City Island Lobster House
A beloved seafood institution offering spectacular bay views, generous portions of fresh catch, and an iconic garlic bread.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
City Island Lobster House
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved seafood institution offering spectacular bay views, generous portions of fresh catch, and an iconic garlic bread.
"Dine in a picturesque setting capturing coastal living essence with the most spectacular seafood ever."
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Weekdays offer a less crowded experience with potentially better service.
Ask About the Special
The $50 special is highly recommended by servers for its freshness and value.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Seafood, American
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Spectacular Seafood Overlooking the Bay
Dine on fresh, abundant seafood with picturesque views of the Long Island Sound. Experience coastal charm.
The Famous $50 Special
A highly recommended and phenomenal value, featuring fresh clams, mussels, lobster, soup, bread, salad, and dessert.
Legendary Garlic Bread
This garlic bread is so good, it's praised by diners as being 'everything people claim' and 'just amazing'.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Weekdays offer a less crowded experience with potentially better service.
Ask About the Special
The $50 special is highly recommended by servers for its freshness and value.
Request Attentive Staff
Waitstaff like Billy and Moises are noted for providing exceptional and attentive service.
Outdoor Seating for Ambiance
Opt for a table outside or in the back for a better atmosphere and stunning waterfront views.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Weekdays offer a less crowded experience with potentially better service.
Ask About the Special
The $50 special is highly recommended by servers for its freshness and value.
Request Attentive Staff
Waitstaff like Billy and Moises are noted for providing exceptional and attentive service.
Outdoor Seating for Ambiance
Opt for a table outside or in the back for a better atmosphere and stunning waterfront views.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
City Island Lobster House is celebrated for its spectacular waterfront views and generous portions of fresh seafood, particularly its renowned lobster and legendary garlic bread. While many rave about the delicious food and attentive service, some diners have experienced issues with food temperature or table selection for optimal views. Overall, it's a highly recommended spot for a memorable seafood feast.
"Our waiterwas Moises, he was very good and attentive. The food was fresh and fulfilling. I ordered the margarita and it was the best I ever had. I don’t know what they doing back there but the whole team here was definitely on point. This will definitely be my primary choice. Next time I come to city Island."
Andrew Davila
"The service and waiters were all amazing, they definitely made our early Mother’s Day lunch an amazing time. My issue was with the food. Everything from the fries to the seafood was cold. Maybe it was a lunch time fluke. But the waiters were amazing."
Johnny Rivera
"We have been coming here for at least 25 years to get a 3 pound lobster and steamers. The outdoors restaurant is facing the bay and it’s always so beautiful to sit enjoy the view and eat the most spectacular seafood ever. Today, a Tuesday in May at noon time , all was quiet , the outdoor space closed but we were welcomed by Billy. Our server for the day who he made our lunch outing a PHENOMENAL EXPERIENCE. He told us the $50 special was a great price and everything was fresh. Clams, mussels a 1 1/25 pound lobster. Soup. Bread and salad and dessert. We said let’s do it. Will come back for the 3 pounder another time . Well. Phenomenal. Out of this world. Everything was so FRESH AND DELICIOUS. Billy was right!! Will never go back to anything else other than this special. French fries were great too. Billy even gave us an amaretto shot at the end. Best waiter ever. Thank you Billy. See you soon."
george stiros
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The $50 special is a crowd favorite, and the garlic bread is legendary. Many also praise the fresh lobster and calamari.
Yes, the restaurant offers outdoor seating overlooking the water, which is highly recommended for the atmosphere.
It's a highly recommended deal that typically includes clams, mussels, lobster, soup, bread, salad, and dessert.
While not guaranteed, requesting servers like Billy or Moises is recommended for exceptional service.
Yes, they offer a children's menu with kid-friendly options.
Some guests have reported difficulty securing waterfront tables, with policies varying based on group size.
Yes, a $50 special is frequently recommended for its value and delicious seafood offerings.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best Restaurants On the Water in NYC: Waterfront Restaurants and Bars
City Island -- only .5 mile wide and 1.5 miles long -- is like a miniature New England, right in the Northeastern Bronx. With Victorian homes, a small-town feel, and super-fresh seafood, you can take the 6 to the last stop, transfer to the BX 29, and immediately forget that you’re in the five boroughs. Order the $47 lobster (it’s served whole, with steak, spare ribs, or fried shrimp) at City Island Lobster House and pretend you’re on vacation.
10 City Island Restaurants Well Worth the Trip
The City Island Lobster House, at 691 Bridge Street, is a very popular and touristy seafood restaurant on the north of City Island. Overlooking the Long Island Sound, the eatery is easily visible with its vibrant sign that can be seen by the new City Island Bridge. The eatery features a Hemmingway Room with velvet-backed booths and an outdoor terrace overlooking the restaurant’s own marina.The rather expensive eatery features a vast selection of freshly caught seafood options ranging from mahi-mahi to Chilean sea bass to halibut.
Visit the Top 10 Restaurants in Bronx New York
City Island Lobster House is a true haven for seafood enthusiasts, located on the picturesque City Island. Known for its fresh catch and stunning waterfront views, this restaurant offers a delightful dining experience that captures the essence of coastal living. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch or a special dinner, City Island Lobster House delivers a memorable culinary journey.
Kid-Friendly Waterfront Restaurants in NYC for Dinner with a View - Mommy Poppins
If you haven't been to City Island, now is the perfect time to go. You'll feel like you're in New York City, but strangely also not, on this little island nestled at the north end of the Bronx. City Island Lobster House is right after you cross the bridge, so you don't have to sit in traffic on the one-lane road on a popular summer weekend.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit