McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe
A beloved family restaurant & pub serving hearty American comfort food with massive portions. Known for its legendary Reuben and cozy atmosphere.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved family restaurant & pub serving hearty American comfort food with massive portions. Known for its legendary Reuben and cozy atmosphere.
"This place serves straight-up no-frills pub food, but it's tasty and well-cooked!"
Ask About Menu Details
Clarify menu items with servers upfront to ensure your order is exactly how you like it.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid busy periods for faster service. Weekdays or earlier evenings are often less crowded.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American Pub Fare
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Legendary Reuben Sandwich
The best Reuben in Erie! Loaded with corned beef and sauerkraut on hearty bread. A must-try for sandwich lovers.
Generous Portions
Don't come hungry! Expect massive servings of comfort food classics like the Turkey Rachel and fried pepperoni balls.
Cozy Atmosphere & Dual Vibes
A family-friendly dining room meets a chill neon-lit bar area. Perfect for casual dates or group outings.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Ask About Menu Details
Clarify menu items with servers upfront to ensure your order is exactly how you like it.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid busy periods for faster service. Weekdays or earlier evenings are often less crowded.
Customize Your Sandwich
Specify preferences for dressings and sauerkraut on sandwiches like the Reuben if you have particular tastes.
Explore Both Areas
Check out the family dining side and the bar area for different vibes and seating options.
Tips
from all over the internet
Ask About Menu Details
Clarify menu items with servers upfront to ensure your order is exactly how you like it.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid busy periods for faster service. Weekdays or earlier evenings are often less crowded.
Customize Your Sandwich
Specify preferences for dressings and sauerkraut on sandwiches like the Reuben if you have particular tastes.
Explore Both Areas
Check out the family dining side and the bar area for different vibes and seating options.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe is celebrated for its generous portions of delicious, homemade comfort food, with the Reuben sandwich consistently highlighted as a standout. While the food is often praised, some diners note that service can be slow or inattentive during peak hours. The atmosphere offers a split personality, with a family-friendly dining area and a more laid-back bar.
"We just ate here and had a wonderful experience thanks to our kind waitress (I forgot her name SORRY) The food was so good and homemade! We had the huge pretzel, fried pepperoni balls they were delicious. I tried the orange chicken stir fry wow that was incredible. We all shared meals as a group. Everything was so delicious, fresh, and homemade!"
Katlyn Valentine Bucci
"First time here. The food was amazing!! Our waitress was great. It’s a place we will definitely visit again."
Jessica Greaser
"This place serves straight-up no-frills pub food. I got the fried haddock, which was tasty and well cooked. It is not much to look at on the outside, but the inside is simple yet bright and clean. The service was a bit slow, but I woukd come back."
Ross Fischetti
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, it's a family-friendly restaurant with a dedicated children's menu and a welcoming atmosphere.
The restaurant is highly praised for its huge and delicious Reuben sandwich, which has been voted best in Erie.
Absolutely! Diners frequently mention the generous portion sizes, with many dishes being enough for leftovers.
Yes, takeout is available, and they even offer on-site catering.
Fried pepperoni balls, orange chicken stir fry, and the Turkey Rachel are frequently mentioned as delicious options.
The restaurant has a dual atmosphere: a light and family-friendly dining room on one side, and a chill neon-lit bar area on the other.
While not explicitly mentioned, visiting during off-peak hours is advised for quicker service due to potential busyness.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
15 Best Restaurants In Erie PA (Pennsylvania)
Take advantage of the chance to eat in this beautiful establishment, where a variety of Irish cuisine is served, along with the pleasure of fine wine. The intriguing fact you learn about this restaurant is that it has a sizable dining room that can hold many people at once. The atmosphere is very different, the location is cozy, and the lighting in the pub setup is stunning.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit