Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
A cherished family-owned pizzeria serving authentic New York-style pizza and Italian classics with genuine warmth and generous portions.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A cherished family-owned pizzeria serving authentic New York-style pizza and Italian classics with genuine warmth and generous portions.
Visit Early for Seating
The pizzeria is small, so arrive early to secure a table and avoid the dinner rush.
Dietary Options Available
Try their vegan options or gluten-free pizzas, with cauliflower crust being a highly recommended choice.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(407) 636-5333
Address
360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789, USA
Website
antonellaspizza.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic New York-Style Pizza
Experience traditional New York-style pizza with a perfect balance of crispy crust and flavorful toppings, a family recipe perfected over years.
Family-Owned Warmth
Enjoy genuine hospitality at this family-run pizzeria, where guests are treated like family, creating a welcoming and cozy atmosphere.
Generous Portions & Value
Indulge in generously sized calzones and dishes, offering great value for money, especially with their affordable lunch specials.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit Early for Seating
The pizzeria is small, so arrive early to secure a table and avoid the dinner rush.
Dietary Options Available
Try their vegan options or gluten-free pizzas, with cauliflower crust being a highly recommended choice.
Consider Delivery/Takeout
During busy times, their delivery service is robust and can be a quicker option than dining in.
Lunch Specials for Value
Opt for lunch specials for an affordable meal with generous portions, a great deal compared to dinner items.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit Early for Seating
The pizzeria is small, so arrive early to secure a table and avoid the dinner rush.
Dietary Options Available
Try their vegan options or gluten-free pizzas, with cauliflower crust being a highly recommended choice.
Consider Delivery/Takeout
During busy times, their delivery service is robust and can be a quicker option than dining in.
Lunch Specials for Value
Opt for lunch specials for an affordable meal with generous portions, a great deal compared to dinner items.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Antonella's Pizzeria is a family-owned Italian eatery praised for its authentic New York-style pizzas and warm hospitality. While many commend the delicious food, generous portions, and welcoming atmosphere, some reviews point to inconsistencies in food preparation and service during busy periods. Overall, it's a beloved spot for those seeking traditional Italian flavors in Winter Park.
"Was our 1st visit. Really nice family owned pizzeria. The owner was great! Was will to change the soup from original recipe to suit me. I really appreciate that but it was delicious as the original recipe. My husband had the Antonella Antipasto salad also delicious. Will be back to try a pizza next time, just wanted a light lunch today."
Mia Hagins
"The pizza was good. It was crispy not soggy. Was not impressed with the toppings not being cooked on the pizza. When you pick up your pizza everything falls off. At least the Pepperoni was cooked."
Angela Roberts
"Cleanliness is questionable. The guy there doesn't use gloves when handling slices. All kinda tools available and he wants to touch your food after he was just scratching his face and using his personal phone. Didn't even bother washing his hands.
The lady had on gloves but took a drink cup off the counter and added it back to the clean cups. Smh just gross
Pizza today was basically the thinnest slice of pizza. I love cheese but when the crust is similar to a paper towel, it's not really pizza. It's a quesdilla. Won't return
My go to spot was closed but definitely liked thr cheese slice. Love a place that does pizza by thr slice. Will go again"
SLutty Roo
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
They specialize in traditional New York-style pizza, known for its balance of crispy crust and flavorful toppings.
Yes, Antonella's Pizzeria offers vegan options and gluten-free pizzas, with cauliflower crust being a notable choice.
Yes, it's a family-owned establishment that treats guests like family, and they offer family-sized portions.
Information on parking availability is limited, but it's a small eatery and public transportation or ride-sharing might be convenient.
Portions are generally generous, with calzones and other dishes being quite substantial.
Due to its small size, it's recommended to visit early to avoid crowds, especially during peak dining hours.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Scott Joseph Orlando Restaurant Guide
Antonella’s Pizzeria is owned by members of the LaCommare family. If the LaCommare name is familiar to you it’s probably because you knew Stefano’s Trattoria in Winter Springs when the brother and sister’s parents, Stefano and Marie, were the owners. The older LaCommare’s sold the restaurant, including the name, and so the younger family members, who all had worked at the popular trattoria for many years, decided to get their own place.
The 25 best restaurants in Orlando right now, according to Yelp | Orlando
360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, (407) 636-5333“After a day of travelling my wife and I just wanted to grab something with no hassle so we bumped into Antonella's. The woman who helped us out was so friendly and kind and made some great recommendations for us since we were new in town. We got a pizza and some garlic knots and got to meet the family who owns the place.
Guide to the BEST Pizza In & Around Orlando
We are a family owned & operated pizzeria that offers local, fresh, traditional New York-Style pizza and delicious Italian food . Our hand spun pizza dough is made daily on the premises, along with fresh homemade sauces & entrees . Throughout the many years of hard work in this business, we have learned one important value; Treat our guest like our family!
19 Best Restaurants in Winter Park Fl You Must Try!
This is another wonderful pizza kitchen you won’t want to pass up especially if you’re looking for a great place to cater your party. Like most restaurants in Winter Park, Antonella’s offers tasty vegan options as well as gluten free pizzas. One of the best crusts to try is the cauliflower crust.
15 Must-Try Restaurants in Winter Park in 2025 - Dining Spots You Can't Miss
Antonella’s Pizzeria is a beloved pizza spot in Winter Park known for its authentic Italian flavors and welcoming atmosphere. This family-owned pizzeria has built a loyal following thanks to its delicious pizzas and friendly service.
13 Best Pizza Shops in Orlando, Florida
360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789Phone: (407) 636-5333 Visit Website. View this post on Instagram. A post shared by Antonellas Pizzeria (@antonellaspizzeria)
17 Best Pizza Places in Orlando
360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789Phone: 407-960-2160 Visit Website. View this post on Instagram. A post shared by Antonellas Pizzeria (@antonellaspizzeria)
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit