Coal Yard Cafe
A quaint neighborhood cafe in Ithaca, Coal Yard Cafe offers delicious breakfast and lunch with unique dishes and specialty coffee in a cozy, rustic se...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Coal Yard Cafe
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A quaint neighborhood cafe in Ithaca, Coal Yard Cafe offers delicious breakfast and lunch with unique dishes and specialty coffee in a cozy, rustic setting.
Avoid Peak Hours
Visit during off-peak times to minimize wait times for your food.
Consider Takeout
If seating is limited, taking your food to go is a viable option.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Quack Jacks
Johnny cake pancakes topped with perfectly cooked duck breast and drizzled with balsamic reduction.
Cozy & Inviting Atmosphere
A warm, neighborhood cafe with rustic decor, leather chairs, and an electric fireplace.
Unique Coffee Creations
Beyond traditional espresso, explore intriguing coffee drinks like the orange-flavored cafe niro.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Avoid Peak Hours
Visit during off-peak times to minimize wait times for your food.
Consider Takeout
If seating is limited, taking your food to go is a viable option.
Outdoor Seating
Enjoy a more relaxed experience by opting for outdoor seating, especially in warmer weather.
Explore Coffee Menu
Don't miss their unique coffee drinks alongside traditional espresso options.
Tips
from all over the internet
Avoid Peak Hours
Visit during off-peak times to minimize wait times for your food.
Consider Takeout
If seating is limited, taking your food to go is a viable option.
Outdoor Seating
Enjoy a more relaxed experience by opting for outdoor seating, especially in warmer weather.
Explore Coffee Menu
Don't miss their unique coffee drinks alongside traditional espresso options.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Coal Yard Cafe is celebrated for its cozy atmosphere and unique, flavorful dishes like the signature Quack Jacks. Diners love the creative menu and specialty coffee drinks. However, some reviews mention small portion sizes and a less-than-ideal service experience when it comes to tipping, with occasional instances of food being served in takeout containers even when dining in.
"Its a VERY small place but it packs a punch with flavor and kindness. I had the crepes with berries and they were delicious. Seating can be hard to come by but once you're in you get a menu and order at the counter and they will bring your dish out. I walked out and left my purse on the chair and a kind fella chased me down. Would definitely stop again."
Patricia Coughlin
"The food left a lot to be desired. Not a lot of flavor and the portion sizes were small. I felt there was more volume in the cup of coffee than the food. Also kinda disappointed to have it served in a take out container even though we were eating in the Cafe."
Amanda Gorges
"Expect to get judged if you don’t pay tips for nonexistent service! There was one time I ordered a coffee to go and didn’t pay tips, because I ordered at the counter and waited right there to pick up myself (It’s not like they took my order at the table and had to bring it to me and clean the table after me or anything.) Before the barista made my coffee, she was exchanging eye contact with the cashier. The cashier was frowning and waving her hand under the counter, which I assumed signaling her that I didn’t pay tips. The barista rolled her eyes, made the coffee, gave it to me with a terribly unpleased look and didn’t say a word. The worst experience ever!
Though I liked their sweet potato hash from previous visits, I have never visited this place since then."
Mengting Huang
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The cafe is known for its unique dishes like the 'Quack Jacks' (pancakes with duck breast), flavorful breakfast and lunch options, and interesting coffee creations in a cozy atmosphere.
The cafe serves breakfast and lunch. It's recommended to check their specific operating hours before visiting, as they are a smaller establishment.
The place is described as very small, so seating can be hard to come by, especially during peak hours. Visiting during off-peak times or considering takeout is advised. +1
While not explicitly detailed in the provided data, the menu does mention 'gluten-free' as an option for some dishes. It's best to inquire directly about specific dietary needs. [^data]
Yes, the cafe offers outdoor seating, which can provide a more relaxed dining experience, especially during warmer weather. [^M1, ^R5]
The atmosphere is often described as cozy, warm, inviting, and like a grandmother's living room, with rustic decor and a comfortable neighborhood feel. [^M3, ^M6]
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
where to eat in Ithaca, NY
The Coal Yard Cafe in Trumansburg is a sweet little breakfast spot with a walk up take out window, and a new pop up stand that just opened on Ithaca’s West End Inlet Island, and Allechant has lunch and Sunday brunch curbside pickup as well as charming outdoor table service in warmer weather. Creekside Cafe in Trumansburg has a lovely brunch menu - seating is limited so call ahead, or grab takeout and take it to a park.
Breakfast & Brunch in Ithaca, NY
Tucked away in a neighborhood near Cornell, you’ll find an enticing food menu with a variety of specialty coffee drinks. Here, you will not be limited to traditional breakfast fare, be sure to look at their lunch menu and sandwiches during your next brunch. Local Pick: Spice up your morning by ordering the Ranch Eggs or take a sweeter route and order the Ithaca Mudd off the drink menu.
A Quick Guide to (Some of) the Best Brunch Spots in Ithaca
The best way to describe this tiny café is by saying that it’s probably like your grandmother’s living room. Warm, fresh home-cooked meals are served to you as you wait in a small, cozy room with an electric fireplace. Though I might be a bit biased, as it’s my personal favorite and go-to Ithacan brunch spot, Coal Yard provides a lot that none of the other brunch spots can offer.
12 Best Restaurants in Ithaca, NY [2024 Updated]
Mouthwatering omelets, scrambles, and breakfast sandwiches – need we say more?. The Coal Yard Cafe is a popular stop for its variety of savory, filling, and unique morning fare. With its location’s long and storied history – for many years, the building housed businesses that sold coal to Ithaca residents – the setting is as unique as the menu.
Best Afternoon Tea in Ithaca, NY: Top 19!
143 Maple Ave, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA(607) 277-0734 View Menu Open in Google Maps. Nestled on Maple Ave in Ithaca, NY, Coal Yard Cafe is a charming haven for coffee enthusiasts and food lovers alike. As soon as you step inside, the aroma of freshly brewed coffee envelops you, promising a delightful experience ahead.
The 5 Best Places To Grab A Coffee In Ithaca
What was once was a coal yard back in the day, the Coal Yard Cafe has since transformed into a quaint spot in Ithaca for breakfast, lunch and—of course—coffee. Leather chairs, a cast iron fireplace, and rustic decor make Coal Yard your comfortable and cozy neighborhood cafe.
Highest-rated Restaurants in Ithaca by Diners
- Rating: 4.1/5 (138 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 143 Maple Ave. Ithaca, New York - Categories: Coffee & Tea, Breakfast & Brunch, New American- Read more on Yelp
Best breakfast spots?! : ithaca
Cafe Dewitt, Lincoln Street Diner, Carriage House Cafe, MIX, Sunset Grill, State Street Diner, Coal yard cafe, Waffle Frolic, for some options
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit