Pienezza Pizza
A quaint Kissimmee pizza joint serving authentic New York-style pies, from classic cheese to unique creations. A true hidden gem for pizza lovers.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Pienezza Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A quaint Kissimmee pizza joint serving authentic New York-style pies, from classic cheese to unique creations. A true hidden gem for pizza lovers.
"The wait can be long, but it's worth it for the delicious pizza."
Avoid Weekday Crowds
Visit on weekdays to bypass the crowds; Tuesday evenings can still be busy.
Seating is Limited
Consider takeout or dining in early due to limited seating inside the restaurant.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza, Vegan
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic New York Style Pizza
Experience genuine New York style slices with flavorful sauce and crispy crusts. From classic cheese to unique options, it's a taste of the Big Apple.
Grandma's Pizza Perfection
Savor Grandma's pizza, renowned for its crispy crust and exceptionally flavorful sauce. A must-try for pizza aficionados.
Unique 'Italian Flag' Pie
Indulge in the visually stunning 'Italian flag' pie, boasting exceptional pesto and a delightful combination of flavors.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Avoid Weekday Crowds
Visit on weekdays to bypass the crowds; Tuesday evenings can still be busy.
Seating is Limited
Consider takeout or dining in early due to limited seating inside the restaurant.
Garlic Sensitivity
Be cautious with raw garlic on pizzas if you're sensitive to strong flavors.
Plan for the Wait
The wait can be long, but many find the delicious pizza worth it.
Tips
from all over the internet
Avoid Weekday Crowds
Visit on weekdays to bypass the crowds; Tuesday evenings can still be busy.
Seating is Limited
Consider takeout or dining in early due to limited seating inside the restaurant.
Garlic Sensitivity
Be cautious with raw garlic on pizzas if you're sensitive to strong flavors.
Plan for the Wait
The wait can be long, but many find the delicious pizza worth it.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Pienezza Pizza is widely celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizzas, with many hailing it as the best in the area. Patrons rave about the quality ingredients, flavorful sauce, and perfectly crispy crusts, particularly praising the Sicilian and Grandma's pizzas. While the food garners high praise, some customers have noted significant wait times and occasional issues with service, though many agree the exceptional pizza makes it worthwhile.
"Pienezza Pizza is hands down one of the best spots in town! Not only do they have amazing pizza, but they’ve recently started offering New York-style bagel breakfast sandwiches, and they’re incredible. The bagels are made fresh, and you can really taste the difference. As a New Yorker living in Florida, I’ve missed that authentic bagel flavor, and Pienezza absolutely nailed it. If you’re looking for a delicious start to your day or just craving a great bagel sandwich, this is the place to go. Highly recommend!"
Pamela Mena
"Ordered the plain grandma, and was not disappointed. Good quality cheese and sauce with a strong garlic flavor (which I like). The crust edges were crisp, really nice chew. Good looking crumb, slightly dense. Overall, great pie, especially for Orlando - this may be the best."
Rishi Malhotra (PizzaKong)
"Pizza was delicious! We got 2 Sicilian pizzas and they were so good! Only issue was that one had all of the toppings stuck to the top. Restaurant was clean and they were very welcoming. Will definitely go again"
Brandi S
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Pienezza is praised for its authentic New York-style slices with a perfect crust, flavorful sauce, and quality cheese. Many reviewers compare it favorably to pizzas from New York.
Yes, Pienezza is noted as a vegan restaurant and offers vegan options, including vegan pizzas.
The Grandma's pizza and Sicilian pizza are frequently recommended for their delicious taste and crispy crusts. The 'Italian flag' pie with pesto is also a unique favorite.
The restaurant assures customers that they take proper precautions to ensure safety for those with gluten allergies, and their gluten-free pizza is highly rated.
While the pizza is highly rated, be prepared for potentially long wait times, especially during peak hours. Some suggest takeout or dining early.
Yes, they also offer appetizers, calzones, strombolis, and even New York-style bagel breakfast sandwiches.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
19 Best Restaurants in Kissimmee You Can't Miss
Pienezza has unanimously been rated the best New York Style Pizzarea in the Kissimmee and surrounding area. Pienezza is a quaint business with only three tables, two outdoor tables, and two larger bar areas, but the pizza is to die for, so it is worth the wait and worth a try if you happen to be in the Kissimmee area. Pienezza has also been charted as one of the best restaurants to travel to if you are searching for something different outside of your regular hometown cuisine.
The Top 9 Pizza Shop Recommendations in Kissimmee
Pienezza Pizza has a sign on the wall of its restaurant that says, "The best pizza is the one we share." And we couldn't agree more!. With its birthplace in the Italian community in New York, the act of coming together as a family to share food is at the heart of this restaurant. And their pies reflect this heritage, with names like Hey Brooklyn, NY White Pie, and Mama's Lasagne
Famous Restaurants in Kissimmee, Florida
If you are looking for delicious pizza in Kissimmee, head to Pienezza. This is a family run New York style pizzeria. Located off of John Young Parkway they are closed Mondays, but open for lunch and dinner Tuesday to Sunday.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit