Key Pizza
A beloved local pizza joint famous for its creative stuffed crust, generous toppings, and surprisingly excellent subs. A must-try for pizza lovers see...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Key Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved local pizza joint famous for its creative stuffed crust, generous toppings, and surprisingly excellent subs. A must-try for pizza lovers seeking something different.
"This place has never changed, offering delicious pizza with a unique calzone-like stuffed crust you'll crave!"
Plan for Waits
Arrive 15 minutes after your reservation time to avoid long waits during peak hours.
Check Online Prices
Online prices may differ from menu prices; always verify before placing an order.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(219) 844-3668
Address
7003 Kennedy Ave, Hammond, IN 46323, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Unique Stuffed Crust Pizza
Experience pizza with a twist! The stuffed or 'fold over' crust creates a calzone-like edge filled with gooey cheese, making every bite a delight.
Generous Toppings & Flavor
Enjoy pizzas loaded with your favorite toppings and a delicious, gooey, and salty cheese blend that complements the flavorful sauce perfectly.
Mouthwatering Subs
Don't overlook the subs! These huge, flavor-packed sandwiches like the 'Super All Meat' or 'BBQ Beef' are substantial enough for two meals.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Plan for Waits
Arrive 15 minutes after your reservation time to avoid long waits during peak hours.
Check Online Prices
Online prices may differ from menu prices; always verify before placing an order.
Confirm Order Accuracy
Double-check your order for any ingredient sensitivities before leaving, as exchanges might require a return trip.
Cash Payment Option
Consider bringing cash to potentially avoid card fees when paying for your order.
Tips
from all over the internet
Plan for Waits
Arrive 15 minutes after your reservation time to avoid long waits during peak hours.
Check Online Prices
Online prices may differ from menu prices; always verify before placing an order.
Confirm Order Accuracy
Double-check your order for any ingredient sensitivities before leaving, as exchanges might require a return trip.
Cash Payment Option
Consider bringing cash to potentially avoid card fees when paying for your order.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Key Pizza is praised for its unique stuffed crust pizzas with generous toppings and flavorful cheese. Many reviewers highlight the delicious subs as well, noting their substantial size. However, some recent reviews mention issues with new ownership, including price increases and inconsistent phone service/delivery availability.
"Amazing stuffed crust pizza! The owner and workers really care about the food that they create. Big fan!"
Umar Haque
"I haven't eaten there in years. Someone told me is was under new ownership. If this is true I couldn't tell. Food and Service was great!"
Msap
"Pizza is good, but it's really a go to place for subs. Super Subs took it to another level. Huge subs. Don't be fooled by the price. You'll get two meals out of it. Super All Meat, BBQ beef, meatball ( my favorites ) plus many more. Support your local business."
Steven
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The stuffed crust creates a calzone-like edge filled with cheese, making each slice more decadent and flavorful.
Many customers rave about the subs, calling them 'huge' and 'super,' often suggesting they are large enough for two meals.
Popular choices include 'Meat Lovers,' 'Mario,' and 'Supreme,' featuring a variety of meats and vegetables.
While some reviews indicate delivery is no longer available, it's best to call and confirm directly.
Reservations are not mentioned, but arriving 15 minutes after your estimated time can help avoid waits during busy periods.
Some recent customers have noted price increases and changes in service under new ownership.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit