Carmine's Pizza
A retro-style pizza haven serving uniquely creative pies and traditional calzones with exceptional customer service.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Carmine's Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A retro-style pizza haven serving uniquely creative pies and traditional calzones with exceptional customer service.
Avoid Peak Times
Visit during off-peak hours to skip long wait times, common on the Cape.
Customize Your Pizza
Ask for custom toppings or variations for a truly personalized meal.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Uniquely Different Pizza
Explore creative pizza combinations beyond the usual.
Exceptional Customer Service
Staff go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience.
Allergy-Friendly Options
Enjoy delicious gluten-free pizzas and other accommodating choices.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Avoid Peak Times
Visit during off-peak hours to skip long wait times, common on the Cape.
Customize Your Pizza
Ask for custom toppings or variations for a truly personalized meal.
Try the 'No Bake' Option
Enjoy takeout with chef tips for a perfect at-home cooking experience.
Tips
from all over the internet
Avoid Peak Times
Visit during off-peak hours to skip long wait times, common on the Cape.
Customize Your Pizza
Ask for custom toppings or variations for a truly personalized meal.
Try the 'No Bake' Option
Enjoy takeout with chef tips for a perfect at-home cooking experience.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Carmine's Pizza is a beloved spot praised for its exceptional, authentic pizza with a perfect crust and delicious toppings. While the cozy, retro atmosphere is noted, the standout is consistently the high quality of the pizza and the friendly, accommodating service. Some find the pricing a bit high for the portion size, and a rare instance of an 'angry lady' was mentioned, but overall, customers rave about its consistency and taste, with many considering it the best pizza they've had locally or even regionally. +7
"Carmine’s Pizza is our family’s favorite on the Cape! Located in Chatham, we’ve been patrons for years. The pizza has an incredibly perfect crust. The sauce and toppings are so good! The chef is a gem, so good at what she makes! I recommend Carmine’s to any friends visiting the area."
Christy L
"We got a large half cheese half pepperoni pizza, we ate it all. Called in the order at 8pm, they had us pick it up at 8:50pm. Busy place. Cute little town."
Elizabeth Han
"Very delicious pizza with a laid back atmosphere. The large is huge and fairly priced. The staff were friendly and helpful. Great end to a great day at Carmine’s!"
Russell W
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Carmine's is known for its uniquely different pizza combinations not found in typical chains, offering a perfect crust, delicious sauce, and fresh toppings. [^M1, ^R1]
Yes, Carmine's offers allergy-friendly options, including delicious gluten-free pizzas. [^M4]
To avoid long wait times common in this area, it's recommended to visit during off-peak hours. [^data_tip1]
Absolutely! You can ask for custom toppings or variations on menu items for a personalized experience. [^data_tip2]
Carmine's has a laid-back atmosphere with checkered tablecloths and retro touches. It's a cozy, low-key stop. [^R3, ^M2]
Yes, Carmine's offers takeout, including a 'no bake' option with helpful tips from the chef for cooking at home. [^data_tip3, ^M3]
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Where the Locals Eat in Chatham
Almost directly across Main Street from Captain’s Table is Carmine’s, a pizza restaurant and cafe that always draws a local crowd. This pizzeria offers pizza by the slice and a selection of specialty pies that aren’t to be missed. If you’re tired of the same old varieties found at every pizza chain in the country, give Carmine’s a try for some uniquely different combinations.
Chatham, MA: A Foodie's Paradise with 21 Amazing Restaurants
Carmine’s is a charming restaurant located in Chatham, MA, USA. It is a quaint and low-key stop that offers a unique dining experience. The retro touches throughout the restaurant add to its cozy and nostalgic atmosphere. One of the highlights of Carmine’s is their delicious traditional pizzas and calzones.
Recommended Restaurant Guide | Chatham, MA, Cape Cod
Located in town, Carmine’s has become a local favorite for pizza, sub sandwiches and salads. They also serve slices and they do deliver. 595 Main St Chatham, MA 02633 (508) 945-5300 Menu
Cape Cod Allergy-Friendly Travel Guide
We ordered and safely ate a mushroom pizza free of egg, peanut, tree nut, and sesame. Also, it was delicious!
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit