Butterfly Café
An intimate and classy restaurant offering a romantic atmosphere with fresh seafood and international cuisine in Marathon, FL.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Butterfly Café
Highlights
Must-see attractions
An intimate and classy restaurant offering a romantic atmosphere with fresh seafood and international cuisine in Marathon, FL.
Opt for Outdoor Seating
For a more intimate experience, choose the covered patio seating overlooking the garden or bay.
Appetizer Recommendations
Start with the butterfly salad or shrimp cocktail for a delightful beginning to your meal.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Seafood
Price
$$$
Phone
(305) 289-7177
Address
2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Romantic Garden Patio Dining
Enjoy intimate outdoor dining on a beautiful back porch overlooking a serene garden, perfect for a romantic night out.
Exceptional Key Lime Pie
Indulge in a truly amazing Key lime pie, often praised for its unique presentation with frozen white chocolate mousse.
Scallop Risotto Perfection
Savor the scallop risotto, described as the most delicious dish ever eaten, with creamy texture and perfectly cooked scallops.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Opt for Outdoor Seating
For a more intimate experience, choose the covered patio seating overlooking the garden or bay.
Appetizer Recommendations
Start with the butterfly salad or shrimp cocktail for a delightful beginning to your meal.
Budget for Higher Prices
Be aware that prices can be steeper than other local dining options.
Inquire About Kids' Meals
If dining with children, ask about vegetable sides to ensure suitable options.
Tips
from all over the internet
Opt for Outdoor Seating
For a more intimate experience, choose the covered patio seating overlooking the garden or bay.
Appetizer Recommendations
Start with the butterfly salad or shrimp cocktail for a delightful beginning to your meal.
Budget for Higher Prices
Be aware that prices can be steeper than other local dining options.
Inquire About Kids' Meals
If dining with children, ask about vegetable sides to ensure suitable options.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Butterfly Café is celebrated for its romantic ambiance and exceptional dishes, particularly the scallop risotto and key lime pie. While many praise the attentive service and beautiful setting, some find the prices to be on the higher side for the portion sizes and quality. Overall, it's considered a classy spot for a special occasion.
"We had such a great experience tonight for our son’s birthday. The food, drinks, and service were all exceptional! They brought out Key Lime Pie for his birthday treat and it was AMAZING. Highly recommend!!"
Brittani Mertens
"What a beautiful birthday dinner! Butterfly Cafe has such a calm atmosphere, which is why I was shocked a table of 8ish people were acting so obnoxious! They definitely had a few drinks before coming, and proceeded to laugh/scream so loudly through our whole meal. The entire restaurant was turning to look at them. Very rude, but didn't let it ruin our evening! I had the risotto and it was the most delicious dish I have ever eaten!"
Candice Clair
"Absolutely incredible meal and experience from start to finish. The dining room was wonderfully appointed and just the right size. We shared the butterfly salad and shrimp cocktail to start, both were excellent and generously portioned. The rosemary and Asiago bread that followed were warm and fresh. I had the scallop risotto and it was incredible! My husband had the snapper and it was also delicious and generously portioned. The key lime pie was GREAT, so different with the frozen white chocolate mousse and Oreo crust. The timing of the dishes was perfect and our server was attentive but not overbearing."
Erin W (Erin)
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The cafe offers a romantic and classy ambiance with soft lighting, elegant decor, and beautiful views, especially from the garden patio.
While not explicitly stated, given the upscale nature and popularity, reservations are likely recommended, especially for peak times.
Popular dishes include the scallop risotto, key lime pie, and various fresh seafood options.
Yes, there is a beautiful outdoor patio overlooking the garden or bay, perfect for al fresco dining.
The restaurant is considered upscale, with prices reflecting a higher-end dining experience.
Yes, they offer a menu for young diners and it's suggested to inquire about vegetable sides.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Romantic Things To Do In The Florida Keys
With its charming atmosphere and delicious cuisine, Butterfly Café is the perfect destination for a romantic night out in Marathon, FL. The restaurant’s intimate setting, complete with soft lighting and elegant décor, sets the mood for a truly special evening. The menu features a range of exotic dishes, made with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that will delight your taste buds. Whether you order a succulent steak or a flavor-packed seafood dish, you’re sure to savor every bite.
The Best Marathon, FL Seafood Restaurants & Markets
The Butterfly Café at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort is a serene dining spot overlooking turquoise waters for a memorable lunch or dinner. The covered patio is perfect for al fresco dining, or you can sit inside the spacious dining room that’s sophisticated yet comfortable for date nights and family gatherings. The tantalizing dinner menu includes the famous Florida Keys shrimp cocktail and horseradish encrusted Florida grouper.
Restaurants in the Florida Keys
Savor Florida Keys dining with award-winning world tropical cuisine indoor or outdoor at Tranquility Bay`s own Butterfly Cafe. Under the direction of Our Chef, Butterfly Cafe captures the essence of the islands cuisine with an emphasis on quality, local ingredients and, of course, ocean fresh seafood in a beautiful airy Marathon restaurant setting. Open daily for dinner, the menu and wine list at Butterfly Cafe change seasonally.
The 16 Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida – It's Boarding Time Somewhere
The Butterfly Café in Marathon is a great option if you’re looking for a quaint restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The charming décor and cozy atmosphere provide a perfect setting for a relaxed meal with friends or family, and it has reasonable prices considering the cost of visiting the Florida Keys. The menu offers a variety of dishes with a focus on fresh ingredients and innovative flavor combinations.
Marathon Florida | Restaurants & Places To Eat
Butterfly Café offers an upscale dining experience in Marathon that combines elegant ambiance with sophisticated cuisine. The menu features creative preparations of fresh seafood and local ingredients with international influences. Located within a resort setting, the restaurant provides a refined atmosphere for special occasions and memorable dining experiences in the Florida Keys.
Best Restaurants In Marathon, Florida That You Must TRY!
The Butterfly Cafe is located at the Tranquility Beach Resort, so you can either dine in, take out, or order room service if you are a hotel guest. Dining options include an impressive dining room with high ceilings and sophisticated home decor or a beautiful covered patio. Enjoy views of the Bay in this upscale dining restaurant that is only open for dinner.
The Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida
This charming cafe is located in Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort and is a pretty spot for sophisticated al fresco dining. Offering American favorites, Caribbean classics, and lots of fresh seafood, foodies will love exploring the menu here. There�s also a great menu for young diners, making it a popular place for families to enjoy a special dinner together.
14 Best Restaurants In Marathon FL You Must Try
If you are looking to have an upscale dinner in Marathon you can also check out Butterfly Café at Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort. Dine alfresco or under their soaring ceilings while taking in views of the bay. Start your meal with an order of crab cakes or a shrimp cocktail, then try the filet mignon or scallop risotto for dinner.
Top Things to Do in Marathon, Florida
If you want the perfect island cuisine, Butterfly Cafe is the place to go. Found in the Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort, Butterfly Cafe features an elegant dining area with a relaxing but sophisticated ambiance. The spacious outdoor seating with a garden view is also a wonderful option, especially for a romantic night out.
The Top Restaurants in Marathon, FL
For a more refined dining experience in Marathon, Butterfly Cafe is known for its eclectic menu and fresh ingredients. This cozy spot features creative dishes with a fusion of local and international flavors. It’s a great option for foodies looking for something beyond the typical seafood fare.
10 Florida Keys Restaurants Perfect for Families
Tucked inside the Tranquility Bay Resort in Marathon is a sensational restaurant called Butterfly Cafe. Don’t let the name fool you – it’s so much more than a cafe. And don’t let the location fool you – everyone is welcome, even if you’re not staying on the property.
Dining - Jolly Roger
MM 48.5 at Tranquility Bay Beach House Resort2600 Overseas Hwy Marathon, FL 33050(305) 289-7177Seafood dinners with a tropical twist in a resort cafe with wicker seats, a patio and bay views.Open daily, 6- 10pm.www.tranquilitybay.com/dining/butterflycafe
The 15 Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida
2600 Overseas Highway Marathon | American, Seafood, Vegetarian Friendly | $30 – $35. Looking for a restaurant that provides a high-quality dining experience with beautifully presented food?. In that case, you’ll want to head over to the Butterfly Cafe.
5 Marathon Restaurants You Can’t Miss – Tranquility Bay Beach Resort
Sample succulent shrimp cocktails and tropical crab cakes, followed by an indulgent taste of Key Lime Pie or our TDF “To Die For” sticky toffee pudding. Dine inside in the impressive dining room or enjoy outdoor Marathon dining on the covered patio.
Marathon Honeymoon - What to Do and Where to Stay in 2024
The Butterfly Cafe is nestled within a garden with bright flowers and beautiful palm trees. The ambiance alone makes it worth visiting, and an extensive menu of lunch and dinner favorites makes it a must for foodies.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit