
Tisha's Fine Dining
A charming, locally-loved BYOB spot in Cape May offering New American cuisine with elegant ambiance and consistently delicious dishes.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Tisha's Fine Dining

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A charming, locally-loved BYOB spot in Cape May offering New American cuisine with elegant ambiance and consistently delicious dishes.
Make a Reservation
Essential for securing a table, especially during peak times like holidays and weekends.
Embrace BYOB
Bring your own bottle of wine to enhance your meal and save on costs.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
New American, Italian
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Seafood Risotto
Creamy and flavorful risotto loaded with perfectly cooked scallops, a standout dish praised by many.

Charming BYOB Ambiance
Enjoy a cozy, intimate dining experience with the flexibility to bring your own favorite wine.

Unique Calamari
Tender calamari elevated with a distinct honey mustard drizzle, a frequently praised appetizer.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Make a Reservation
Essential for securing a table, especially during peak times like holidays and weekends.
Embrace BYOB
Bring your own bottle of wine to enhance your meal and save on costs.
Prepare for Delays
Peak times may experience understaffing, so patience is advised.
Tips
from all over the internet
Make a Reservation
Essential for securing a table, especially during peak times like holidays and weekends.
Embrace BYOB
Bring your own bottle of wine to enhance your meal and save on costs.
Prepare for Delays
Peak times may experience understaffing, so patience is advised.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Tisha's Fine Dining is praised for its consistently delicious food, particularly the seafood risotto and unique appetizers, within an elegant yet quaint ambiance. While many commend the attentive service and the value of the BYOB policy, some diners have experienced issues with overbooking, potential delays during peak times, and less-than-ideal seating arrangements.
"This restaurant deserves five stars all around! The service was great. The atmosphere is quaint. But the food is definitely spot on. Everything from the appetizers right through to the dessert was amazing. No complaints had by anyone at the dinner table, and we went with a big group. I would definitely recommend if you’re looking for a more luxurious meal."
Lynne A
"We have been here multiple times over the past few years, and the food and service are always above and beyond. Danny has been our server the last two times we have been here and he remembered us and even where we sat the last time. We came today to celebrate our one year wedding anniversary while in Cape May. We are from Pittsburgh so we are only here once a year or so. We always make a point to stop here for dinner while vacationing in CM. The food is always delicious but the service is more so what keeps us coming back. I can’t speak highly enough about this restaurant. If you’re looking for fine dining while in Cape May, this is the place to go. Thank you, Tisha’s, for always making us feel special!"
Ainsley M
"Came here for dinner for my cousins bachelorette weekend. Love a great BYOB and this place came highly reccomended. Service was great and food was phenomenal. Would definitely go back if I go back to that area. The calamari was EXCELLENT, burrito a peach salad was ok, the peaches weren't ripe so that was a little underwhelming. The Halibut that had on special was incredible, so fresh and cooked perfectly. The filet was delicious but the peppercorn(in my opinion) was a little too much to my liking. The seafood risotto was very flavorful and cooked perfectly as well. The gnocchi was great too."
Sarah Malter
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Tisha's Fine Dining is a BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle) restaurant, allowing you to bring your favorite wine or other beverages.
Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak seasons and weekends, as the restaurant is quite small.
The seafood risotto is a standout, and many diners also rave about the calamari with honey mustard drizzle.
During peak times like holidays or weekends, the restaurant can be understaffed, so some delays are possible.
Tisha's serves New American cuisine with some Italian influences, offering a variety of dishes from seafood to steaks and pastas.
Yes, Tisha's offers outdoor seating, which some diners find to be a pleasant option.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The 20 Best Restaurants In Cape May - Jersey Shore
Spend at least one night of your stay strolling the Washington Street outdoor mall, popping into art galleries and boutiques selling pricey jewelry and handmade soaps. When you do, plan for dinner at Tisha’s. A Cape May mainstay for more than three decades, this restaurant still hits with consistent favorites like the creamy lobster bisque and the seafood risotto with a heap of scallops.
Best Dining Towns NJ Cape May - NJ Monthly
Other top-flight restaurants known for creative, sophisticated menus and inviting ambience include the ocean-facing Union Park (try the Ahi Tuna with kiwi salad and spiced green tea glaze); The Peter Shields Inn (with five dining rooms and cappuccino bar); the intimate Ebbitt Room (where pianist Steve LaManna holds court); French/Caribbean/New Orleans-influenced 410 Bank Street; Axelsson’s Blue Claw; Oyster Bay; the Pier House at the Water’s Edge; Aleathea’s; the Merion Inn (where you’ll find what’s billed as the city’s oldest bar, built in 1885); the “New American” cuisine at Tisha’s (located on the beachfront promenade)—and The Mad Batter, the city’s best breakfast spot, with specialties that include gourmet oatmeal pancakes and orange-almond French toast. If it’s afternoon tea you’re after, check out the pleasantly understated Carriage House Tea Room & Café, with a fixed-price menu for both tea and lunch.
Breakfast & Dining
With such a selection of enjoyable dining in Cape May… we’re happy to share our favorites with you!. Seafood Cape May Fish Market (BYOB) H & H Seafood (BYOB) *temporarily closed off-season Mayer’s Tavern (full bar) *late season open Wed-Sat Prawn Restaurant (BYOB) *temporarily closed off-season The Lobster House (full bar) Two Mile Landing & Crab House (full bar) *temporarily closed off-season. Upscale Black Duck on Sunset (BYOB) *late season open Thurs-Mon Grana (BYOB) *late season open Thurs-Mon Peter Shields Restaurant (BYOB – close by) *closed Tuesdays Primal by Mia Mia (BYOB) *late season open Thurs-Sun The Ebbitt Room (full bar) *late season open Wed-Sun The Pier House Restaurant – La Mer Hotel (full bar – close by) *late season open Thurs-Sun Union Park Dining Room (BYOB – close by) *closed Tuesdays Vintage (BYOB) *closed Mondays Washington Inn (full bar) *late season open Thurs-Sat
Seasonal Salads at the Shore
Tisha’s features tasty side salads on both their lunch and dinner menus. For lunch, try their classic Cobb salad or order their House Specialty salad with grilled or crispy chicken on romaine, tomato relish, red onion, cucumbers, hard boiled egg, and house-made buffalo blue cheese dressing. For dinner, enjoy their simple and delicious Kale Caesar salad with pecorino romano, anchovies, and their house-made caesar dressing.
16 Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ 2023 (Best Food)
The quaint and elegant Tisha’s Fine Dining is a lovely locally-owned eatery filled with small-town charm and an impressive new American menu. The restaurant has rustic polished wood accents with white-clothed tables for a fine dining experience amid casual surroundings. The place is well-loved by patrons and visitors for its delicious variety and views of the town streets from the breezy outdoor seating area.
Exploring The 26 Best Restaurants In Cape May NJ
Located on the Washington Street Mall, Cape May NJ, Tisha’s is over 30 years old and a staple when it comes to trying New American and fine Italian cuisine. In a classic setting, they continue to provide exquisite dinners, such as grilled Fish and Prawns, salads and Risotto, and a variety of Burgers, Po’boys, and wraps as well. Tisha’s is highly recommended; they’re BYOB but offer Cape May Wines.
Off-Season Cape May Dining: Exploring Charming Winter Cafes and Restaurants
For a true winter retreat, venture to Tisha’s, a culinary haven that exudes warmth and hospitality. Tucked away in the heart of Cape May, Tisha’s offers a menu that reflects the charm of the season. From hearty soups to inventive New American dishes, each plate is a testament to the chef’s commitment to crafting a culinary experience that warms both the heart and the palate.
BYOBs in Cape May Part I -
Tisha’s on Washington Street Mall (it had been located on the beach) was established in 1995 and has developed quite a following. In addition to a lovely dinner menu, Tisha’s also serves lunch during the busier months (they take a few months off at the start of the year). The menus are limited but hit all the notes of cuisine from seafood to steak to pasta.
All Restaurants in Cape May
A trip to Cape May, the oldest seashore resort in the country, would not be complete without dinner at Tisha’s. Conveniently located on the Washington street mall, Tisha’s is celebrating 30 years in business and considered a must try in the Cape May restaurant community. Our New American cuisine is sure to please even the most sophisticated palates.
Not the Jersey Shore you'd expect: Cape May NJ is the Perfect Getaway
Fine Dining on Washington Street For an exceptional fine dining experience, head to Tisha’s on Washington Street. Known for its outstanding cuisine, this restaurant allows you to bring your own bottle of wine to accompany your meal. The seafood risotto is a standout dish, making Tisha’s a must-visit for connoisseurs seeking culinary excellence.
19 Best Restaurants in Cape May (2021 Guide)
Located on the Washington Street Mall, Tisha’s has been a staple since 1988. With 30 years of business under its belt, this fine dining restaurant is by far one of the best in Cape May. Their New American style encompasses cuisines from across the States while keeping a strong focus on the delectable seafood that the cape is known for.
A Weekend in Cape May, NJ
It has been a popular spot downtown for over 30 years at 322 Washington St. The Ugly Mug Restaurant & Bar at 426 Washington St. is a casual pub with indoor and outdoor seating. I talked to some locals who enjoy the food. Margie D’s Soda Fountain is a vintage soda fountain on the Washington St. Mall at 501-503 in the Della’s 5 & 10.
19 Unique Things to Do in Cape May, NJ
📍 Google Maps | Phone: (609) 884-9119 | Website | Hours: See website for current Lunch & Dinner hours. Tisha’s Fine Dining isn’t just one of many great restaurants on the Washington Street Mall, it’s one of the best!. Celebrating over 30 years of service in Cape May, Tisha’s Fine Dining serves up some of the tastiest dishes.
40 Best Restaurants in Cape May, New Jersey – Best Places to Eat
Located in Washington street mall, Tisha’s Fine Dining is a beloved restaurant that specializes in Italian cuisine. The restaurant captivates visitors with its warm atmosphere and favorable dishes. Serving New American fare, the restaurant offers something for even the most sophisticated of palates for both lunch and dinner.
Where to Eat in Cape May
A trip to Cape May would not be complete without dinner at Tisha’s. Conveniently located on the Washington street mall, this year Tisha’s celebrates 30 years in business and is considered a must try among the restaurant community. Their New American cuisine is sure to please even the most sophisticated palates.
Cape May Restaurants « The Mission Inn
Tisha’s is located in the heart of downtown Cape May, offering delicious lunch and dinner menus with limited inside dining. And since it’s downtown, you can plan to walk around after dinner and enjoy some shopping, live music, or people watching. Make reservations through Open Table or call 609-884-9119.
7 Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ
Located in the Washington Street Mall, Tisha’s Fine Dining offers new American cuisine that’ll satisfy even the most sophisticated palate. Tisha’s provides a large selection of lunch and dinner options. Enjoy seafood risotto, short rib bolognese, or one of the restaurant’s many other delectable entrées.
Romantic Restaurants in Cape May
A short distance from our business, Tisha’s is located on the Washington Street Mall. It’s a great spot to grab a delicious meal and enjoy strolling in and out of the shops on the Mall. The restaurant has been in business for over 20 years and offers a wonderful variety of steak and seafood entrees.
Top Cape May Restaurants for a Perfect Date Night
Tisha’s Fine Dining, located in the Washington Street Mall, offers a cozy yet refined atmosphere perfect for a casual yet romantic evening. With a menu that blends classic American dishes with a touch of Mediterranean flair, Tisha’s provides a unique dining experience in the heart of Cape May.
Cape May Restaurants | Dining
Tisha’s – Tisha’s Fine Dining is a New American restaurant with intimate ambiance and a creative and exciting menu. With a family tradition of love and passion for food, Tisha’s is a Cape May restaurant staple for an unforgettable meal. Only a ten minute walk from Bedford Inn.
Cape May’s 11 greatest restaurants, ranked, for 2023
In 1988, Letitia Negro opened a 10-table Wildwood restaurant known for its home cooking. Her son, Paul, and his wife, Jennifer, opened Tisha’s Fine Dining, on the Washington Street Mall, in 1995. This is the most refined restaurant among those along the mall.
The Complete Guide to Restaurants in Cape May
Tisha's Fine Dining is located in the historic section of Cape May, New Jersey. This cozy sit-down restaurant specializes in New American fare, including sandwiches and burgers. The ambiance is charming and offers an excellent view of the waterfront.
Top 7 Eats in Cape May County!
In 1988, Leticia Negro (AKA Tisha) opened a 10-table restaurant in Wildwood serving "made from the heart" cuisine. Although the times and location have changed, the family proudly continues the tradition to honor Tisha’s passion for good food.
Best Dining Spots in Cape May NJ
Tisha’s Fine Dining is in a cozy location along busy Washington Street. They serve sophisticated dinners like Grilled Salmon and Shrimp with Thai Chili Sauce or Short Rib Bolognese with pappardelle. Tisha’s is a BYOB establishment.
Top 8 Gluten-Free American Diners to Experience in Cape May
Enjoy a cozy outdoor vibe with attentive service, local wine options, and a menu that keeps dining exciting for everyone. Great food and good service. They were knowledgeable about gluten free options and very accommodating.
Cape May Restaurants
This probably goes along with our favorite breakfast spot, because at Tisha’s you are seated directly on the beach, too. You see...we aren't very sophisticated people and like the simple things in life.
25 Best Restaurants in Cape May, NJ for 2025 (Top Eats!)
322 Washington StreetCape May, NJ 08204(609) 884-9119 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Tisha’s is a small, sit-down restaurant known for its New American menu.
16 Great Outdoor Dining Destinations
The people-watching on the Washington Street Mall is as delicious as the food at Tisha’s, where you’ll find steak au poivre and other elegant selections.
Tisha’s Cape May voted as one of the best in outdoor dining
Tisha’s Fine Dining has been open for 34 years and is located in the very scenic Washington Street Mall. It is a BYOB restaurant with outstanding food.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit