Mr. Nick's Restaurant
A beloved Italian eatery in Tarrytown, offering authentic pizza, pasta, and warm hospitality in a relaxed setting.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Mr. Nick's Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved Italian eatery in Tarrytown, offering authentic pizza, pasta, and warm hospitality in a relaxed setting.
Ask for Recommendations
Staff are accommodating and happy to help you choose from the extensive menu.
Parking Convenience
Street parking and nearby lots offer convenient options within walking distance.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Italian Flavors
Savor classic Italian dishes from fresh pasta to authentic Brooklyn-style pizza, all made with care.
Brooklyn Pizza in Tarrytown
Experience the taste of genuine Brooklyn pizza right in Tarrytown, a true local favorite.
Warm & Welcoming Atmosphere
Enjoy a relaxed dining experience with top-notch service from friendly employees and owners.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Ask for Recommendations
Staff are accommodating and happy to help you choose from the extensive menu.
Parking Convenience
Street parking and nearby lots offer convenient options within walking distance.
Enjoy the Ambiance
Consider dining indoors for a great food and atmosphere experience.
Try the Passionfruit Margarita
A delightful drink option that's highly recommended by patrons.
Tips
from all over the internet
Ask for Recommendations
Staff are accommodating and happy to help you choose from the extensive menu.
Parking Convenience
Street parking and nearby lots offer convenient options within walking distance.
Enjoy the Ambiance
Consider dining indoors for a great food and atmosphere experience.
Try the Passionfruit Margarita
A delightful drink option that's highly recommended by patrons.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Mr. Nick's is celebrated for its fresh, homemade Italian food, especially its pizza and pasta dishes, with many praising the attentive and friendly service. The restaurant offers a warm atmosphere, making it suitable for various occasions from family meals to solo dining. While generally well-loved, some reviews touch upon past staff changes and the need for better customer service training for owners.
"My goodness, what a wonderful restaurant! The wine was so good, the food was amazing, everything so home made to perfection. Best cheesecake I’ve ever had. Best pizza I’ve ever had. Best mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had! 100% worth the money."
Elizabeth Carney
"Mr. Nick's is an absolute gem of an Italian eatery!!! Mr. Nick himself is an outstanding gentleman And always offers a warm smile and hospitality!! His staff are very attentive and helpful in navigating the menu andi cannot say enough to great things about his establishment!!!! Outstanding Service is an understatement!!! I ordered the Lasagna Pizza and It was hot and fresh and delicious!!!! See picture... One word comes to mind with this pizza....Capolavoro...which means masterpiece in Italian!!!!"
Jason Thomas
"Nick’s is a great restaurant with fresh pizza and Italian food. They also have a full bar and plenty of nice seating in the back area. Nick’s is perfect for family meals, large groups, or dining solo. You can’t go wrong with the pastas, pizza, and the rest of the menu here. Chicken Scarpiello and Chicken Martini during dinner time is amazing! They have great vegetarian pastas here. I highly recommend Nick’s. Enjoy!"
Phil P.
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Mr. Nick's offers a wide range of Italian favorites, including fresh wraps, authentic Brooklyn-style pizza, and delicious pasta dishes like Sicilian Ziti.
Yes, parking can be found nearby on the street or in parking lots within walking distance of the restaurant.
Absolutely! The staff and owners are very accommodating and happy to provide recommendations from their extensive menu.
Yes, the restaurant features a full bar with a selection of drinks, including a highly recommended passionfruit margarita.
Many reviewers consider Mr. Nick's a great place for family meals, with options for various dietary preferences.
Yes, the menu includes great vegetarian pasta options.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
A Coalescing of Crawls Boosts Local Bars-and a Bookstore
About a hundred competitors, most of them in out-of-season Halloween costumes, made the rounds of the two villages’ watering holes, including the Tapp on North Broadway where the idea was conceived by manager Sarah Haase, Horsefeathers, The Cube Inn, Mr. Nick’s and J.P. Doyle’s on Sleepy Hollow’s Beekman Street. At each stop, participants were greeted with libations, trivia questions and assignments to find clues in places ranging from the obvious to the obscure.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit