Caplinger's Fresh Catch
A family-run fish market and cafe serving over 150 years of combined experience, offering fresh seafood, unique dishes like alligator, and celebrated ...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Caplinger's Fresh Catch
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A family-run fish market and cafe serving over 150 years of combined experience, offering fresh seafood, unique dishes like alligator, and celebrated lobster rolls.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long waits by visiting during non-peak times, though expect some busyness even then.
Don't Miss the Lobsta Roll
Their Almost Famous lobsta roll is a must-try, bringing a taste of Maine to Indiana.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Seafood
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(317) 288-7263
Address
7460 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46250, USA
Website
caplingersfreshcatch.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Juicy & Tender Catfish Nuggets
Experience perfectly cooked catfish nuggets that are juicy, tender, and delightfully crunchy. A true taste of perfection!
Almost Famous Lobster Roll
Savor a taste of Maine with their renowned lobster roll, packed with fresh lobster and a perfect remoulade.
Extensive Fresh Fish Selection
Explore a wide variety of fresh seafood options available by the pound, from local catches to exotic finds.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long waits by visiting during non-peak times, though expect some busyness even then.
Don't Miss the Lobsta Roll
Their Almost Famous lobsta roll is a must-try, bringing a taste of Maine to Indiana.
Ask for Side Recommendations
Highly recommended sides include okra and green beans, perfect complements to your meal.
Consider the Caplinger Special
The Caplinger Special Dinner offers Basa fish pieces with hush puppies and two sides.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid long waits by visiting during non-peak times, though expect some busyness even then.
Don't Miss the Lobsta Roll
Their Almost Famous lobsta roll is a must-try, bringing a taste of Maine to Indiana.
Ask for Side Recommendations
Highly recommended sides include okra and green beans, perfect complements to your meal.
Consider the Caplinger Special
The Caplinger Special Dinner offers Basa fish pieces with hush puppies and two sides.
Credit Card Surcharge Warning
Be aware of a potential surcharge for credit card use; inquire about cash pricing upfront.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Caplinger's Fresh Catch is lauded for its incredibly juicy and tender catfish nuggets, excellent lobster roll, and a wide array of fresh seafood options. Customers frequently praise the friendly service and the generous portion sizes of both main dishes and sides. However, some reviews mention concerns about the walleye being pricey, and a few diners have noted issues with cross-contamination in the fry oil and a credit card surcharge.
"My goodness....This is the first restaurant here in Central Indiana that's worth dining at. My catfish nuggets were so juicy and tender yet crunchy and flavorful, not overcooked and hard, just perfect. I'm savoring every bite of it 😋. Even the sides were super delicious. I highly recommend the okra and the green beans. I will definitely be back again. My meal was worth every penny plus more. Brought back good childhood memories 😌 And the customer service was excellent! All around 5 stars!"
Theresa
"We purchased a certificate from Fox 59 and finally made it here before it expired. I was not aware of how many different options they had. I didn't look at the menu before coming. The staff was all very pleasant and patient while I decided what to order. I ordered the fish and chicken meal. I was excited I could get the chicken grilled and the fish fried. Everything we ordered was AMAZING! Can't wait to go back!"
Christina Thompson
"Our food was tasty, my walleye fillets didn't smell fishy at all, they gave big portions of sides as well. A lot of fresh sea/lake products here are very interesting. The place feels clean too, definitely recommended if you feel like eating fresh seafood"
Soleil
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The juicy and tender catfish nuggets and the 'Almost Famous' lobster roll are highly recommended by patrons. Many also rave about the crab cakes and clam chowder.
Yes, they offer chicken and pork tenderloins, but be aware that all items are fried in the same oil, which may be a concern for those with strict dietary needs.
Absolutely! Caplinger's Fresh Catch is also a fish market, offering a wide selection of fresh fish by the pound to take home.
It's recommended to visit during off-peak hours. While it can still be busy, the wait times are generally shorter.
Some customers have noted a surcharge for using credit cards. It's advisable to inquire about cash pricing upfront to avoid surprises.
Patrons highly recommend the okra and green beans as excellent side dish choices. Hush puppies are also a popular accompaniment.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The Best Markets In Indianapolis
This seafood market provides many fresh water delicacies that include lobster, octopus, clams, alligator, colossal king crab and more. Caplinger’s Fresh Catch is a family-owned business that has over 150 years of combined experience among their staff.
27 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis in
Nick Caplinger, Andrew’s father, and business partner, previously operated the 56th Street Fish Market. In 2017, the restaurant was named one of the top twenty-five places to get a lobster roll in the country!. The Caplinger’s Special is the restaurant’s number one selling sandwich served with fried or grilled fish.
Indy's 50 Best Restaurants
Great seafood doesn’t have to be expensive, and Caplingers serves it for the people daily. You can get fancy with a dozen oysters on the half shell, or a fried whitefish sandwich, plus a fish market so you can take home some seafood for DIY cooking.
50 Best Restaurants in Indianapolis, IN for 2025 (Top Eats!)
7460 Shadeland AveIndianapolis, IN 46250(317) 288-7263 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Caplinger’s Fresh Catch is a family-run fish market and cafe in Cranbrook Center that serves a variety of seafood, sandwiches, and side dishes.
Highest-rated Seafood Restaurants in Indianapolis by Diners
- Rating: 4.3/5 (858 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 7460 North Shadeland Ave. Indianapolis, Indiana - Categories: seafood markets, seafood- Read more on Yelp
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit