Gage & Tollner
1 / 10

Gage & Tollner

4.6
·491k reviews·,

A historic Brooklyn steakhouse since 1879, offering Gilded Age grandeur, classic American fare, and legendary desserts.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Gage & Tollner

Gage & Tollner

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A historic Brooklyn steakhouse since 1879, offering Gilded Age grandeur, classic American fare, and legendary desserts.

4.6
(491k reviews)

"Experience the magic of a bygone era with exceptional steaks and an iconic dessert."

TIP

Book Ahead

Make a reservation in advance to secure your table and avoid wait times.

Bar for Dessert

Consider snagging a seat at the bar for cocktails and dessert if reservations are unavailable.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens Thursday 5PM

Cuisine

American

Price

$$$

Phone

(347) 689-3677

Address

372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Step Back in Time

Step Back in Time

Experience a unique old-school atmosphere with classic vibes and Gilded Age grandeur.

50 Best Restaurants in Brooklyn: All the Classics to New FavoritesThe Best Steakhouse in NYC for Every Type of DinerThe Best Steakhouses in New York City
Legendary Steaks

Legendary Steaks

Enjoy top-tier steaks, including grass-fed and dry-aged options, cooked to perfection.

The MOST Legendary Steakhouses in NYC (Plus a Map)Google Review+1
Iconic Baked Alaska

Iconic Baked Alaska

Don't miss this show-stopping dessert, perfect for sharing and a grand finale.

20 Most Romantic Restaurants in NYC for Date NightThe 20 Best Restaurant Desserts In NYC - New YorkGoogle Review
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

At Gage & Tollner, one of the oldest restaurants in Brooklyn, New York, lives a legacy that starts with the menu inspired by one developed decades ago by chef Edna Lewis. Lewis, who had no formal training but climbed to ranks of the restaurant in her 70s, is the granddaughter of Chester Lewis, a formerly enslaved man who went on to help build the city of Freetown. Marking #Juneteenth , #TODAYShow'...
@todayshow
501 likes • 8.1K views

Book Ahead

Make a reservation in advance to secure your table and avoid wait times.

Bar for Dessert

Consider snagging a seat at the bar for cocktails and dessert if reservations are unavailable.

I was so excited for this opening: Gage & Tollner in Downtown Brooklyn. #nycrestaurants #restauranttiktok #gageandtollner #romanticizeyourlife
@thisistaracox
14 likes • 1.5K views
@Gage & Tollner Dine like it’s the gilded age at this retro restaurant. The steak is overpriced, but I’d go back for the crispy layered hash brown in cream any day 🤭#gageandtollner #gageandtollnernyc #gageandtollnerisback #gageandtollnerbk #brooklyndining
@muffinsgonnachangemylove
2 likes • 936 views

Post-Dinner Drinks

Head upstairs to the sunken harbor club for cocktails after your meal.

Consider a Share

The Baked Alaska is portioned for two and is a popular, shareable dessert.

Greatness In Downtown Brooklyn: Gage & Tollner. #foodiemagician #brooklyn #nyc #fyp #foryourpage #foodtiktok #foodie #love #steak
@foodiemagician
67 likes • 2.6K views

Tips

from all over the internet

Book Ahead

Make a reservation in advance to secure your table and avoid wait times.

Bar for Dessert

Consider snagging a seat at the bar for cocktails and dessert if reservations are unavailable.

Post-Dinner Drinks

Head upstairs to the sunken harbor club for cocktails after your meal.

Consider a Share

The Baked Alaska is portioned for two and is a popular, shareable dessert.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Gage & Tollner offers a unique, historic atmosphere and is lauded for its classic American dishes, particularly steaks and the iconic Baked Alaska. While many praise the warm service and grand ambiance, some find the portions small for the high price point, and a few reviews mention inconsistencies in steak preparation. Despite minor critiques, the restaurant is considered a Brooklyn gem for a special occasion.

"Old school esthetics. Very unique vibe to itself compared to other steakhouses I have been. Our servers were supers nice as well as the host. The manager also check in on us which is always a plus. Food overall was incredible and to the standard of a top tier steakhouse. Some of the highlights for me was their house sauce. It was rich with flavor and slight kick which is not common in most sauces. They also had a citrus dessert that was one of the best i have had in long time. The highlight of this establishment is that they have the classics but they also have unique items. Will def go back."

Ronald Hernandez

"Whoa ! Great quality food and excellent flavors. To start, the rolls, broccoli, and Caesar salad was delicious and well developed. Our table also ordered the hen of the woods and oysters. A few of us split the Porterhouse for Three, which was excellently seasoned. To finish, the comeback special sundae was super amazing. I’m delightfully satisfied.

One issue we had was with our steak — we ordered medium rare and it came more on the rare side. This is fine with me because I prefer my steak on the rare side, and the buttery texture and seasoning compensated. That being said, not all at my table preferred this.

All and all, I’m excited to eat here again sometime. Super modern and classy atmosphere, as well as great service. Every course was so unique from the last, and deeply satiating."

wallace dos santos

"Gage & Tollner is a true gem and a perfect spot for a special date night. This historic Brooklyn steakhouse has been around since 1879, and it’s easy to see why it’s stood the test of time. The food is outstanding—classic surf & turf done right, with incredibly high-quality ingredients. I especially appreciate that their steaks are grass-fed, dry-aged, and many ingredients are sourced from local farms, which really shows in the flavor.

The service is warm and attentive, and the old-school atmosphere adds to the charm. It’s definitely on the pricier side, but well worth it for the quality and experience. My only minor complaint is that the tables are a little too close together, which can make it feel a bit tight. That said, we’ll absolutely be back—this place is a Brooklyn classic for a reason."

Lin Chen

What People Like

Historic, Gilded Age atmosphere
Top-tier steaks and seafood
Warm and accommodating service

What People Dislike

Steak portions perceived as small
High price point
Occasional steak preparation issues

Frequently Asked Questions

Gage & Tollner is most famous for its historic Gilded Age atmosphere, top-tier steaks, and its iconic Baked Alaska dessert.

50 Best Restaurants in Brooklyn: All the Classics to New Favorites20 Most Romantic Restaurants in NYC for Date NightThe 20 Best Restaurant Desserts In NYC - New York+1

Yes, the romantic, old-school atmosphere with dimmed lighting and classic cocktails makes it a perfect spot for a special date night.

20 Most Romantic Restaurants in NYC for Date NightThe Best Steakhouses in New York CityGoogle Review

Yes, it's highly recommended to make a reservation in advance, especially for popular times, to avoid long waits.

Standout dishes include the steaks, oysters, Parker House rolls, and the Baked Alaska for dessert.

Best Restaurants in NYCThe 20 Best Restaurant Desserts In NYC - New YorkGoogle Review

Yes, many diners suggest snagging a seat at the bar for cocktails and to enjoy desserts if a table reservation isn't available.

The 20 Best Restaurant Desserts In NYC - New York

Yes, the restaurant has a classic cocktail list, with martinis and other signature drinks being popular choices.

The Best Steakhouses in New York CityGoogle Review

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

Thrillist

50 Best Restaurants in Brooklyn: All the Classics to New Favorites

After an initial 13-month delay due to COVID-19, Gage & Tollner in Downtown Brooklyn made its highly anticipated debut last spring. The legendary oyster and chop house’s origins date back to 1879, and its revival is brought to you by veteran restaurateurs Sohui Kim and Ben Schneider (the wife-and-husband duo behind The Good Fork and Insa), and St. John Frizell ( Fort Defiance). Inside a space that stuns with its Gilded Age glory, use an evening here as a reason to get dressed up for a night out and prepare for some prime people-watching of your fellow diners within the intimate dining room—all the while enjoying a menu of seafood platters, steaks, and much more.

Visit Source →
Time Out

20 Most Romantic Restaurants in NYC for Date Night

Originally opened in 1879, the city's long-lasting love affair with this chophouse might just rub off on you and your date. The bartenders wear jackets, the chandeliers catch the dimmed light and you can't go wrong with a pair of martinis and oysters from the raw bar. Try this: The baked Alaska, filled with chocolate and cherries and finished with a golden meringue, is portioned for two so you won't end the night in a squabble over who gets to lick the spoon.

Visit Source →
The New York Times

Best Restaurants in NYC

The 19th-century dining room had been out of commission for so long that when Gage & Tollner finally came back in 2021, almost everybody who came to eat was getting a first look at its marble, mahogany and converted gaslights. Now the place has a reputation again, and those who are lured by its oysters and Parker House rolls, fried chicken, crab cakes and baked alaska are likely to be return customers. That doesn’t mean heads have stopped swiveling.

Visit Source →
Eater NY

The Best Fried Chicken in New York City

Visit Source →
The Infatuation

The 20 Best Restaurant Desserts In NYC - New York

Dessert nerds already know that the sweets at Gage & Tollner are the real reason to stand outside at 4:30pm if you can’t manage to snag a reservation here. In fact, we’d go so far as to say that you should skip the full meal, get a seat at the bar, and have drinks and dessert. Not only are these the strongest sections of the menu, but the thing is, you simply must order the Baked Alaska, which serves two—allegedly.

Visit Source →
Condé Nast Traveler

The Best Steakhouse in NYC for Every Type of Diner

Gage & Tollner is more than 100 years old, but somehow manages to feel exactly like a Brooklyn restaurant of today should: inviting, thoughtful, and bustling—with a dose of history mixed in for good measure. It’s the type of restaurant that reminds guests why New York is a great city to dine in. The landmarked interior at Gage & Tollner is lined with mirrors and cherry wood arches and lit by brass chandeliers.

Visit Source →
Travel + Leisure

New York City Travel Guide

Originally open for 125 years from 1879 to 2004, Gage & Tollner reopened in April 2021 as a modern oyster and chop house. Now, once again, the cornerstone of Downtown Brooklyn's restaurant scene, Gage & Tollner gives plenty of nods to its history, through both the food and largely Gilded Age-inspired design. Looking to stray from the classic '40s martini-and-steak vibes?

Visit Source →
MICHELIN Guide

The Best Steakhouses in New York City

Vintage mirrors, cherry wood and brass chandeliers line the length of this historic restaurant, which first opened in 1892. With an amber glow and buzzing crowd, the room immediately charms, down to the no-nonsense all-classic cocktail list. There is plenty to eat here, as the team is not content to merely let history and looks stand in for substance.

Visit Source →
New York Drinks Guide

The best new restaurants in NYC

Returning to all its glory in Downtown Brooklyn in April of 2021, Gage & Tollner revived its status as operational after shutting down in 2004. Back in the 20th century, it had a big name in New York, from surviving the Prohibition era to being granted landmark status by the Preservation Commission. Having always risen up to occasions like Valentine’s and other celebratory festivities, their revitalized menu is loaded with A La Carte selections like caviar, oyster, steak, chops, and other meat dishes.

Visit Source →
Your Brooklyn Guide

The MOST Legendary Steakhouses in NYC (Plus a Map)

A true New York legend and contender for the best steakhouse in New York, Gage and Tollner has lived more than nine lives. One of the oldest steakhouses in New York originally opened in 1879, the restaurant exchanged ownership over the course of 125 years before closing in 2004. After Chef Sohui Kim, her husband and restaurateur Ben Schneider, and fellow restaurateur St. John Frizell purchased the space in 2017, raising the significant funds needed to renovate and finally open the eatery in 2021.

Visit Source →
Resy | Right This Way

The Resy Guide to Incredible Desserts in New York — Resy

Where would Gage & Tollner be without their desserts and the impeccable coif of award-winning pastry chef Caroline Schiff?. Many have waxed on about her showstopping baked Alaska for two, in which a lightly torched meringue hides no less than three layers of homemade ice cream (fresh mint, dark chocolate, and Amarena cherry). But don’t let this signature overshadow her other creations — a blueberry chèvre cheesecake and a seasonal sundae are just as mighty.

Visit Source →
The Vendry Memo

The Trendiest Restaurants in New York City Right Now

Gage & Tollner in Downtown Brooklyn stands out as a hot new spot for Brooklynites and Manhattanites alike. The restaurant's two private dining rooms, meticulously restored to their former Victorian splendor, offer an exquisite setting for celebrations in Brooklyn. Adorned with a marble-topped brass bar, custom wainscoting, and ornamental fireplaces, these rooms exude a timeless charm that creates an elegant backdrop for corporate gatherings.

Visit Source →
Condé Nast Traveller

The 31 best restaurants in New York City

Gage & Tollner is more than 100 years old, but somehow manages to feel exactly like a Brooklyn restaurant of today should: inviting, thoughtful, and bustling – with a dose of history mixed in for good measure. It’s the type of restaurant that reminds guests why New York is a great city to dine in. The landmarked interior at Gage & Tollner is lined with mirrors and cherry wood arches and lit by brass chandeliers.

Visit Source →
Avenue Magazine

The Best Steakhouses in NYC

Had I a telescope, from the patio I might have been able to sight another of the city’s great steakhouses: Gage & Tollner, an almost 150-year-old steakhouse brought back to life a few months ago by a trio of talented restaurateurs. Whereas most steakhouses fortified themselves with endless lobbies and antechambers to keep the public at bay, Gage & Tollner opens right onto the bustle of Brooklyn’s Fulton Street.

Visit Source →
Sea the City

Top 20 Rooftop Restaurants in NYC

Historic chophouse Gage & Tollner offers fine dining for that special occasion you’ve been carefully planning. Once there, you’ll be transported to a bygone era where bartenders wear jackets, chandeliers cast a dimmed light, and martinis and oysters from the raw bar set the tone for romance. Begin your culinary journey with unique starters from the menu, like the exquisite, crispy hen-of-the-woods mushrooms.

Visit Source →
securespace.com

The 45 best brunch spots in NYC you need to try this weekend

It is now well regarded as one of the best new restaurants and in no time became a place to be for Brunch NYC lovers. Located in Downtown Brooklyn, Gage & Tollner opens its doors on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays from 11: A gastronomic heaven between 30 am and 4:30 pm that welcomes patrons. The brunch menu includes eggs, bacon, and a homemade brunch burger, making each bite a gastronomic adventure.

Visit Source →
Sea the City - NYC

Top 20 Most Romantic Restaurants in NYC

If you are looking for cozy restaurants in NYC to spend some quality time, Gage & Tollner has you covered. G&T is a historic chophouse in Downtown Brooklyn, and it is a remarkable blend of bygone elegance and contemporary culinary artistry. This celebrated restaurant, known for its gaslight-era chandeliers and retro decor, has been a renowned name in Brooklyn for over 125 years.

Visit Source →
Travel New York Now

83 Amazing & Unique Restaurants in NYC You Must Try Now!

Step back in time for dinner in one of the most stunning and historic restaurants in New York City!. Because after first opening in 1879, Gage & Toller has seen plenty of change. However, its new revival has it looking like a masterpiece of old New York, complete with posh brass chandeliers, plush booths, and a sweeping bar that looks like something straight out of Mad Men!

Visit Source →
Restaurant Clicks

32 Best Restaurants in Brooklyn

372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201Phone: 347-689-3677 Visit Website. Gage & Tollner is one of Brooklyn’s most famed restaurants, having served locals and tourists on Fulton Street for more than a century. The current owners are working to restore the restaurant and make it an oyster and chop house that can keep providing memories and good meals for decades to come.

Visit Source →
Noms Magazine

27 Best Brooklyn Restaurants in NYC To Eat At In 2024 (+ What To Order)

Oddly located on a bustling street in downtown Brooklyn, Gage & Tollner stands out from its neighboring discount shops and empty storefronts. This posh, vintage restaurant is furnished as it came straight from the Art Nouveau period. Serving up exquisite American-French-English cuisine that comes in generous portions, coming here is like a reward to one’s self.

Visit Source →
Girl With The Passport

41 Local NYC Brunch Spots that are Amazing in 2024

In fact, if you head to Gage and Tollner, you will find that the lavish interiors will transport you back in time because it has a cool retro theme going. Mind you, people come here for all meals and not just brunch but at brunch you can eat everything you want. From their decadent steaks to oysters or just choose some of the more traditional eggs and bacon.

Visit Source →
monaghansrvc.com

The best 9 desserts in Brooklyn Heights New York City

The dessert offered at this establishment is certainly a highlight. The Alaskan cake, in particular, is a standout, with a rich and indulgent flavor that is sure to leave a lasting impression. The atmosphere of the restaurant is reminiscent of an upscale eatery in Brooklyn, with a chic and modern ambiance that creates a sophisticated dining experience.

Visit Source →
theurbanlist.com

10 Of The Best Steakhouses in NYC (2025 Edition)

It was Gage & Tollner's dedicated martini menu that first caught my attention, featuring seven variations of my favourite, boozy concoction. But there's a whole lot more to this oyster and chop house than just cocktails. Originally opened in 1879, it’s recently been revived and is now once again serving up classic steakhouse fare with a modern twist.

Visit Source →
Cozymeal

Brooklyn Restaurants | Top Spots in 2025

Gage & Tollner is a historic Downtown Brooklyn restaurant that’s the epitome of classic New York City luxury and panache. Gage & Tollner first opened in the 1890s, before closing in 2004 and opening once again in 2020. These days, this classic Brooklyn restaurant serves up cocktails and bites in a ballroom-esque setting that’s perfectly extravagant.

Visit Source →
Tasting Table

26 Best Steakhouses In NYC, Ranked

Gage & Tollner is a historic oyster and chophouse in Brooklyn that was a staple in the area for over 125 years. Just before the COVID-19 pandemic broke out, irrevocably changing the world and the culinary landscape, three local restaurateurs sought to restore Gage & Tollner to its former glory. The opening date was scheduled for March 2020.

Visit Source →
The Tour Guy

The 20 Best Restaurants in New York City in 2024

Gage & Tollner is a revival of an old classic near Brooklyn Heights. It’s a restaurant housed in a building that is so lovely, even its interior is protected by the city’s Landmark Preservation Commission. Travel back to the early 20th century as you dine on a selection from the raw bar or a veal chop beneath brass candelabras.

Visit Source →
Way Blog

Best Place to Eat in NYC

Gage & Tollner, which was established in 1892 at this location, was both a relative newcomer and an emblem of Old New York. However, it was revived well over a century later. In 2021, this august institution was reopened to immediate acclaim by a trio of Brooklyn hospitality professionals, including chef Sohui Kim.

Visit Source →
ROADBOOK

The best restaurants in New York City

Best for: A classic New York steak, set in a 19th-century buildingAddress: 372 Fulton Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201Price: Mains from 34 USD. New York City is a place that values tradition, but also expects that tradition to evolve. Gage & Tollner, which first opened in 1879 in downtown Brooklyn, has done just that.

Visit Source →
Devour Tours

Where to Go for the Absolute Best Steak in NYC

Several generations of Brooklynites knew of this handsome eatery on the Fulton Street Mall until it unceremoniously shut down in 2004 and a fast-food chain restaurant moved in. But in 2021, a steakhouse re-emerged here with the same name it had been two decades earlier. The walls were scrubbed.

Visit Source →
Frommers

Restaurants in New York City

No restaurant in New York City does as good a job at making special occasions special as Gage & Tollner. Which is part of its legacy. One of the oldest oyster and chops joints in the United States, the original iteration of the restaurant was opened in 1879 and was patronized…

Visit Source →
Tripleseat

4 Award-Winning Fine Dining Restaurants for Your Next Event

The team has inhaled much of what made G&T so beloved, including favorites from the eighties, when culinary giant Edna Lewis was head chef, like the she-crab soup, creamy as ever and laced with roe,” according to Esquire.

Visit Source →
Grub Street

Oysters - Grub Street

Visit Source →
FlyerTalk Forums

Dining in Downtown Brooklyn

Visit Source →