Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant
Experience old-world Italian charm in a rustic lodge with unique taxidermy and cozy ambiance. Famous for wood-fired pizzas and gluten-free options.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Experience old-world Italian charm in a rustic lodge with unique taxidermy and cozy ambiance. Famous for wood-fired pizzas and gluten-free options.
"Step into a unique lodge atmosphere and savor delicious Italian fare, especially the wood-fired pizzas!"
Timing is Everything
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid long wait times and ensure a smoother dining experience.
Don't Miss the Pizza
Wood-fired pizzas are highly recommended by patrons and are a signature dish.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Enchanting Rustic Decor
Step into a rustic lodge filled with hand-carved fixtures and unique taxidermy displays, creating an unforgettable, old-world atmosphere.
Wood-Fired Pizzas
Highly recommended wood-fired pizzas with delicious crusts and toppings, a must-try for any visitor.
Gluten-Free Pizza Options
Enjoy authentic Italian flavors with dedicated gluten-free pizza options available.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Timing is Everything
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid long wait times and ensure a smoother dining experience.
Don't Miss the Pizza
Wood-fired pizzas are highly recommended by patrons and are a signature dish.
Decor Appreciation
Explore the eclectic decor, including wildlife displays and Christmas decorations, for a unique ambiance.
Flavor Check
Be mindful that some entrees may lack flavor; consider pizzas or other highly-rated dishes.
Tips
from all over the internet
Timing is Everything
Visit during off-peak hours to avoid long wait times and ensure a smoother dining experience.
Don't Miss the Pizza
Wood-fired pizzas are highly recommended by patrons and are a signature dish.
Decor Appreciation
Explore the eclectic decor, including wildlife displays and Christmas decorations, for a unique ambiance.
Flavor Check
Be mindful that some entrees may lack flavor; consider pizzas or other highly-rated dishes.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant offers a unique dining experience with its rustic, lodge-like ambiance and taxidermy decor. While the wood-fired pizzas and gluten-free options are often praised, some diners find the flavors of certain entrees to be lacking and the prices to be high. Service is generally described as friendly and efficient, but the unusual decor can be polarizing.
"Atmosphere better then i thought it would be. Food was delicious bigger portions then you normally see. Very good place, be back for sure."
Jason Anderson
"I would seriously caution anyone from spending their money at this restaurant. my family of four split two meals, and the only reason you see food eaten off the plates is because we had not ate anything else all day.
The food is absolutely not worth the $30+ price tag—not even close. It lacks authenticity, flavor, and any sense of quality. This Fettuccine Alfredo was quite literally the worst I’ve ever had. I’ve had wings from the brew house next door that were 10 times better than anything served here, so if you need to eat, i suggest going there.
The only decent item was the Caesar salad, which—believe it or not—wasn’t even included with the pasta. For the price they’re charging, that’s ridiculous.
While the service was fast, the overall atmosphere was uncomfortable and honestly made the entire experience worse.
If you’re looking for a satisfying meal or anything remotely close to what you paid for, go somewhere else. This was a major letdown and a complete waste of money."
Savanna Marie
"Everything was just fine, though I wouldn't likely rush to the town solely to eat here. The decor was so cool! Staff was very pleasant and service was pretty quick."
Lara
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The restaurant features a unique rustic lodge atmosphere with hand-carved fixtures and taxidermy displays of animals and Christmas decorations.
Yes, Nonna Lisa's offers gluten-free pizza options, which are a popular choice for those with dietary restrictions.
The wood-fired pizzas are highly recommended. Other popular dishes include chicken parmesan and seafood options.
Yes, the restaurant is described as kid-friendly, and the unique decor can be engaging for children.
The restaurant is considered to have higher prices, with entrees often priced at $30+.
Be aware that seating may require the entire party to be present. Some reviews mention issues with order processing if parts of the party arrive separately.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The Best Restaurants In Mackinaw City, Michigan
Nonna Lisa’s restaurant is a restaurant with amiable staff and delectable Italian cuisine. From soups and salads such as minestrone or chicken Caesar, to wood-fired pizzas, which include such toppings as pepperoni and Italian sausage, the menu is wide ranging and delicious. Sample the chicken parmigiano complete with tenderized chicken breast that is lightly dusted with breadcrumbs and baked with mozzarella and homemade marinara sauce.
The Best ASIAN FOOD In BARCELONA: Fusion And Traditional
Both had so much knowledge about Barcelona, from historical facts to humorous anecdotes. Lisa, our Montserrat guide, gave our varied group (from ages 21 to 60) options to fit each person's abilities. Half of our group took a hike and the other half opted for the art museum visit (which in itself was incredible).
Top 14 Gluten-Free Dinner Spots to Delight in Mackinaw City
They looked at crust I brought and said that was definitely regular pizza but I must have grabbed the wrong box. He boxed the pizzas himself and there is no way it was wrong, it had to be my fault. If you have a gluten allergy avoid this place at all cost.
6 Amazing Mackinaw City Restaurants
Address: 312 S Huron Ave, Mackinaw City, MI 49701, United States. It is an absolute treasure in Mackinaw City to try some delectable Italian food and pizza. Nonna Lisa is known for great Italian food and its beautiful wood-based interior.
30+ AWESOME Things to Do in Mackinaw City in 2025
For the best Italian meals in the village, go to Nonna Lisa’s. The restaurant specializes in outstanding pasta dishes and wood-fired pizza. Also on the menu are salads, soups, traditional entrees, and great wine pairings.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit