
City Park Grill
A historic Victorian-era pub, once a Hemingway haunt, now serving a global menu with live music and a cozy, classic rock vibe.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

City Park Grill

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A historic Victorian-era pub, once a Hemingway haunt, now serving a global menu with live music and a cozy, classic rock vibe.
Honey with Biscuits
Ask for honey with your biscuits for an extra touch of sweetness.
Complimentary Bread
Don't miss the free bread served at the start of your meal.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
American / Global
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Historic Hemingway Haunt
Step back in time at this Victorian-era building, a known haunt of Ernest Hemingway.

Cozy Atmosphere & Live Music
Enjoy a warm, inviting ambiance with classic rock tunes setting the mood.

Delicious Global Cuisine
Savor a diverse menu featuring globally inspired dishes, including hot fish and fries.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Honey with Biscuits
Ask for honey with your biscuits for an extra touch of sweetness.
Complimentary Bread
Don't miss the free bread served at the start of your meal.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To ensure quicker service, consider visiting during less busy times.
Tips
from all over the internet
Honey with Biscuits
Ask for honey with your biscuits for an extra touch of sweetness.
Complimentary Bread
Don't miss the free bread served at the start of your meal.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To ensure quicker service, consider visiting during less busy times.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
City Park Grill offers a unique dining experience with its historic atmosphere and varied menu. Many praise the delicious food, the cozy ambiance, and the friendly service, particularly noting dishes like the fish and chips and the signature biscuits. However, some diners have encountered slow service and inconsistencies in food quality, with occasional complaints about dishes being overcooked or not fresh.
"Had an amazing meal at City Park Grill. Friends who visit seasonally return every year. The staff was fantastic—our waitress Kelsey was especially sweet and expertly handled our dietary restrictions. The atmosphere was cozy and homey, with classic rock playing in the background."
amber Stoutenborough
"Great spot to stop. Our waitress was pleasant however she never asked us if we wanted beverages. We hunted her down for some. Then she just brought us the check. Never asked if we wanted anything else. We ordered additional stuff and she made the comment that she would have to get us a new check. The food was good."
TraciAnn Keim
"We stopped in just before 1:00 pm on a Sunday. Didn’t appear to be that busy, capacity at about 50%. Service was quite slow, which changed our agenda to one drink and and appetizer. From this time we sit our beer order 15 minutes to order, another 10 to arrive. The place is nice, staff friendly, hopefully service times improve."
Tommy Andrew
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, City Park Grill is housed in a historic Victorian-era building dating back to 1875, and was frequented by Ernest Hemingway.
The restaurant offers a diverse global menu, with popular dishes including fish and chips, steaks, and Jambalaya.
While reservations are not explicitly mentioned, it's advisable to call ahead, especially during peak times, to inquire about availability.
Yes, the restaurant has a gluten-free menu, but it's crucial to inform your server about any celiac or severe gluten allergies.
The atmosphere is cozy and historic, often featuring classic rock music, making it a comfortable and unique dining environment.
The restaurant description mentions live music, contributing to its vibrant and entertaining dining experience.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Petoskey Restaurants
Also the restaurant at the Little Traverse Bay gold course is very good. Don't miss Knot a Bar at the Bay Harbor complex. Noggin Room (basement of Stafford's Perry) very good for casual; good pizza, salads, sandwiches, specials.
The 14 Best Gluten-Free Spots with Outdoor Seating in Petoskey
I came here a week ago and am disappointed to say that my experience was less-than-stellar and in many ways just bad. I came here because it had good ratings for gluten-free food (I have celiac.) They had a gluten-free menu from which I ordered a bowl of soup and made sure it was put in as a gluten allergy so it would be taken seriously. After waiting for almost 30 minutes for a single bowl of soup (I was ordering to-go!) they brought out a box with the bowl of soup in it right next to two biscuits, which I was then told by the manager were not gluten-free.
19 BEST Petoskey Restaurants to Satisfy Your Cravings
City Park Grill is a restaurant housed in one of the most historic buildings in Petoskey. Located in a building that was constructed in 1875 and was originally used as a billiard hall reserved exclusively for men, City Park Grill is considered a must-visit attraction to uncover the history of the community. In addition to learning a little bit more about Petoskey, you can grab a scrumptious burger, an innovative sandwich, or a mouthwatering entrée from this popular local restaurant.
7 Best Restaurants in Petoskey, Michigan, in 2025
Located in downtown Petoskey, the City Park Grill is a historic Hemingway haunt history-buffs will love. You can imagine Hemingway writing and smoking at the second seat from the end of the bar, where the charred indentation from his cigar stains the otherwise polished bar. When Hemingway hung out here, the then saloon was the Annex, most likely the inspiration for the saloon in his story The Man of the World.
How To Spend A Weekend In Petoskey, MI
My favorites include Barrel Back in Walloon Lake, Cafe Sante in Boyne City, City Park Grille and Palette Bistro in downtown Petoskey, and Stafford’s Pier Restaurant in Harbor Springs. Fun fact, if you are here during the season for morel mushrooms many of the local restaurants will have morels as part of their menu.
Petoskey, MI – What to See and Do in a Day
This is an amazing restaurant and it is one you must dine in when visiting Petoskey. The restaurant is in one of the oldest buildings in Petoskey and it was originally constructed in 1875. The City Park Grill is one of the highest rated restaurants in the area and is known for some amazing dishes.
Where to eat in downtown Petoskey, Michigan
Head a block up to City Park Grill and enjoy their bone in House Brined Chicken Wings. We almost always order City Park’s Original Hot with a side of their delicious homemade blue cheese sauce (to die for). I even order the blue cheese sauce on the side for almost all my dishes at City Park Grill.
Area restaurants preparing Thanksgiving specials
City Park Grill — City Park Grill is offering a "Thanksgiving Feast for 4" to-go with prices ranging from $85.95 to over $100 depending on whether you order turkey, beef brisket or add on bottles of wine or extra sides. Orders can be placed by calling the restaurant at (231) 347-0101.
Petoskey Area Allergy-Friendly Restaurant List
City Park Grill – We dine here all of the time and they are amazing and understand the seriousness!. I commend the staff for always ensuring the food they prep is safe for our boys. They even bake the chicken fingers for our boys now instead of putting them into the deep fryer.
The Ultimate Petoskey Michigan Dining Guide
A member of the Wineguys Restaurant Group collection, it is located in one of the oldest buildings in Petoskey. It was built to be a males-only billiard parlor. Now it contains one of the best fine-dining restaurants with great recipes using local, seasonal items.
The Best Things To Do In Beautiful Petoskey, Michigan, Plus Where To Eat And Stay
City Park Grill, built in 1875, was initially a male-only billiard hall called McCarty Hall. Today City Park Grill serves everything from hamburgers to filet mignon. You can also enjoy a catch from the Great Lakes, with their whitefish and walleye.
How to spend a Michigan's Best day in Petoskey
During that terrible time in American history known as Prohibition, owner Frank Fotchtman made sure that Petoskey could still imbibe, building a myriad of secret underground tunnels to move hooch in and out of the building.
How Petoskey's City Park Grill is Celebrating 25 Years
City Park Grill is housed in one of Petoskey’s oldest buildings, originally constructed in 1875. McCarty Hall, as it was then known, was a males-only billiard parlor that offered cigars and “intoxicating beverages.
Petoskey Area Featured Dining Petoskey Area, Michigan
Surviving prohibition and volatile Northern Michigan winters, the City Park Grill is rich with history, but the menu is absolutely contemporary. Don’t miss the best live music in the North.
After 25 Years of Roasting, Great Coffee Doesn’t Just Happen
Roast & Toast is part of the Wineguys Restaurant Group collection, with sister restaurants City Park Grill and Palette Bistro, also in downtown Petoskey.
Things To Do In Petoskey With Kids – Oh My! Omaha
The City Park Grill is an old Hemingway haunt in Petoskey, Michigan. He usually sat in the second seat from the end of the bar.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit