C.J. Maggie's
A beloved neighborhood eatery in Elkins offering a vast American grill menu with generous portions and a cozy, homey atmosphere.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
C.J. Maggie's
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved neighborhood eatery in Elkins offering a vast American grill menu with generous portions and a cozy, homey atmosphere.
Ask Servers for Recommendations
Friendly servers like Brandy B. or Suzanne can offer great insider tips on must-try dishes.
Embrace Generous Portions
Portions are huge! Be prepared for leftovers or consider sharing your meal.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Generous Portions & Homestyle Comfort
Experience hearty meals with huge portions, from wood-fired calzones to chicken pot pie. Leftovers are practically guaranteed!
Diverse Menu & Cozy Atmosphere
An extensive menu offers something for everyone, from pizzas to steaks, in a homey setting with private booths.
Signature Wood-Fired Calzones & Pizzas
Known for their delicious wood-fired calzones and pizzas, especially the unique Thai chicken pizza.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Ask Servers for Recommendations
Friendly servers like Brandy B. or Suzanne can offer great insider tips on must-try dishes.
Embrace Generous Portions
Portions are huge! Be prepared for leftovers or consider sharing your meal.
Consider Off-Peak Hours
Visit during non-peak times to potentially avoid wait times, as service can sometimes be slow.
Don't Skip Dessert
The homemade ice cream, especially the fresh raspberry, is a highly recommended sweet treat.
Tips
from all over the internet
Ask Servers for Recommendations
Friendly servers like Brandy B. or Suzanne can offer great insider tips on must-try dishes.
Embrace Generous Portions
Portions are huge! Be prepared for leftovers or consider sharing your meal.
Consider Off-Peak Hours
Visit during non-peak times to potentially avoid wait times, as service can sometimes be slow.
Don't Skip Dessert
The homemade ice cream, especially the fresh raspberry, is a highly recommended sweet treat.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
C.J. Maggie's offers a wide-ranging menu in a cozy atmosphere, with many diners praising the generous portions and unique dishes like wood-fired calzones and homemade ice cream. However, some reviews indicate inconsistencies in food quality and service, with occasional issues like undercooked burgers or bland flavors.
"Very cool place with great food!
Had to wait a bit longer than I thought for a pickup order, but it was worth the wait.
As an out-of-towner, I'm glad I picked this place while passing through town!"
Kevin
"I ordered the mile high shrimp, and it came out as a very small portion. My daughter did get a cheese pizza, and it looked better than most places. Two nights ago, my girlfriend and I had dinner here, and I ordered the burgundy steak pasta . The steak was very bland and had zero flavor. They give it such a fantastic description, and it didn't live up to the
hype. The only thing that was good was the server. She was very nice. The food was terrible. Shrimp was 20.99 before taxes, and you can get triple that amount for 6 dollars at Walmart. I did have the ice cream, and I would give that an 8 out of 10."
Zachary Mallow
"Magical pizza and ice-cream. Something for everyone no doubt. We had Margaret eata with banana peppers added and Thai with jalapeño added. Raspberry chip ice-cream and fried green beans appetizer. Cold trail beer with slice of orange. This visit added a nice touch to a great weekend at Dolly Sods"
Mark Nunley
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Diners often rave about the wood-fired calzones, pizzas (like the Thai chicken pizza), chicken pot pie, and the homemade ice cream. Generous portions mean you'll likely have leftovers!
Yes, the diverse menu with options for all tastes and the cozy atmosphere make it a good choice for families.
Absolutely! Many reviews mention 'huge' or 'generous' portions, so come hungry or plan for take-home meals.
The restaurant has a cozy, homey, and quirky atmosphere with private booths and interesting decor, making it a pleasant place to dine.
Service can be inconsistent. Some diners report fast and pleasant service, while others mention delays or a rushed feeling. Visiting off-peak hours might help.
Yes, look for unique options like the wood-fired calzones, Thai chicken pizza, and homemade ice cream flavors.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Vintage, A Casual Fine Dining Experience and Wine Bar - a "Best Things West … Restaurant Bar Live Music Beander WebTHE 10 BEST Dinner Restaurants in Elkins (UPDATED 2023) United States West Virginia (WV) Elkins Elkins Restaurants Elkins Dinner Restaurants View map Sort by: Highest Rating 1. The Forks Restaurant & Inn 175 reviews Open Now American $$$$ “We will be back” “Lovely evening!” 2. El Gran … aadya pune address Dine - Elkins-Randolph County Tourism WebBest Sports Bars in Elkins, WV 26241 - Twisted Bull, Jimbo’s Place, Bryan's & Brent's Place, Applebee's Grill + Bar, Buffalo Wild Wings, 3rd Base Sports Bar & Grille, The Locker Room Sports Bar, Black Bear Tavern and Restaurant, Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar Clarksburg DUKE EL GRAN SABOR, Elkins - Restaurant Reviews, … West Virginia sees biggest May snowfall on record with … WebSmoke on the Water a traditional BBQ Restaurant in Elkins, WV including ribs, wings, burgers & more. Call us today at 304-636-9669 . aadya pg WebSpecialties: BBQ restaurant featuring outdoor dining in a wooded setting, live music, craft beers and full bar Established in 2011. Smoke on the Water began in 2011 as a take out BBQ restaurant in a small cabin on the Shavers Fork of Cheat River and has grown into a large BBQ restaurant just … aadyant meaning C.J. Maggies • American Grill • Buckhannon & Elkins … Web26 Jan 2021 · Save Share 221 reviews #2 of 31 Restaurants in Elkins $$ - $$$ Latin Venezuelan Central American 413 Kerens Ave, Elkins, WV 26241-3854 +1 304-636-8200 Website … aadya pandey Travel Guide to Convention From Washington DC SCOTTIE’S OF ELKINS - Menu, Prices GREAT HARVEST, Elkins - Updated 2023 Restaurant … Web16 Oct 2021 · 175 reviews #1 of 32 Restaurants in Elkins ££££ American Vegetarian Friendly Vegan Options. 35 Scenic Ridge Rd Kelly Mtn Rd., … aadyansh name meaning in hindi WebTHE 10 BEST Dinner Restaurants in Elkins (UPDATED 2023) United States West Virginia (WV) Elkins Elkins Restaurants Elkins Dinner Restaurants … WebDelivery & Pickup Options - 53 reviews of The Forks Restaurant & Inn "My family decided to eat here since the … aadyanth inc WebOffers Takeout 1. The Forks Restaurant & Inn 53 American (New) $$$ “We've been enjoying The Forks for about a year now, and for Randolph County, it … Web3 May 2023 · West Virginia wasn’t alone with the big snow totals in the region. Laurel Summit — near Seven Springs ski area in southwest Pennsylvania — picked up 11.8 inches, which is one of the largest ...
9 Incredible Things To Do In Elkins, West Virginia
If you’re looking for a huge variety of items on the menu to choose from, CJ Maggie’s is the place to go in Elkins. This cozy restaurant, with private booths and tables, has one of the most extensive menus I’ve seen. We sampled lots of yummy dishes, with French onion soup, chili, nachos, and Caesar salads topping the list.
The 5 most popular restaurants in Elkins, WV
First opening in Buckhannon, WV in 1992, the American grill-style restaurant C.J. Maggie’s retained the first space while opening a second location in Elkins. While they might be best known for their wood-fired calzones and pizzas—including a Thai chicken pizza—C.J.
Town guide: Elkins - Almost Heaven
C.J. Maggie’s: There’s something for everyone at this all-American grill, which prides itself on fresh ingredients. They cut all their own steaks, stuff their own sausages and whip up their own soups and dressings.
Elkins | Halal Food & Travel
CJ Maggies Davis Avenue ☎ +1 304-636-1730 - Open daily for lunch, dinner, and drink. Diverse menu including sandwiches and Pastas plates. Also serves Appalachian Ale and other brews from the Appalachian Company.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit