
Caldwell House Restaurant
A charming, chef-owned log cabin eatery offering superb steaks, seafood, martinis, and homemade desserts in an intimate mountain setting.

Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Caldwell House Restaurant

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A charming, chef-owned log cabin eatery offering superb steaks, seafood, martinis, and homemade desserts in an intimate mountain setting.
"Experience a memorable meal with superb surf-and-turf and exceptional service in a cozy log cabin atmosphere."
Weekend Reservations Recommended
Book ahead for weekend visits, as this popular restaurant can quickly become busy.
Early Bird Specials
Take advantage of great deals on the early bird menu, available before 5:30 PM.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
$$$
Phone
(518) 668-2211
Address
1809 US-9, Lake George, NY 12845, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Cozy Log Cabin Ambiance
Experience a warm, intimate dining atmosphere in a historic 1940s log cabin, perfect for any season.

Superb Surf-and-Turf
Indulge in high-quality steak and seafood dishes, with prime rib and scallops being popular highlights.

Signature Martinis & Homemade Desserts
Enjoy a wide selection of martinis and delightful homemade desserts to complement your meal.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Weekend Reservations Recommended
Book ahead for weekend visits, as this popular restaurant can quickly become busy.
Early Bird Specials
Take advantage of great deals on the early bird menu, available before 5:30 PM.
Cozy Winter Dining
Visit during colder months for a particularly warm and inviting mountain cabin dining experience.
Attentive Service
Expect friendly and attentive staff, with servers like Nikia and Angela often praised for their excellent service.
Tips
from all over the internet
Weekend Reservations Recommended
Book ahead for weekend visits, as this popular restaurant can quickly become busy.
Early Bird Specials
Take advantage of great deals on the early bird menu, available before 5:30 PM.
Cozy Winter Dining
Visit during colder months for a particularly warm and inviting mountain cabin dining experience.
Attentive Service
Expect friendly and attentive staff, with servers like Nikia and Angela often praised for their excellent service.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Caldwell House Restaurant is celebrated for its cozy, high-end log cabin ambiance and superb surf-and-turf cuisine, particularly the prime rib. Guests frequently commend the attentive service and signature martinis. However, some diners have experienced inconsistencies with food preparation and value for money, with occasional remarks on dishes not meeting expectations.
"We had an amazing experience at this steak house! It had a great atmosphere, delicious food and very friendly staff. Nikia was our server and she is probably the best waitress I have ever met, she was very positive, very attentive and made great recommendations for our whole family. Definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a great meal and a wonderful experience."
V A
"We went for my birthday Dinner. Food was not very good. Prime rib was old reheat, Crab legs were over priced, rice was horrible and baby carrots still had white on them. Lamb was good. Mashed potatoes were just smashed reds. We don't think they had any butter or cream in them. Stuffed shrimp were filled with plain old bread crumbs. French onion was ok. Drinks were good. Very expensive. Pass on this place. We won't be going back. 😔"
Jeffrey Curtin
"Visited the area from Indiana. The restaurant was adorable. The waitress was excellent. The food was “interesting.” Husband ordered sirloin, med rare and it was cooked well done. A bit dry. His lobster was good. I ordered the pork shank with blackberry glaze. I couldn’t eat it nor the mashed potatoes due to the glaze over them which did not compliment anything. And the onion rings over everything was a no for me. Our friends, 1 ordered a chicken pasta dish which was just ok. The other ordered t-bone and it was fine, cooked according to the request. Salads were good, bread was very bland. The crackers and spread were delicious. All of the drinks were spot on. I’d say it’s a gamble to eat here which was so disappointing since it had all the ingredients to make for an excellent experience."
Debi Brady
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Reservations are suggested for weekends as the restaurant is quite popular and can get busy.
Popular choices include superb surf-and-turf, prime rib, scallops, signature martinis, and homemade desserts.
Yes, they offer an early bird menu with great deals available before 5:30 PM.
The restaurant is housed in a cozy, high-end log cabin with a warm and intimate atmosphere, especially inviting during colder months.
The restaurant does offer vegetarian and vegan options on its menu.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Top Things to Do in Lake George, NY
Caldwell House Restaurant & Martini Bar is a cozy but high-end log cabin restaurant within the village, touted by locals and visitors as some of the best food and service in the area. Superb surf-and-turf cuisine is what you can expect at this restaurant, also featuring a signature martini selection, and homemade desserts. (reservations suggested for weekends)
Best Lake George Restaurants For Special Occasions
Travel back in time when you visit this chef-owned establishment set in a 1940s log cabin. This is a great option for a cozy, more casual date with no loss in quality of food or service. The scallops and steak dishes are among the most popular menu mainstays, and guests comment on the lovely fireplace and extensive martini menu!
Lake George restaurants, bars, and diners from TripAdvisor
The Caldwell House Restaurant serves American food and is open for dinner. The restaurant has vegetarian and vegan options. Top review: “Last night we went to the Chateau at Bolton Landing it was sub-par to say the least.
THE BEST 5 American Restaurants in Warren County (Updated April 2025)
Everything was pretty tasty, cooked well, and served in a timely manner. The cracker platter had an enjoyable dip, the bread was warm and soft. Lobster Mac n Cheese was filling as was the Prime Rib.
15 Best Restaurants in Lake George, NY for 2025 (Top Eats!)
1809 US-9Lake George, NY 12845(518) 668-2211 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Caldwell House is an intimate, chef-owned American restaurant offering dinner specials in an intimate space.
Top 10 Restaurants You Must Try Near Lake George
Casual, family-friendly, and loaded with comfort food This no-frills spot is known for its generous breakfasts, classic sandwiches, and homestyle dinners.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit