess if she could possibly be let me out the back door, the same person that said I couldn't be served downstairs (and aware of my recent injury), the answer was "no"again. So, I made my out the front and used the black railing on the side to help myself along, only to cut my hand on something on the railing.
What could have been an amazing side trip turned into a stressful and disappointing experience due to the lack of accommodations."
KS Ann
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
It's housed in a historic Civil War-era church, offering a distinctive atmosphere alongside craft beers and wood-fired pizzas.
They focus on robust beers, particularly IPAs and stouts, with creative flavor profiles and names.
Yes, the wood-fired pizzas, especially the thin-crust varieties, are frequently highlighted as delicious and a must-try.
To avoid crowds, it's recommended to visit during the off-season, as it can get very busy during the summer months.
Yes, they have a large outdoor patio and a rooftop deck, often noted as a great spot for dining, especially in good weather.
Yes, gluten-free options are available on the menu, noted as a positive for diners with dietary restrictions.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Road-trip time: A guide to southwest Michigan's booming brewery scene
What's next: More breweries are on the way for Berrien County in 2016: Beer Church Brewing (www.beerchurchbrewing.com) plans to open by late summer in a Civil War-era church in New Buffalo with a focus on bigger beers, especially IPAs, and with Tapistry's initial head brewer, Nate Peck, at the helm of the brewing operation; Watermark Brewing (www.watermarkbrewing.com) targets a mid-June opening in Stevensville; and Haymarket Brewing (www.haymarketbrewing.com), one of Chicago's most popular brewpubs, aims to open its production facility and taproom in a former Michigan State Police facility in Bridgman in August.
Outdoor Bars Near Me | Largest Outside Bar in Michigan with Outdoor Se
_ You'll notice from the beautiful pizzas + wood-fired sandwiches in our reels, pics, and posts -and those of our hundreds-of-thousands of GUESTS each year-_ that we make our own bread each day. The same for our pizza dough + fresh mozzarella. And we serve it all at each of our bars including the UPPERDECK + CHURCH INTERIOR.
Destination New Buffalo, Michigan
I recently learned about the Beer Church Brewing Co. at 24 S Whittaker St., where you can sample their locally brewed beers and wood fired pizza. I was excited to visit the brewery on my recent trip. Located in a former Civil War era church, they have an indoor taproom and restaurant, a large outdoor patio and rootop deck.
New Buffalo Restaurants: Your Guide to the Best Eats in Town
Located in a restored, Civil war-era church, Beer Church Brewing takes the concept of “beer and pizza” to the next level. In additon to amazing, small-batch pours, they have one of the best pizzas this side of Chicago. The Pizza Napoletana is nothing short of amazing, pair it with some craft beers.
8 Unique Places to Dine Outside in New Buffalo
You’re unlikely to miss Beer Church as you enter town, with two levels of colorful outdoor seating astride a stately white Civil War-era church. The food game focuses on wood-fired pizza Napoletana with flavor profiles as creative and confident as the atmosphere. Sports fans, this is your place!
How to Spend a Weekend in New Buffalo, Michigan
Day drinking is the agenda at Beer Church Brewing Company, a taproom nestled in a renovated Civil War-era church. Sip small-batch brews (the Pontius Pilate IPA is a fan favorite), and dive into Neapolitan-style pizza in the lively beer garden, touted as Michigan’s largest.
15 Best Restaurants in New Buffalo, MI | Blog
Housed in a renovated church, this brewery and restaurant serves wood-fired pizza alongside its craft beer lineup. Beer Church Brewing Co. blends historic architecture with a modern menu, offering both indoor and patio seating. Its casual vibe appeals to a wide audience.
Discovering New Buffalo, Michigan: Restaurants and Attractions
Housed in a converted 19th-century church, Beer Church Brewing Co. offers a unique dining experience. Their website states they have the largest outdoor bar in Michigan. Known for their craft beer and artisan pizzas, it’s a lively spot perfect for casual outings.
New Buffalo, Michigan Travel Guide
Beer Church Brewing Co – I missed the beer this time around, but they have a great list!. They also have a pizza oven and some delicious thin crust pizza!. The patio outside is heated and if you need a good spot to hang out after a day at the beach, this is it!
Things to Do in New Buffalo, Michigan
This Civil War-era church-turned-brewery and pizzeria has a large two-level outdoor heated beer garden. Lots of large high-top tables can accommodate larger groups. Breakfast is served daily in addition to lunch and dinner.
Day Trip from Chicago: New Buffalo, MI
Housed in an old church, Beer Church Brewing was popping when we arrived. We were able to snag a seat at the bar. One of the best things about Beer Church was how easy it was to try samples of all their unique beers.
New Buffalo Michigan Attractions & Top Activities
If you prefer craft beer, Beer Church Brewing Co. offers a unique experience with its craft brews served in a beautifully restored historic church.
New Buffalo | Neighborhood Guide
The craft beer scene is also growing, with breweries such as Beer Church Brewing Co. offering a relaxed atmosphere for locals and tourists alike.
4 Days Romantic Weekend In New Buffalo: Itinerary 2025
End your evening with a visit to Beer Church Brewing Co. where you can enjoy craft beers in a unique setting.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit