San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
The only VPN-certified Neapolitan pizzeria in Milwaukee, featuring an authentic Italian oven and exceptional wood-fired pizzas.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
Highlights
Must-see attractions
The only VPN-certified Neapolitan pizzeria in Milwaukee, featuring an authentic Italian oven and exceptional wood-fired pizzas.
"Hands down one of the best pizzas I have had anywhere! Really well balanced flavors."
Book Ahead, Especially Busy Nights
Reservations are recommended, as tables may have time limits during peak hours to manage demand.
Dine at the Bar
Sit at the counter to watch chefs prepare pizzas. It's an interactive and enjoyable experience.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(414) 276-2876
Address
838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203, USA
Website
sangiorgiopizza.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Neapolitan Pizza
Experience VPN-certified Neapolitan pizza cooked in a unique, imported Italian oven. High-quality ingredients and traditional methods shine.
Interactive Pizza Oven Experience
Dine around the striking blue, conical pizza oven imported from Italy. Watch skilled chefs craft your Neapolitan pizzas right before your eyes.
Unique Toppings & Cocktails
Beyond traditional, discover pizzas with unique toppings like sunny-side eggs and enjoy expertly crafted cocktails for a surprising twist.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Book Ahead, Especially Busy Nights
Reservations are recommended, as tables may have time limits during peak hours to manage demand.
Dine at the Bar
Sit at the counter to watch chefs prepare pizzas. It's an interactive and enjoyable experience.
Explore the Menu
Don't hesitate to try different pizzas; popular choices like San Giorgio and Maria Carmella are highly recommended.
Start with Olives
If you love olives, the 'olive misti' appetizer is a great way to begin your meal.
Tips
from all over the internet
Book Ahead, Especially Busy Nights
Reservations are recommended, as tables may have time limits during peak hours to manage demand.
Dine at the Bar
Sit at the counter to watch chefs prepare pizzas. It's an interactive and enjoyable experience.
Explore the Menu
Don't hesitate to try different pizzas; popular choices like San Giorgio and Maria Carmella are highly recommended.
Start with Olives
If you love olives, the 'olive misti' appetizer is a great way to begin your meal.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana consistently earns rave reviews for its authentic Neapolitan pizzas, praised for their perfect crust and quality toppings. The interactive pizza oven experience and friendly service are also frequently highlighted as major draws, making it a memorable dining destination. While some patrons note a wait for seating, most agree the exceptional food and atmosphere are well worth it.
"How have I not found this gem of a restaurant until now?! Absolutely incredible Neopolitan style pizza. It was fun to sit next to the pizza oven and watch them make the pizzas. They even have seats surrounding it as well. We had a couple drink cocktails which were delicious. The meatball appetizer was just as incredible as the pizza. I would like to every order single pizza off the menu. The service was also very friendly and we loved our server who was very personable with us!"
Erika Comdohr
"One of the very best meals I’ve had since coming to Wisconsin. We ordered the gnochetti (exquisite), a margherita pizza, and the doppio calabrese… absolutely stunning. Perfect chew to the crust, and the pizza toppings were all incredible. Super friendly server as well. Absolutely recommend!"
Maggie Burk
"I strolled across the street from my hotel after hearing nothing but good things about this place. I decided to sit at the bar and was pleased with my choice. All the servers were very friendly and attentive. For a starter I ordered the olive misti because I love olives. I mean who doesn't love olives?It was time to order my pizza and after struggling to decide on which one, I wanted, I finally went with the Maria Carmella. It was an excellent choice. The dough was light and airy and all the topping were fantastic. Not much beats a wood fired pizza when it comes to taste. The only problem I can think of is I live so far away and will not be back for a long time."
Rick
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
They are the only VPN-certified pizzeria in Milwaukee, adhering to strict traditional Neapolitan pizza-making standards, including using a specific oven and ingredients.
Yes! You can sit around the conical blue pizza oven and watch the skilled chefs prepare your pizzas in real-time.
It's recommended, especially on busy nights, as tables may have time limits.
Yes, besides traditional options, they offer unique toppings like sunny-side eggs, adding a creative twist.
Customers often recommend the 'San Giorgio' and 'Maria Carmella' pizzas, but exploring the menu is encouraged.
Popular dessert choices include Tiramisu and Cannoli, with Tiramisu often noted as being particularly delicious.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Best Pizza in Milwaukee: Pizza Shops With the Best Slices in Town
The focal point of San Giorgio is the conical blue pizza oven, imported from Italy, which pumps out pies at breakneck speed while diners sit around it at the bar and watch the action. This is the only VPN-certified pizzeria in Milwaukee, which means the owners pay a lot of money to be evaluated by the supreme Neapolitan pizza gods, who dictate everything from ingredients they can use to the size of the yeast packages they can buy. Maybe that really makes a difference, and maybe it's just marketing hype, but either way, it's good pizza.How to order: Call 414-276-2876.
These are some of the best restaurants in downtown Milwaukee
Lovers of Neapolitan-style pizza should make a pilgrimage to San Giorgio, the only Milwaukee-area pizzeria that’s certified under the strict rules of the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana. The pies are cooked in a 900°F Stefano Ferrara oven and come out with a puffy crust with charred edges and a delicate center. It’s one of the top pizza joints in town, and it feels classy enough for a pre-show meal but not too stuffy to stop in before a Bucks game a couple blocks north.
52 restaurants for your bucket list in 2019
It’s simple: you’ll find well executed authentic Neapolitan style pies, antipasti and even spit-roasted Italian style chicken, if you’re so inclined. San Giorgio also claims the honor of being the singular Vera Pizza Napoletana certified pizza restaurant in Milwaukee. That means every bite of that chewy, wood-fired oven blasted crust is derived from a long tradition of Italian expertise.
The 7 Best Pizzas In Milwaukee
Their pizza couldn’t be more classical in style or authentic. This is the real deal and every bit as good as anything you’d eat in Italy. Their dough is made fresh and naturally fermented in accordance with the strict standards of the authentic Vera Pizza Napolenta.
Milwaukee-Style Pizza
A relative newcomer to Milwaukee’s pizza scene, this eatery is serving up ultra-traditional Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas. Snag a seat at the bar to watch the pizzas being made in the beautiful cobalt blue pizza oven, brought straight from Naples.
50 Best Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI for 2025 (Top Eats!)
838 N Old World 3rd StMilwaukee, WI 53203(414) 276-2876 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Located in the city center, this dining establishment with an all-white facade offers Neapolitan pizzas, pasta and sides in casual environs.
Best Pizza Places in Milwaukee
This is the pie you want when you’re sad, happy, in love, in lust. In short, it’s the pizza you want all the time. Owner Gino Fazzari, who also runs the MKE-style-pizza- serving Calderone Club next door, is serious about Neapolitan pizza.
A Pizza My Heart: Downtown Milwaukee's Pizza Guide | Blog | Experience
For an authentic taste of Italy in Milwaukee San Giorgio is a must try!. Fresh and naturally fermented pizza dough is a non-negotiable for head chef Gino Fazzari, who follows the strict standards of the authentic Vera Pizza Napoletana.
Highest-rated Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, According to Tripadvisor
- Rating: 4.5 / 5 (93 reviews)- Detailed ratings: Food (4.5/5), Service (4.5/5), Value (4.0/5)- Type of cuisine: Italian, Pizza- Price: $$ - $$$- Address: 838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203-1701- Read more on Tripadvisor
35 Best Restaurants in Milwaukee
838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203Phone: 414-276-2876 Visit Website. View this post on Instagram. A post shared by San Giorgio Pizzeria MKE (@sangiorgiopizzerianapoletana)
Best restaurants in Milwaukee [PHOTOS]
Enjoy some delicious true Italian pizza at San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana. This restaurant is located at 838 N Old World 3rd St.San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana Facebook
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit