Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge
An elegant eatery serving Italian, Greek, and Caribbean cuisine with waterfront views and white tablecloths for special occasions.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge
Highlights
Must-see attractions
An elegant eatery serving Italian, Greek, and Caribbean cuisine with waterfront views and white tablecloths for special occasions.
Reserve Your Table
Secure your spot, especially on busy nights, by making reservations in advance.
Balcony & Deck Views
Opt for balcony seating for romance or the deck for canal views. Consider the quieter dining area.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Greek, Caribbean, Continental
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Diverse International Menu
Savor a global culinary journey with Italian, Greek, Caribbean, and Continental dishes.
Romantic Waterfront Dining
Enjoy breathtaking canal views from the deck or a romantic experience on the balcony.
Celebratory White Tablecloth Dining
Mark special occasions in an elegant white tablecloth dining room with top-notch service.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Reserve Your Table
Secure your spot, especially on busy nights, by making reservations in advance.
Balcony & Deck Views
Opt for balcony seating for romance or the deck for canal views. Consider the quieter dining area.
Try the Specials
If fresh yellowtail is available, it's highly recommended. Shrimp with scallops in Thai sauce also praised.
Explore the Bar Menu
The bar menu offers additional food listings alongside excellent pizza and Espresso Martinis.
Tips
from all over the internet
Reserve Your Table
Secure your spot, especially on busy nights, by making reservations in advance.
Balcony & Deck Views
Opt for balcony seating for romance or the deck for canal views. Consider the quieter dining area.
Try the Specials
If fresh yellowtail is available, it's highly recommended. Shrimp with scallops in Thai sauce also praised.
Explore the Bar Menu
The bar menu offers additional food listings alongside excellent pizza and Espresso Martinis.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Old Tavernier is lauded for its diverse menu, offering a range of Italian, Greek, and Continental dishes, with many praising the friendly service and pleasant atmosphere. While some find the food delicious and portions generous, others have noted issues with presentation and value, with one reviewer mentioning a dog disruption during their meal.
"We had dinner on a weekday night in early December. The restaurant has nice waterfront views but we ate well past sunset so everything was already dark.
We had a wonderful dining experience. Terrific ambiance, a nice menu, good portions, reasonable prices, and outstanding service. Kudos to our server Mario, who was super accommodating of food allergies and preferences, and made sure we had a great dining experience.
We enjoyed the yellow tail snapper, and also the shrimp with scallops in Thai sauce for dinner. The chocolate cake for dessert was wonderful.
This is a first rate restaurant with great food and service. We will definitely return the next time we vacation in the area."
Steve X
"Caesar salad was good, a little plain however. Food lacked presentation but made up for it in taste. We got the Chicken and Shrimp Al Mare ($28) and the shrimp scampi ($28) and two drinks ($6). The dishes were quite delicious! It has a nice older and dim atmosphere and good variation of items on their menu 🕯️"
Amber Ender
"Another Islamorada original. Good food served in a dining room with real linen tablecloths! Brie was attentive, fun and arranged things exactly as we wanted!"
Kevin Schmidt
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Old Tavernier offers a diverse menu featuring Italian, Greek, Caribbean, and Continental dishes, with homemade preparations and imported olive oil.
Yes, outdoor seating is available on the balcony and deck, offering romantic experiences and canal views.
Yes, they are known for delicious cocktails, including a famous espresso martini.
The restaurant is accommodating of food allergies and preferences, but it's best to confirm specific needs when booking.
Highly recommended dishes include coconut encrusted yellowtail snapper, shrimp with scallops in Thai sauce, and prime rib. The pizza is also a favorite.
Absolutely. The white tablecloth dining room is a popular choice for celebrating anniversaries, birthdays, and other special occasions.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Old Tavernier 675 reviews Closed Now Italian, American $$ - $$$ Menu 1.5 mi Key Largo “Very nice dinner spot in Key Largo” “... I needed a nice dinner with some cl...” 2022 2. … global gruppe versicherung The Best 10 Restaurants near Tavernier, FL 33070 - Yelp KRUST pizza & pies Tavernier, FL 33070 - Restaurantji WebTavernier Restaurants Restaurants in Tavernier View map Sort by: Highest Rating We found great results, but some are outside Tavernier.
Top 10 Islamorada Restaurants
Old Tavernier is a local favorite and has a very diverse menu, Italian, Greek, Caribbean and Continental. Everything is homemade, fresh baked goods daily, food prepared with imported extra virgin olive oil from the family’s grove located in Southern Greece. Many an anniversary, birthday and special occasion is celebrated by locals and family in the white tablecloth dining room of Old Tavernier.
Tavernier Restaurant Guide
An elegant restaurant serving chef prepared Surf and Turf, stuffed lobster, Chicken Florentine, seafood pasta, duck with cranberry sauce, Greek style whole yellowtail snapper and extravagant desserts on crisp white tablecloths. Top notch service and an extensive wine list round out the experience.
Best Restaurants in Tavernier, Florida
This was the best meal in the keys!! We have been coming to the Keys for more that 10 years, and this meal is without a question the best. We had appetizers and a lobster thermodore and finished wi...
15 Best Restaurants in Islamorada, FL for 2025 (Top Eats!)
90311 Old HwyTavernier, FL 33070(305) 852-6012 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. The Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge is a terrific restaurant specializing in Italian and Greek cuisine.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit