Big Apple Bagels
A beloved spot for authentic East Coast-style bagels and creative sandwiches, offering quick and friendly service for any time of day.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Big Apple Bagels
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved spot for authentic East Coast-style bagels and creative sandwiches, offering quick and friendly service for any time of day.
"Experience the deliciousness of authentic East Coast bagels and flavorful sandwiches!"
Arrive Early for Best Selection
Get your favorite bagels fresh and hot; popular choices can sell out quickly.
Card Fees May Apply
Be aware of potential card fees when paying, especially for smaller purchases.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Bagel Shop
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic East Coast-Style Bagels
Experience genuinely East Coast-style bagels, a rare find that locals and visitors rave about.
Delicious Bagel Sandwiches
From the 'Holey Guacamole' pizza bagel to hearty breakfast sandwiches, these are packed with flavor.
Friendly and Efficient Service
Enjoy quick service and a welcoming staff that makes grabbing a bite a pleasant experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Arrive Early for Best Selection
Get your favorite bagels fresh and hot; popular choices can sell out quickly.
Card Fees May Apply
Be aware of potential card fees when paying, especially for smaller purchases.
Check Availability
If you have a specific favorite bagel, it's wise to call ahead as availability can vary.
Loyalty Program Frustrations
The rewards program has changed multiple times, making loyalty accumulation difficult.
Tips
from all over the internet
Arrive Early for Best Selection
Get your favorite bagels fresh and hot; popular choices can sell out quickly.
Card Fees May Apply
Be aware of potential card fees when paying, especially for smaller purchases.
Check Availability
If you have a specific favorite bagel, it's wise to call ahead as availability can vary.
Loyalty Program Frustrations
The rewards program has changed multiple times, making loyalty accumulation difficult.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Big Apple Bagels is praised for its authentic East Coast-style bagels and delicious sandwich creations, making it a go-to spot for breakfast. While many appreciate the friendly and quick service, some customers have expressed frustration with frequent changes to the loyalty program and occasional issues with ingredient quality or value. Overall, the bagels themselves are a consistent highlight, though potential upcharges and service inconsistencies are noted.
"Small dine in place. Got our bagel sandwich to go. Holey guacamole pizza bagel sandwich was great!
If you use a card, they will charge you a card fee. My fee was 38¢ for my $10 sandwich."
Ashley K
"Overall good breakfast experience, I have enjoyed all of the bagels I’ve tried there including the pizza bagel, cheddar bacon, garlic, and french toast. The only thing is that sometimes they run out of the poplar bagels early. So, if you show up in the afternoon your choices are limited."
Lily B
"I love this place. However, the older lady that works there currently is terrible. Ive been coming in since i was a kid. I always ask for a large cup for water and the older lady always tries to charge me for the cup of water. I just want a cup with a lid for water. I dont know why i would have to pay $4 for a cup with a lid. This makes me not want to go back."
Crystal Morinelli
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Customers frequently rave about the Asiago, strawberry, cheddar bacon, garlic, and french toast bagels. It's best to arrive early for the widest selection.
Currently, Big Apple Bagels does not offer gluten-free options, which is a noted limitation for customers with allergies.
Yes, some customers have reported a small card fee being added to their bill, particularly for smaller purchases.
Service is generally described as friendly and quick, ideal for grab-and-go. However, some reviews mention issues with specific staff members or chaotic ordering processes.
They are noted for providing authentic East Coast-style bagels, which are hard to find elsewhere and are consistently fresh and delicious.
Yes, a rewards program is available, but some customers find it frustrating due to frequent changes and previous purchases not transferring.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
BEST Bubble-tea Near Green Bay in 2025 – Doordash
Icespresso Java Chip tasted just like a Frappuccino from Starbucks! Will def order again!! This was my first time ordering from here and the bagel was bigger than expected and so delicious! I will for sure be trying more items soon.". "The bagels here are so fresh and addicting. And because they're open in the morning, they're a great choice for breakfast! Try their Chai Latte, it's perfectly spiced!". Bagel & Cream Cheese
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit