Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co.
Bustling Custer eatery famous for its creative pizzas and, most notably, its incredible bison burgers served on fresh, house-made buns.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Black Hills Burger & Pizza Co.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Bustling Custer eatery famous for its creative pizzas and, most notably, its incredible bison burgers served on fresh, house-made buns.
Try the Bison Burgers!
Don't miss the bison burgers, praised as the best in Custer for their fresh buns and flavor.
Pizza with a Kick
Be aware that some pizzas have jalapeños, which can be quite spicy. Order with caution if sensitive to heat.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American (Burgers & Pizza)
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(605) 673-3411
Address
441 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD 57730, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Signature Bison Burgers
Juicy bison burgers crafted with fresh, house-made buns and unique toppings. A must-try for burger enthusiasts!
Creative Pizzas
Explore unique pizzas with flavorful toppings like Thai Chicken and the spicy Hot Granny. Perfect for adventurous eaters!
Welcoming Atmosphere
Enjoy a cheerful, modern space with friendly staff, making it a great spot for families and casual dining.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Bison Burgers!
Don't miss the bison burgers, praised as the best in Custer for their fresh buns and flavor.
Pizza with a Kick
Be aware that some pizzas have jalapeños, which can be quite spicy. Order with caution if sensitive to heat.
Order at the Counter
Seat yourself and order at the counter for efficient service. Online ordering is also available.
Beat the Crowds
Visit during off-peak hours or right when they open, especially on weekends, to avoid long wait times.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Bison Burgers!
Don't miss the bison burgers, praised as the best in Custer for their fresh buns and flavor.
Pizza with a Kick
Be aware that some pizzas have jalapeños, which can be quite spicy. Order with caution if sensitive to heat.
Order at the Counter
Seat yourself and order at the counter for efficient service. Online ordering is also available.
Beat the Crowds
Visit during off-peak hours or right when they open, especially on weekends, to avoid long wait times.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners rave about the exceptional bison burgers and creative pizzas, often calling them the best in the area. The friendly atmosphere and unique toppings are frequently praised. However, some find the fries to be average, and there's a mention of a transition from a burger-focused menu to pizza, which initially caused some disappointment but has since been rectified with the return of bison burgers.
"Amazing food! Owner was so friendly. Thai pizza was beyond impressive! I wish we had pictures from before!
So good we went back the next day… burgers were as great as the pizza! Took pictures today! If you are in Custer, or even close by, this is a must!!
Mr and Mrs Pizza 🍕. Bacon blue burger 🍔 Hot honey burger so good best and unique must try!!!!🍯 the heat was perfectly balanced! Do yourself a favor and just try this place."
Elizabeth Hart
"Our family loved this place! You seat yourself and order at the counter… you can also order online! It was busy but the staffed worked hard to clear tables and seat people that were waiting! We ordered the terminator with no sausage and the cheese curds! So good!!"
Blair K
"The Big and Juicy Buffalo burger was amazing. I ate it too fast so missed the picture. The pizza was also a delight. Would recommend if you are passing through Custer to make it a food stop."
Damion Van Slyke
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The bison burgers, particularly options like the 'Hot Granny,' and creative pizzas such as the 'Thai Chicken' and 'Betty White' are highly recommended.
Yes, you can build your own pizza with a choice of crust, sauce, and toppings to create your perfect pie.
Yes, the description mentions creative burgers with vegetarian options, and pizzas can also be customized.
To avoid long wait times, it's recommended to visit during off-peak hours or right when they open, especially on non-weekend days.
They offer a good selection of craft beers, including local brews, and handmade shakes.
While not explicitly detailed, the menu board does list 'Gluten Free Bun' as an option for burgers.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit