Mister P Pizza
A casual pizzeria known for hand-tossed, brick-oven pies and traditional Italian dishes, offering comfort food for families.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Mister P Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A casual pizzeria known for hand-tossed, brick-oven pies and traditional Italian dishes, offering comfort food for families.
Check your order carefully
When ordering for pickup or delivery, it's recommended to double-check your order to avoid discrepancies.
Try the large plain pizza
Customers highly recommend the large plain pizza, often citing it as a standout menu item.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza, Italian
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Outstanding Large Plain Pizza
A must-try if you're in the area, this hand-tossed, brick-oven pizza is consistently praised for its deliciousness.
Diverse Italian Menu
Beyond pizza, enjoy traditional Italian dishes and hearty hoagies, catering to a variety of family preferences.
Family-Friendly Comfort Food
This local staple offers a relaxed atmosphere and comforting dishes that families have enjoyed for years.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Check your order carefully
When ordering for pickup or delivery, it's recommended to double-check your order to avoid discrepancies.
Try the large plain pizza
Customers highly recommend the large plain pizza, often citing it as a standout menu item.
Avoid peak dining hours
Visiting during off-peak times may lead to better service and a more attentive dining experience.
Tips
from all over the internet
Check your order carefully
When ordering for pickup or delivery, it's recommended to double-check your order to avoid discrepancies.
Try the large plain pizza
Customers highly recommend the large plain pizza, often citing it as a standout menu item.
Avoid peak dining hours
Visiting during off-peak times may lead to better service and a more attentive dining experience.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Mister P Pizza offers a diverse menu with many recommending their large plain pizza and hoagies. While some patrons praise the consistent quality and friendly service, others have reported issues with food preparation, order accuracy, and staff rudeness, leading to a mixed dining experience. Consistency and quality have been points of concern for some long-time customers.
"I picked up 2 cheese pizzas ordered over the phone for take out. I come here all the time so I didn’t think I had to check my food before leaving (Mr. P in Abington). My family comes here all the time and I never expected them to serve me an old pizza. I drove about 20 minutes home to find the second box of pizza was nothing like the first pizza. It was cold, old, dried up and hard; it literally felt like a frisbee. I immediately called them to complain, this is totally unacceptable! I was told some customers order “well done” pizza and the pizza may have been left on top of the oven and given to me. I never ask(ed) for “well done” and it should have never been served to me. I had time today so I drove 20 minutes back to Mr P Pizza to show them the pizza and request a refund for the inconvenience. This should have never happened. I was offered 2 “fresh pizzas” but at this point I declined because 2 “fresh pizzas” should have been given to me in the first place."
Tee
"Pizza was just super undercooked. Second star because it probably would have been pretty solid if it spend another few minutes in the oven. I ordered three slices and threw out two of them."
Rich Woods
"As I was waiting for my car to finish being services I decided to give this place a try. It a nice small place but has a very large menu. I settled on a slice of pepperoni pizza and some fries. One thing I like about this place is that you order your food and then the waitresses bring it to your table. So once I got the pizza it was a big slice. Crust was thin and crispy however the crust tasted bland and reminded me of school pizza from the 80's and 90's. Eating just the cheese and pepperoni was better than the crust. Fries were hot and unseasoned. Now I say this because no matter how.much salt I put on them to felt like there was none on them. I have to say I wasn't impressed and because of that I decided on not getting something to take home."
Marie Montgomery
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The large plain pizza is highly recommended, along with their hoagies and traditional Italian dishes.
Yes, some customers have reported receiving incorrect orders, so it's wise to verify your items.
Yes, Mister P Pizza is described as a casual eatery with dine-in service available.
To potentially receive better service, it is advised to avoid peak dining hours.
While specific dietary accommodations are not detailed, the menu includes a variety of Italian dishes.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit