Fish Tales Market and Eatery
A no-frills, beloved seafood eatery and market offering fresh catches, unique dishes, and a laid-back atmosphere by the marina.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Fish Tales Market and Eatery
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A no-frills, beloved seafood eatery and market offering fresh catches, unique dishes, and a laid-back atmosphere by the marina.
Dine Early
The restaurant closes early; plan to visit before 6:30 pm for dinner.
Seating Choice
Sit inside if you prefer to avoid smelling like fish after your meal.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Seafood, American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Fresh, Cooked-to-Order Seafood
Indulge in incredibly fresh seafood, from local catches to unique preparations like marinated mesquite grilled wahoo.
Signature Key Lime Pie
Savor the best Key lime pie with a graham cracker crust, a sweet and tart conclusion to any meal.
Unique Menu Items & German Heritage
Explore unique dishes like the Bavarian fish sandwich and enjoy German beers, a nod to the restaurant's heritage.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Dine Early
The restaurant closes early; plan to visit before 6:30 pm for dinner.
Seating Choice
Sit inside if you prefer to avoid smelling like fish after your meal.
Don't Miss Dessert
The homemade key lime pie is a must-try and highly recommended.
Visit the Market
Purchase fresh seafood to cook at home from the attached market.
Tips
from all over the internet
Dine Early
The restaurant closes early; plan to visit before 6:30 pm for dinner.
Seating Choice
Sit inside if you prefer to avoid smelling like fish after your meal.
Don't Miss Dessert
The homemade key lime pie is a must-try and highly recommended.
Visit the Market
Purchase fresh seafood to cook at home from the attached market.
Embrace Local Vibe
Engage with locals for an authentic experience at this popular spot.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Fish Tales Market and Eatery is a highly praised local gem known for its incredibly fresh seafood and generous portions. Diners rave about the quality of the fish, the delicious homemade sides, and the unforgettable key lime pie. While the atmosphere is casual, the friendly and attentive service adds to the overall positive dining experience.
"We stopped for lunch before a snorkel tour in the neighboring dive shop. We were pleasantly surprised by the attentive service. And we were even more surprised by the delicious food. We had the snapper and fried green tomato sandwich. It is served with a special sauce that you should request “on the side” if you choose to get the sandwiches. One of us got fries and I got the “cult followed” green beans. The snapper was as fresh as you can get and breaded and fried to perfection. Super flaky fish but still very firm. It was as good a fish sandwich as you’ll get anywhere. The green beans are made in beef stock and are soft and delicious. The fries are seasoned and thick. We came back later that evening for dessert. The key lime pie is pictured, which is almost like an ice cream but it’s super tasty. Also pictured is the mud pie. It is Oreo crust with chocolate chip ice cream with chocolate syrup. And the last one is a bourbon pecan pie, which was actually my favorite. I LOVE pecan pie. Also pictured are the freezers where they sell fresh seafood by the pound. It is insane how much variety they have and everything is so fresh. The restaurant has a German heritage behind it so you’ll find German beers on tap and several German style food options on the menu. I’m telling you, this place is amazing for lunch or dinner. I’ll be stopping again next time I’m here."
Steve Cooper
"Visited twice during our stay in Marathon. Friendly attentive service. Excellent food each time. If you even remotely like green beans you will love theirs. Fried shrimp coleslaw. Everything was great. Great sweet tea."
Kathy Perkins
"This was a great seafood lunch spot. We had the clam chowder, the fried red shrimp basket and the fried snapper sandwich. The shrimp was cooked perfectly tender. The fried snapper sandwich was amazing. So delicate and tasty!the. Lack beans and rice were very flavorful. They had lots of specials and market items for sale that were t just seafood. There was a great selection of meats and sausages."
Bucky Reed
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The restaurant is open daily from 10 am to 6:30 pm, with shorter hours on Saturdays and closed on Sundays.
Many recommend the fresh fish sandwiches, especially the snapper and the Bavarian fish sandwich. The key lime pie is also a must-try dessert.
Yes, Fish Tales has an attached market where you can purchase fresh seafood by the pound.
It's a casual, no-frills, local eatery with outdoor seating available, ideal for a relaxed meal.
Yes, the menu includes options like burgers, chicken, and hot dogs, with gluten-free buns available.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Restaurants in The Florida Keys
This no-frills, roadside eatery has a loyal local following, an unfussy ambience, a couple of outside picnic tables, and friendly service. Signature dishes include snapper on grilled rye with coleslaw and melted Muenster cheese, a fried-fish burrito, George's crab cake, and tomato-based conch chowder. Landlubbers can choose everything from burgers and dogs to meat loaf and Cuban pork.
Top Things to Do in Marathon, Florida
The oldest fish market and restaurant in Marathon, Fish Tales serves seafood “fresh from our market to your table.” You’ll find a large selection of fish and seafood at the market, such as lobsters, pink shrimps, mahi mahi, snapper, grouper, sea scallops, and so much more, then have them prepared and served just the way you want them. Fish Tales also sells and serves top quality certified Angus beef steaks. Not to be missed is their signature Chef Johnny’s Rambler Sandwich, which was named the best fish sandwich in Marathon.
The 16 Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida – It's Boarding Time Somewhere
The menu at Fish Tales Market & Eatery features a range of seafood dishes, including classics like fish and chips, seafood chowder, and lobster rolls. The seafood is fresh and of good quality, and it is sourced locally and prepared with care. In addition to the restaurant, Fish Tales Market & Eatery also features a seafood market where customers can purchase fresh seafood to cook at home.
Top 11 Florida Keys Kid-Friendly Restaurants - Tripping.com Rentals
If your kids aren’t fans of crab and lobster, the kids’ menu includes burgers, chicken, and hot dogs. If you’re visiting the Keys in October, stop by the cafe’s version of Oktoberfest, which features live music, German food, and German beer. Check out the attached market on your way out, and pick up some fish to cook up back at your vacation rental.
The Top-Rated Seafood Market in Marathon FL for 2025
Fish Tales Market and Eatery in Marathon FL is a hidden gem for all seafood lovers. With an impressive selection of fresh catches, incredible flavors and a friendly atmosphere, this place truly stands out from the rest. Don't miss the opportunity to indulge in their mouthwatering seafood delicacies!
17 Best Things to Do in Marathon FL
One of Marathon’s oldest fish markets and restaurants, Fish Tales Market and Eatery provides a wide selection of fresh fish ranging from shrimp and crabs as well as a range of hand-made prime steaks. The menu includes an afternoon meal served from 11 – 4 p.m. Dinner is served from 16 – 20 p.m.
11 Best Restaurants in Marathon, FL
11711 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050Phone: 305-743-9196 Visit Website. A post shared by Marcella Peters (@cellabella25). Fish Tales Market & Eatery is the next place I want to mention and it’s always a surefire spot to visit in Marathon for great food and good times.
15 Best Restaurants in Marathon, FL [2023 Updated]
Whether you love fresh or cooked seafood, Fish Tales Market and Eatery is ready to serve you. Its fresh from-the-ocean ingredients will satisfy you with every bite. Try out some of their classics, such as ‘Red Conch Chowder’ and ‘Fried Calamari.’
Dining - Jolly Roger
MM 5311711 Overseas Hwy Marathon, FL 33050(305) 743-9196No frills seafood restaurant and sop offering simple fare in a colorful space with outdoor seating.Open daily 10am- 6:30 pm. Saturday 10am- 4 pm. Closed Sunday.www.floridalobster.com
Best Marathon Florida Keys restaurants - Kelly Willey
For a truly local experience, head to Fish Tales Market & Eatery. This no-frills seafood market and restaurant is all about fresh, simple flavors. Their fish sandwiches and seafood platters are a must-try for anyone visiting Marathon.
The 15 Best Restaurants in Marathon, Florida
11711 Overseas Hwy, Marathon | American, Seafood, Vegetarian Friendly | $4 – $16. Fish Tales Market & Eatery is one of the most casual food places in Marathon. It is a seafood restaurant situated in “the heart” of the Florida Keys.
The Best Fish Sandwich In Florida Is Hiding Inside This Iconic Seafood Market
The unassuming exterior might have you driving past if you didn’t know better, but locals and in-the-know travelers make deliberate pilgrimages to this Florida Keys institution for one legendary item: the hogfish sandwich.
Restaurants in the Florida Keys
Seafood restaurant & shop offering simple fare in a colorful space with outdoor seating. Location: 11711 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050. Phone: (305) 743-9196
Where Do Locals Eat in Marathon: Discover Authentic Dining Spots
You can buy fresh fish to take home or enjoy a meal on-site. The setting is simple, with a cozy, nautical theme.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit