Baker's Bakery & Cafe
A quaint Custer mainstay serving homestyle American breakfast and lunch with an irresistible bakery counter full of fresh treats.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Baker's Bakery & Cafe
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A quaint Custer mainstay serving homestyle American breakfast and lunch with an irresistible bakery counter full of fresh treats.
"This is the BEST way to start your day in Custer, SD."
Arrive Early for Breakfast
Beat the rush by arriving before 10:00 AM, as breakfast service ends at 11:00 AM.
Party Must Be Present
Ensure your entire party is ready before being seated to avoid issues with waiting lists.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Decadent Pastries & Donuts
Irresistible baked goods, from fluffy cinnamon rolls to perfect donuts, beckon from a tempting display case.
Generous Homestyle Breakfasts
Start your day with hearty portions of classic American breakfast fare, including huge pancakes and flavorful burritos.
Savory Burgers & Lunch
Satisfy your lunch cravings with delicious burgers, like the Jalapeno Ranch, and crispy garlic cheese curds.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Arrive Early for Breakfast
Beat the rush by arriving before 10:00 AM, as breakfast service ends at 11:00 AM.
Party Must Be Present
Ensure your entire party is ready before being seated to avoid issues with waiting lists.
Don't Skip the Sweets
The baked goods, especially donuts and caramel rolls, are a must-try and incredibly delicious.
Try Unique Offerings
Explore beyond the classics with flavorful options like loaded oats or a smothered burrito.
Tips
from all over the internet
Arrive Early for Breakfast
Beat the rush by arriving before 10:00 AM, as breakfast service ends at 11:00 AM.
Party Must Be Present
Ensure your entire party is ready before being seated to avoid issues with waiting lists.
Don't Skip the Sweets
The baked goods, especially donuts and caramel rolls, are a must-try and incredibly delicious.
Try Unique Offerings
Explore beyond the classics with flavorful options like loaded oats or a smothered burrito.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Baker's Bakery & Cafe is a beloved Custer staple, praised for its generous portions of delicious homestyle American food and an array of irresistible baked goods. Diners rave about the friendly service and cozy atmosphere, making it a top choice for both breakfast and lunch. While the food and service are consistently highlighted as positives, some minor suggestions for environmental improvement have been noted.
"Folks were very nice and the food was hot and tasty and the craft beers was excellent! Very Historic town. The baked goods were absolutely delicious! Try the burgers and garlic cheese curds!"
Matthewseven13
"Located in beautiful Custer you’ll find this seemingly small restaurant and then upon entering are met with a plethora of seats in the front and back area. Don’t have time to dine in? No problem! One pastry will feed a family of four. Check it out for yourself. Food was great, service was great, they have tap to pay option as well as regular card terminals and they take cash."
Chris Masterson
"We stopped in for donuts and loved them! The staff were friendly and funny! Encouraging us to try them all (which was tempting). Even the other guests were recommending donuts. They were some of the best raised donuts we’ve had in a long time. So fresh and squishy-just like I like them! My husband for carrot cake and the berry cheesecake bar. So good! We are going back tomorrow for more!"
Nikki Butler
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
It's recommended to arrive before 10:00 AM, as breakfast service ends at 11:00 AM and seating can be limited.
The restaurant does not explicitly mention accepting reservations. It's advised to arrive with your full party present to be seated, especially during peak times.
Diners highly recommend the donuts, cinnamon rolls, breakfast burritos, and burgers. The Jalapeno Ranch Burger is a notable favorite.
Yes, the menu indicates that gluten-free options are available. It's always best to confirm with your server for current offerings and cross-contamination concerns.
Street parking is typically available in the downtown area where the restaurant is located.
Yes, Baker's Bakery & Cafe serves lunch, featuring a selection of burgers, sandwiches, wraps, and salads.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Black Hills National Forest: First-Timer's Guide
You’ll likely notice the glass display case brimming with pastries at the Baker’s Bakery and Cafe while you’re strolling down the main strip in Custer, and that’s usually all it takes to choose this breakfast spot. Only open for breakfast and lunch, you’ll be satisfied by the haunt’s classic diner fare, but don’t skip ordering a pecan roll or other specialty treat for the table.
Best Places to Eat in Custer
If you like a little FUN on the side, Baker’s Bakery & Cafe is for you!. This family-operated restaurant has a classic midwest menu with a little south-western flare. As one of the top rated breakfast places in South Dakota, this is the BEST way to start your day in Custer, SD.
Best Brunch in Custer, SD
541 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD 57730-1531+1 605-673-2253 See Menu. Baker’s Bakery & Cafe feels like the heart of Custer’s brunch scene. The first time I stepped in, the scent of fresh-baked bread pretty much made any other plans disappear.
Best Restaurants in Custer, SD
Baker’s Bakery & Cafe, open seasonally for breakfast and lunch, has an incredible menu of traditional as well as unique offerings. But personally, the main attraction is DOUGHTNUTS!. I kid you not, they are amazing.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit