Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant
A family-run trattoria serving authentic Italian dishes from pizza to pasta in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A family-run trattoria serving authentic Italian dishes from pizza to pasta in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere.
Takeout before 3:45 PM
Visit before 3:45 PM for takeout only hours, ideal for dog owners.
Make Reservations
Consider making reservations during busy times like Valentine's Day to avoid long waits.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(910) 867-8700
Address
1400 Walter Reed Rd #130, Fayetteville, NC 28304, USA
Website
littleitalyfay.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Italian Cuisine
Savor delicious Italian pizza with fresh ingredients and authentic dishes like carbonara and lasagna.
Cozy and Welcoming Atmosphere
Relax in a cozy setting, perfect for conversations with friends and family, with a warm and inviting ambiance.
Customizable Orders
Dietary preferences are accommodated, allowing you to customize your order to suit your needs.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Takeout before 3:45 PM
Visit before 3:45 PM for takeout only hours, ideal for dog owners.
Make Reservations
Consider making reservations during busy times like Valentine's Day to avoid long waits.
Try Unique Menu Items
Sample unique items like the meatball sandwich made with freshly prepared sauce.
Enjoy the Ambiance
Dine in to experience the romantic ambiance, perfect for savoring your meal.
Tips
from all over the internet
Takeout before 3:45 PM
Visit before 3:45 PM for takeout only hours, ideal for dog owners.
Make Reservations
Consider making reservations during busy times like Valentine's Day to avoid long waits.
Try Unique Menu Items
Sample unique items like the meatball sandwich made with freshly prepared sauce.
Enjoy the Ambiance
Dine in to experience the romantic ambiance, perfect for savoring your meal.
Topping Costs
Be mindful that individual toppings may come at an additional cost.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant is praised for its delicious, authentic Italian food and welcoming atmosphere, with many highlighting fresh ingredients and friendly service. However, some diners have experienced issues with service speed and order accuracy. Despite occasional setbacks, many consider it a reliable favorite for satisfying Italian cravings.
"5/5 great food and experience!
We order pizza and you can tell they read the reviews to make improvements. Ordered two pizzas for the family and it was made on time, and they showed us the pizza before we accepted it to ensure we we're satisfied! Great topics and pizza, nice crust - overall great.
We also stopped here for our anniversary a while back and the food was great, nice italian food. The bruschetta was amazing- probably top 3 I've ever had.
Love the environment also, they were so patient when our toddler was having a tantrum and let us address it. Will return- one of our favorite and most reliable place in Fayetteville!"
Alfredo Ramirez
"Cute little spot for lunch, Stopped in after a dr. appointment. Ordered the bruschetta and it was phenomenal, 10 out 10! Dressings are house made and delicious. Husband ordered a blacken chicken salad 🥗 and I got the Italian wrap w/fries. Can't wait to go back during dinner hours to try more dishes."
Shannon Good
"Food was excellent served nice and hot the bread dip that came with the entree full of flavor...I really enjoyed the spaghetti sauce flavor and the meatballs were perfectly cooked. Our server Lane was very prompt knowledgeable of menu items and had a good personality. The fresh garlic and olive oil on the garlic knots was tasty. We will come back again."
Carolyn Worth
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Signature dishes include authentic Italian pizza, carbonara, lasagna, stuffed pies, and subs like the Italian.
Yes, takeout is available, with special hours for takeout only before 3:45 PM.
Reservations are recommended during busy periods like Valentine's Day to avoid long waits.
Yes, the restaurant offers gluten-free pizza options.
Yes, the staff is accommodating and can customize orders to suit dietary preferences, including avoiding pork.
The restaurant offers a cozy, romantic ambiance with Italian music playing, making it suitable for conversations and a relaxing meal.
Unique items include the meatball sandwich made with freshly prepared sauce and options like bruschetta.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
3 Favorite Italian Restaurants in and Around Fayetteville, NC | Valley Auto World BMW
Whether you’re in the mood for pizza, fresh pasta, fresh seafood, subs, or something else, you will find what you are looking for at Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant. If you’re feeling a cold sub for dinner, you can’t go wrong with the Italian.If you’re in the mood for a hot sandwich, the gyro is divine and the eggplant parmigiana will have you wishing you had room for a second sandwich. However, Little Italy’s pizza is its real claim to fame.
15 Best Restaurants In Fayetteville NC You Must Try
If there ever was a restaurant that looks like it should be in Italy it’s this one. This family-run trattoria serves authentic Italian entrees and Giuseppe “Joe” Scibilia, the chef and owner is committed to serving some of the best food around. The menu includes such Italian specials as Eggplant Rollatini, Veal Sorrentino over Penne Pasta, and Chicken Parmigiana.
The 7 Best Gluten-Free Lunch Spots in Douglas Byrd
The dishes are very lightly salted and the taste of tomato is pronounced in both dishes: lasagna and pizza. My children mention that they are rediscovering the taste of Italian pizza from Montreal (Canada). You have the choice of a gluten free pizza and that's great!
Restaurants near Fayetteville NC
Family owned and operated Pizzeria and Restaurant serving standard Italian fare. 30 minutes from the dropzone. Address: 1400 Walter Reed Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28304, United States
Highest-rated Italian Restaurants in Fayetteville, North Carolina by Diners
- Rating: 4.0/5 (145 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 1400 Walter Reed Road Ste 130 Fayetteville, North Carolina - Categories: Italian, Pizza- Read more on Yelp
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit