Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery
A no-frills seafood shack and market offering exceptionally fresh catches, from fried favorites to raw oysters, with a side of award-winning cookies.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A no-frills seafood shack and market offering exceptionally fresh catches, from fried favorites to raw oysters, with a side of award-winning cookies.
Order Raw Oysters
Raw oysters are highly recommended by reviewers. Consider trying them on your next visit.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To avoid crowds, it's advised to visit during less busy times.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Seafood
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Award-Winning Cookies
Don't miss out on Gadaleto's unbelievably delicious and award-winning cookies – they're a must-try!
Fresh, High-Quality Seafood
Experience incredibly fresh seafood, from perfectly cooked haddock and scallops to raw oysters and crab cakes.
Casual Waterfront Dining
Enjoy a relaxed, no-frills atmosphere with counter service and a spacious dining room, perfect for seafood lovers.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Order Raw Oysters
Raw oysters are highly recommended by reviewers. Consider trying them on your next visit.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To avoid crowds, it's advised to visit during less busy times.
Reusable Silverware Option
Opt for reusable silverware when dining in to help reduce waste.
Call Ahead for Events
If planning an event or catering, call ahead to request special orders.
Tips
from all over the internet
Order Raw Oysters
Raw oysters are highly recommended by reviewers. Consider trying them on your next visit.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To avoid crowds, it's advised to visit during less busy times.
Reusable Silverware Option
Opt for reusable silverware when dining in to help reduce waste.
Call Ahead for Events
If planning an event or catering, call ahead to request special orders.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Gadaleto's Seafood Market & Eatery is highly praised for its incredibly fresh, high-quality seafood and generous portions, served in a casual, no-frills atmosphere. While many rave about dishes like the haddock, shrimp, and award-winning cookies, some diners have had less satisfactory experiences with specific items like calamari and found issues with silverware presentation and credit card tipping prompts.
"Best seafood meal I've had in decades. A big hunk of fresh, fresh haddock, cooked to perfection and served hot. It was accompanied by sweet potato fries, again, perfectly prepared. And also a generous serving of crunchy cole slaw, in a take-home container. My companion shared one of her scallops with me: also perfectly fresh, tenderly prepared. Six stars."
Maggie Boys
"Atmosphere is relaxed. Everyone is extremely nice. I will definitely come back. Food was good. I had crab and fries. Hubby had lobster bisque and fish. Definitely recommend"
H&R Event Planning
"Had the best shrimp basket here!! The batter was lite and crunchy,the tarter was delicious!! Fried to perfection!! Casual dining, highly recommended"
Dayna Mudge
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Gadaleto's is celebrated for its exceptionally fresh seafood, including haddock, scallops, shrimp, oysters, lobster, and various fish dishes.
Yes, Gadaleto's has a spacious and clean dining room where they will bring your food after you order at the counter.
Absolutely! Gadaleto's is famous for its award-winning cookies, which are a must-try addition to your meal.
Reviewers highly recommend the fresh haddock, shrimp basket, fish tacos, raw oysters, and the delicious cookies.
Yes, it's described as an excellent casual fish restaurant suitable for families, offering a wide selection of fresh seafood options.
Yes, Gadaleto's has an adjoining fish market where you can purchase high-quality, fresh seafood to take home.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
15 Best Restaurants in New Paltz, NY for 2025 (Top Eats!)
Built in 1979, Gadaleto’s Seafood has become one of the award-winning seafood restaurants in New Paltz. It follows sustainable fishing guidelines to ensure a high quality of food.
Restaurants near Hokkaido Japanese Restaurant, New Paltz
Great! Always fresh from ocean fest! Great oysters! Cold beer! Nice wine selection. Super duper friendly staff. Chefs are great. Never dissatisfied or disappoint!!!!
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit