All Star Pizza & Italian Restaurant
A beloved neighborhood spot serving authentic New York-style pizza with a diverse menu and generous portions at great prices.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
All Star Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved neighborhood spot serving authentic New York-style pizza with a diverse menu and generous portions at great prices.
Crispy Pizza Request
Ask for your pizza to be extra crispy for a perfectly cooked crust that suits your preference.
Specialty Pie Recommendations
Try unique flavors like the Ricotta and garlic white pie or the Sunday special for a delightful experience.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic New York-Style Pizza
Experience the fluffy, airy crust and flavorful toppings of authentic New York-style pizza, a true standout for many.
Generous Portions, Great Value
Enjoy substantial meals and pizza portions that offer incredible value for money, making it a local favorite.
Diverse Menu Beyond Pizza
Explore a wide array of Italian dishes, from flavorful garlic knots and subs to specialty pies and wings.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Crispy Pizza Request
Ask for your pizza to be extra crispy for a perfectly cooked crust that suits your preference.
Specialty Pie Recommendations
Try unique flavors like the Ricotta and garlic white pie or the Sunday special for a delightful experience.
Lunch Specials for Value
Take advantage of their lunch specials for a great value meal, often including pizza and a drink.
Don't Miss Wing Wednesday
Enjoy Wing Wednesday with $1 wings, served with your choice of ranch or blue cheese.
Tips
from all over the internet
Crispy Pizza Request
Ask for your pizza to be extra crispy for a perfectly cooked crust that suits your preference.
Specialty Pie Recommendations
Try unique flavors like the Ricotta and garlic white pie or the Sunday special for a delightful experience.
Lunch Specials for Value
Take advantage of their lunch specials for a great value meal, often including pizza and a drink.
Don't Miss Wing Wednesday
Enjoy Wing Wednesday with $1 wings, served with your choice of ranch or blue cheese.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners consistently praise All Star Pizza for its delicious New York-style pizzas, generous portions, and friendly service. The restaurant offers great value, especially with its lunch specials and unique specialty pies. While most experiences are positive, some customers have reported issues with delivery times and order accuracy.
"The chicken parmesan pizza was so good! We loved it! We will be ordering again soon! God bless you guys ❤️🙏"
Nikki Harvey
"Amazing Chicken Francese & Great Portions!
We’re so glad we finally tried this Italian restaurant after living in the area for over 20 years! The Chicken Francese was the best we’ve had, and the portions were very generous. The meal came with delicious pasta, salad, and fresh rolls, making it an incredible value. Even the person who took my order over the phone was kind and helpful. Excellent food and service—we’ll definitely be back!"
Vicki Losasso
"Great pizza! Our neighbor recommended this place after we mentioned we couldn’t find a place we liked, this is a little ways away from us but worth the drive. I got the Sicilian pizza and let me just tell you it was amazing! The bread was so fluffy and airy and I especially loved the sausage they use. The sauce is great too! They offer a variety of beers for dine in and have some really awesome lunch specials. We will be back!"
Wendy Chavez
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
All Star Pizza is known for its authentic New York-style pizza, featuring a fluffy and airy crust. They also offer specialty pies and customizable options.
Yes, the restaurant offers a gluten-free cauliflower crust for their pizzas, which has been well-received by diners.
Besides pizza, popular items include flavorful garlic knots, hearty subs, delicious chicken wings, and mozzarella sticks.
Yes, they have attractive lunch specials that offer great value, often including pizza and a drink.
Yes, All Star Pizza has wheelchair accessible bathrooms and seating, making it inclusive for all guests.
Yes, the restaurant offers delivery services in addition to dine-in and takeout options.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best coconut creek fl Italian Food Restaurants of 2025
On our Restaurants Listings directory, you can easily find the best restaurants, and bars across coconut creek, fl. Whether you're looking for the best cup of coffee or your favorite steak, Restaurants Listings directly will help your restaurant. you will not only find the best listings for Restaurants in coconut creek, fl but you can also view customer reviews, ratings, pictures, menus on the restaurants in coconut creek, fl
Things to do in Coconut Creek with kids
Yeah thy do have pretty good pizza, we ate there few times, til we tried Amici's & its right in our area. Also anothr 3rd choiuce is All Star Pizza has delicious piuzza. But everyione has their own ideas,opinions of whats "good". Oh well ,enjoy ur pizza wherever u decide! 🍕👍🍕
The 5 Best Gluten-Free Restaurants in Coconut Creek
A sauce that is just the right consistency, and a flavor straight from Italy. I opted for the gluten free crust, which I was happy to discover was a cauliflower crust. many places.use the udi's GF crust, which is ok, but not great.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit