Casey's New Buffalo
A historic 200-year-old building offering a vibrant sports bar and grill experience with a beachside vibe, live music, and a dog-friendly patio.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Casey's New Buffalo
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A historic 200-year-old building offering a vibrant sports bar and grill experience with a beachside vibe, live music, and a dog-friendly patio.
Embrace the Patio in Warm Weather
Enjoy the large patio and live music during warmer days for the best experience.
Seek Indoor Seating for Quiet
Opt for indoor seating if you prefer a quieter atmosphere than the bustling outdoor areas.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American, Bar & Grill
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(269) 469-6400
Address
136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117, USA
Website
caseysnewbuffalo.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Live Music and Patio Ambiance
Enjoy lively entertainment on the patio during warmer months, creating a vibrant atmosphere.
Historic Building Charm
Dine in a cozy, 200-year-old building near the beach, offering a unique historical ambiance.
Diverse & Delicious Menu
Savor a variety of dishes, from specialty burgers and seafood to vegetarian options.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Embrace the Patio in Warm Weather
Enjoy the large patio and live music during warmer days for the best experience.
Seek Indoor Seating for Quiet
Opt for indoor seating if you prefer a quieter atmosphere than the bustling outdoor areas.
Try the Unique Cocktails
Don't miss out on Casey's unique cocktail offerings, known for being fantastic.
Heed Side Portion Advice
Be aware that some reviewers mention side dish portions might be on the smaller side.
Tips
from all over the internet
Embrace the Patio in Warm Weather
Enjoy the large patio and live music during warmer days for the best experience.
Seek Indoor Seating for Quiet
Opt for indoor seating if you prefer a quieter atmosphere than the bustling outdoor areas.
Try the Unique Cocktails
Don't miss out on Casey's unique cocktail offerings, known for being fantastic.
Heed Side Portion Advice
Be aware that some reviewers mention side dish portions might be on the smaller side.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Casey's New Buffalo is praised for its friendly and attentive service, with staff like Tamara and Ariana frequently highlighted for making dining experiences enjoyable. The food receives positive mentions for being delicious, especially burgers and fish and chips, though some reviewers noted issues with specific dishes like the perch or ribs. The atmosphere is generally liked, particularly the outdoor patio, but noise levels inside can be high.
"Today we both had burgers. My wife had the Casey's with blue cheese and I had the shroomed burger and truffle fries. We also had the drunken scallops appetizer. All of it was delicious!
They're dog friendly, at least on the patio."
Dan Balasses
"We had such a great experience here! The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Our server accidentally spilled some water on my daughter, but she handled it so well—we actually found it pretty funny and appreciated her grace under pressure. I had the fish and chips, which were cooked just right. My only suggestion would be to serve them last so they stay piping hot and extra crispy. The outdoor seating area in the back is beautiful and made for a perfect setting after a long day at the beach. Overall, a really pleasant and memorable meal!"
Jason Theriault
"Casey’s Bar and Grill in New Buffalo is a true gem! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for a casual night out or a quick bite. The menu has a great variety — everything we ordered was cooked perfectly and full of flavor. The service was fantastic as well — friendly, fast, and attentive without being overbearing. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, Casey’s is definitely worth the stop. Can’t wait to go back!"
Douglas Meece II
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Casey's New Buffalo is dog-friendly, especially on their patio. They even provide water for your canine companions.
Reviewers often rave about the burgers, fish and chips, Mahi Po Boy, crab cakes, and pot roast stroganoff.
Casey's often features live music on their backyard patio during warmer months.
The restaurant has a lively sports bar vibe, especially inside. The backyard patio offers a more relaxed and enjoyable setting, particularly with live music.
While not always necessary, during peak times or for larger groups, it might be wise to call ahead, though walk-ins are common.
During busy periods, drinks may be served in plastic cups, which some patrons find less than ideal.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
New Buffalo, Michigan
Party: If you’re looking for a lively bar scene to do some shoulder-rubbing, flirting, or dancing, there are just three tickets in town — 1) The rooftop at the Stray Dog is bar vibes only, but you’re guaranteed to fight for room at the bar and enjoy close encounters with other travelers, 2) The backyard at Casey’s offers a Juke Box and on many nights live music, inside or outside, you are guaranteed to have a good time and great service, 3) if you are the gambling type, take the bus from The Harbor Grand Hotel (where the Terrace Room is) or the Marina Grand Hotel (where the Bentwood Tavern is) to The Four Winds Casino (and Hard Rock) at the edge of town, the Hard Rock has live music all the time and the dance floor is always a vibe.
8 Best Restaurants in New Buffalo, MI | Blog
is a popular sports bar and grill known for its casual atmosphere, friendly service, and mouthwatering pub fare. Located just steps from the beach, this laid-back eatery is a favorite among locals and tourists. Guests can enjoy a variety of classic comfort food dishes, including burgers, sandwiches, wings, and nachos, as well as a selection of craft beers and cocktails.
New Buffalo Restaurants: Your Guide to the Best Eats in Town
Casey’s in New Buffalo throws open its doors (and its heart) to locals and visitors alike. Think hand-cut steaks sizzling on the grill, juicy burgers stacked high with fresh fixings, and sunset cocktails shimmering like spilled rainbows. But Casey’s isn’t just about filling your belly – it’s about soaking up the good vibes.
15 Best Restaurants in New Buffalo, MI | Blog
A reliable neighborhood eatery, Casey’s offers a menu filled with American pub favorites such as wings, wraps, and burgers. It’s a laid-back spot popular with both locals and visitors. The outdoor seating area is active during warmer months, often featuring live music or seasonal events.
BEST DINNER OPTIONS IN NEW BUFFALO, MICHIGAN
Casey’s offers casual yet fine dining – the vibe is relaxed and fun. Fresh seafood, signature burgers/sandwiches and creative salad options will make your taste buds sing.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit