Romeo's Pizza
A traditional pizzeria chain known for its unique sweet sauce, great deals, and consistently presented pizzas, offering a casual dining experience.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Romeo's Pizza
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A traditional pizzeria chain known for its unique sweet sauce, great deals, and consistently presented pizzas, offering a casual dining experience.
Try the Sweet Sauce
If you enjoy sweet sauces, Romeo's offers a unique flavor profile that some find addicting.
Check for Deals
Keep an eye out for ongoing promotions to get the best value for your meal.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(330) 390-8444
Address
987 S Washington St, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Signature Sweet Sauce
Romeo's signature sweet sauce is a polarizing but addicting flavor, with some finding it uniquely delicious.
Consistent Pizza Appearance
Pizzas are noted for their consistent appearance, with evenly cooked layers and toppings.
Value Deals
The pizzeria frequently offers great deals that are hard to resist, making it an appealing option.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Sweet Sauce
If you enjoy sweet sauces, Romeo's offers a unique flavor profile that some find addicting.
Check for Deals
Keep an eye out for ongoing promotions to get the best value for your meal.
Inspect Your Order
Upon delivery or pickup, check your order to ensure it meets expectations for size and toppings.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Sweet Sauce
If you enjoy sweet sauces, Romeo's offers a unique flavor profile that some find addicting.
Check for Deals
Keep an eye out for ongoing promotions to get the best value for your meal.
Inspect Your Order
Upon delivery or pickup, check your order to ensure it meets expectations for size and toppings.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Romeo's Pizza garners mixed reviews, with patrons often divided on its signature sweet sauce. While many praise the deals and consistent appearance of the pizzas, others report issues with rude service, incorrect orders, and uneven topping distribution. Some customers find the sweet sauce addictive, while others find it overly sweet. The quality of ingredients and preparation can also vary, leading to disappointment for some.
"Out of town shoppers so we stopped by because it was close to our hotel. Had the 1/2 Tuscan and 1/2 pepperoni blast."
John Lilley
"I’m not sure if the one woman at the counter ever smiles. Typically when I call with a question it’s a female answering the phone and she is quite rude. The ONLY reason we still order from there is because my boyfriend likes the food. However, our last order my pizza was horrid, all the toppings were in the middle and there was very little cheese even spread on it. Truly disappointed."
Christy Hershner
"Romeo's is definitely one of the....pizzas of the world. Its not good, and it's not bad. Its a pizza you get when you really don't feel like making Mac and cheese at home.
The sauce - 3.5
If you're one of those weird people that likes sweet sauce, you'll like Romeo's. Now, I understood it was sweet going into my first bite, but holy cow was it sweet. Who dumped the maraschino cherries in with the tomatoes?
The crust - 2
Have you ever microwaved a pizza, and really got it bubbling, and then let it cool down before eating it? You remember how tough the crust was, but at the same time it was still soft? Yeah. You could tell me the crust wasn't microwaved, and I'd call you a dirty liar. BUT, it was consistent. It was crusted, and crunchy around the edge, and flat under the sauce.
The look - 4
As I said, it was definitely a consistent pizza. Evenly layered, evenly cooked. The only reason it didn't deserve 5 stars on appeal is because I had to look for my ham. When I ordered it, I was expecting maybe 1\4 or 1\2 chunks of ham. No, it was more like the size of bacon bits, just cubed ham. The slices were even, and it was neat and tidy.
Overall - 3.16 stars.
Final comment:
Save yourself the cash, and grab a Red Baron pizza from the freezer at Dollar General."
Ben Giovenco
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Romeo's Pizza is recognized for its signature sweet sauce, which some customers find addicting, and for offering frequent deals.
Some customers have reported issues with incorrect orders, missing items, and toppings being unevenly distributed.
Service can be a point of contention, with some customers describing staff, particularly a manager, as rude.
While some reviews note consistent appearance and even cooking, others have received pizzas with toppings in the center or uneven cheese.
Romeo's Pizza is generally considered mid-range, with good deals often available that make it a budget-friendly option.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit