
Benchwarmers Bagels
A celebrated bagel shop in Raleigh, known for its artisanal wood-fired bagels, innovative cream cheese, and a cozy atmosphere.

Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

Benchwarmers Bagels

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A celebrated bagel shop in Raleigh, known for its artisanal wood-fired bagels, innovative cream cheese, and a cozy atmosphere.
"These are the best bagels in Raleigh, and it's not up for debate."
Beat the Weekend Rush
Visit during weekdays for a more relaxed experience and quicker service compared to crowded weekends.
Beat the Lines
During peak hours, consider ordering online for pickup to skip potentially long wait times.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
Bagel Shop / Coffee Shop / Pizza Restaurant
Price
Mid-range
Address
500 E Davie St STE 107, Raleigh, NC 27601, USA
Website
benchwarmersbagels.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Wood-Fired Bagels
Experience delicious, oversized bagels crafted with heirloom grains and organic flour in a traditional wood-fired oven.

Unique Cream Cheese Flavors
Beyond classic cream cheese, explore exciting spreads like pimento cheese and spicy Carolina reaper for an adventurous taste.

Butterscotch Coffee
A must-try sweet treat, their butterscotch coffee offers a special touch that elevates the entire dining experience.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Beat the Weekend Rush
Visit during weekdays for a more relaxed experience and quicker service compared to crowded weekends.
Beat the Lines
During peak hours, consider ordering online for pickup to skip potentially long wait times.
Unique Flavor Adventures
Dare to try their distinctive cream cheese spreads like pimento cheese or Carolina reaper for a flavor explosion.
For Sourdough Lovers
If you enjoy sourdough notes, their crispy dark outside bagel with a slightly tangy flavor is highly recommended.
Tips
from all over the internet
Beat the Weekend Rush
Visit during weekdays for a more relaxed experience and quicker service compared to crowded weekends.
Beat the Lines
During peak hours, consider ordering online for pickup to skip potentially long wait times.
Unique Flavor Adventures
Dare to try their distinctive cream cheese spreads like pimento cheese or Carolina reaper for a flavor explosion.
For Sourdough Lovers
If you enjoy sourdough notes, their crispy dark outside bagel with a slightly tangy flavor is highly recommended.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Benchwarmers Bagels garners praise for its unique wood-fired bagels and creative cream cheese flavors, with many customers highlighting the friendly service and cozy atmosphere within Transfer Co. Food Hall. However, some reviews point to inconsistency in bagel quality, with occasional issues of being burnt or soggy, and long wait times, particularly on weekends.
"Excellent bagel gem inside Transfer Co. Food Hall. Found out it doubles as a pizza shop after 5pm, pure genius. Missed the pies this time but a sure return trip just based on the level bagel goodness from here."
Raymond Culbert
"I had high expectations given that this place is rated as one of the top 25 bagel stores in the USA, but unfortunately, the bagels were a major disappointment. They were noticeably burnt, compromising both flavor and texture, and certainly not worth the premium price. Benchwarmer bagels lacked the soft interior and perfect crust that make a bagel truly exceptional. For the price and reputation, I expected much more. I would hesitate to return or recommend it based on this experience."
Adam Sch
"Ohmygoodness. This place is so quaint and beautiful. There is seating at the counter or any where you want to sit. The bagels are huge and delicious. Did the mention the Butterscotch coffee"
catty cox
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
They use heirloom grains, organic flour, and a wood-fired oven for their bagels, and offer unique cream cheese spreads.
Most reviews are positive, but some customers have reported inconsistent quality, with occasional issues of bagels being burnt or soggy.
They offer unique cream cheese spreads like pimento cheese and Carolina reaper, as well as specialty items like butterscotch coffee.
Yes, weekends tend to be very crowded with long wait times. Visiting on weekdays is recommended for a quicker experience.
Yes, Benchwarmers serves unique wood-fired pizza on Friday and Saturday nights.
Ordering online for pickup during peak hours is a good option to avoid long lines.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
23 Of Our Favorite Downtown Raleigh Restaurants For All Tastes!
Not a restaurant I know, but hey, it’s about food and if you’re looking for bagels in downtown, Benchwarmers is one of the most popular bagel shops in Raleigh and the best in the downtown area. Benchwarmers use a wood-fired oven, heirloom grains, extended fermentation, and fresh-milled, pre-fermented 100% organic flour to make their modern bagels. They have 6 styles of bagels including the usual classics and some unique cream cheese spreads including pimento cheese, Maitre d’hotel (herby + lemon), Carolina reaper (spicey), pecan butterscotch, and a cashew (vegan).
Best Restaurants in Downtown Raleigh, NC
Benchwarmers, serving wood-fired bagels and craft coffee in downtown Raleigh's Transfer Co. Food Hall, is an exciting collaboration from the masterminds behind Jubala Coffee—one of Raleigh's beloved, local coffee shops—and Boulted Bread, a bakery that earned acclaim with one of Food & Wine’s Top Croissants in America and Bon Appétit’s Best New Bakeries in 2016. Not your average bagel shop, the menu—the work of chef John Knox—includes unique sandwiches like a house-cured lox with deviled egg spread and duck rillette with sour cherries and pickled onions.
Where Are the Best Bagels in Raleigh?
One of the newest bagel shops in the area is Brandwein’s Bagels in Chapel Hill. Since opening their doors, they have taken the local foodie community by storm, being referred to as the best bagel shop in the Triangle by more than one blogger. Our own Real-Tour Experience partner, Megan at NC Eat & Play even said ” Thank you, @brandweinsbagels for blessing my life with some of the best bagels I’ve ever had.
Favorite Local Takeout Spots in Downtown Raleigh
While Benchwarmer’s makes some great bagel sandwiches and other treats in the mornings, on Friday and Saturday nights, they create some of the best, unique pizza around. Their cheese pizza is almost like a marriage of regular pizza and focaccia, highlighting simple, wonderful ingredients on an incredible crust. Our order: Cheese pizza + side of ranch
10 Great Sandwiches in Raleigh
Food Hall, Benchwarmers offers breakfast sandwiches on their freshly baked bagels, and, yes, they do taste as good as they look. View this post on Instagram. A post shared by benchwarmers (@benchwarmersbagels) on Aug 11, 2020 at 9:03am PDT
35 Best Restaurants in Raleigh, NC That Locals Love
Food Hall, Benchwarmers Bagels is a great breakfast on the run. Their homemade bagels served plain, with cream cheese, or as a sandwich are delicious comfort food to kick your day of right. Note: Closed on Mondays
FINDER: Where to Eat, Drink, Shop, and Play in Downtown Raleigh
Food Hall gang, Benchwarmers—a collaboration between Josh Bellamy and Sam Kirkpatrick of Boulted Bread and Andrew Cash of Jubala Coffee—prides itself on giving equal attention to both coffee and bagel.
75 Date Ideas in Raleigh, NC: Romantic Things To Do in Raleigh
This restaurant serves a variety of delicious bagels that I'm sure you'll love. Moreover, these bagels come with a large variety of delicious toppings. So, there's likely a bagel you'll like.
Brunch restaurants in Raleigh, NC
Davie St. | Tuesday-Friday, 7 a.m.-2 p.m.; Saturday-Sunday, 8 a.m.-2 p.m. | This shop takes bagel sandwiches to the next level — and food magazine Bon Appétit agrees.
Raleigh, NC bakery makes best pastries in the state: Yelp
Since its start in 2014, the team behind the bakery also has launched Benchwarmers Bagels and Bright Spot Donuts, both in Raleigh, The News & Observer reported.
Best of Raleigh, NC (According to Residents)
But, I have to say – the menu isn't very “New York” in its options, nor is it trying to be. They have southern twists on sandwiches and creative cream cheeses.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit