We never actually got to go to Goodnight Fatty’s because the line was so long it wrapped around the block – that’s how good it is. But my brother and sister-in-law and their friends all rave about the weekend pop up joint that sells the most amazing cookies and soft-serve ice cream. And judging by the smell alone, their cookies must be nothing short of heaven. Part of their charm is that they’re only open on the weekends, and only in the evening (after 5 on Friday and Saturday, after 2 on Sunday), selling rotating concoctions you can’t get anywhere else, like frosted animal cracker cookies, peanut butter and Reese’s Pieces cookies, and your traditional cookie staples.

When I visited, Goodnight Fatty was a late-night cookie “speakeasy” open only on the weekends, in an unmarked storefront down a creepy-looking alley. They’ve since moved to a storefront near the Salem Witch Museum, and are open in the morning for breakfast “chubbies” and afternoon and evening for small-batch treats, including vegan flavors, and cooies with soft-serve ice cream. Speaking of cold treats, Melt serves a dozen-plus homemade ice cream flavors (including vegan), and usually has a line snaking around the block.

Goodnight Fatty is a cookie shop in Salem with an almost cult-like following. This shop serves up some of the most delicious and unique cookies in town, offering a sweet treat to locals and tourists alike. Defying the traditional notion of a “cookie” with their innovative flavors and soft, chewy texture, these late-night baked goods have quickly topped the list of best places to eat in Salem, MA in October.

If there’s a better name for a cookie than a “fatty”, we have yet to discover it. Every weekend, Goodnight Fatty offers a new line up of cookie flavors, which remain secret until you order and are only available after 6pm. To enjoy one (or more!) of their fatties, you can walk up to their counter, order online for pickup, or request a Fatty Drop (you know, what boring people call delivery).

We’ve said these exact words a million times late in the evening after dinner and the answer has been any number of things, from cake to pie to cookies. Luckily, we live somewhere we can easily fulfill that craving. The story of Goodnight Fatty’s humble beginnings are the same, except founders Erik Sayce and Jennifer Pullen weren't as fortunate and decided to do something about it.

⭐️⭐️⭐️ Goodnight Fatty: They make late-night cookies, and they also have some breakfast items. You have to continue all the way down Church Street as it turns into Brown Street and meets Hawthorne Blvd to get here. (Right next to the Salem Witch Museum) GO HERE. They’re only open Fri-Sun nights and their cookie selection changes every weekend.

Goodnight Fatty in Salem, MA, offers a delightful dessert experience with takeaway, delivery, and dine-in options. Goodnight Fatty has you covered whether you’re in the mood for a sweet treat to enjoy at home or to savor in a cozy setting. Their menu features a variety of delicious cookies and other desserts that will satisfy any sweet tooth.

One thing that makes Goodnight Fatty unique is that they don’t advertise their menu until you start ordering. Once you start your order, you can see the selection of fatties that are being sold that day. There have been smores fatties, sprinkle fatties, and even more tasty treats at this Salem bakery.

Sweeten your Salem experience with a visit to Goodnight Fatty. This late-night dessert destination serves up indulgent, freshly baked cookies in a variety of tempting flavors. From classic favorites to inventive combinations, Goodnight Fatty is your go-to spot for satisfying sweet cravings after dark.

Goodnight Fatty can be located in 1 Washington Square, Salem, MA. I’m not exaggerating when I say that the cookies here are mouth watering!. Now, the cookie shops opens its door at 7 PM, yep, that’s right; and, even though it opens so late, there will always be a line of people waiting out front.

Let me start by saying that the cookies at Goodnight Fatty are simply phenomenal. Every bite is an explosion of flavors that will leave you wanting more. From classic favorites like chocolate chip to unique creations like peanut butter chocolate pretzel, there is a cookie for everyone's taste.

It’s what they call their ooey gooey thick cookies served right out of the oven!. Goodnight Fatty is a late-night cookie shop serving gourmet cookies paired with soft serve ice cream and milk. It’s only open on the weekends and every weekend there’s a new line of three epic cookie options.

At the Carriage House in Salem, across from the Commons, lies Goodnight Fatty. Their amusing name and social media presence may make you giggle, but their cookies are no laughing matter. Grab a cup of milk (dairy or non-dairy) with an order of multiple flavored cookies, and thank me later.

Goodnight Fatty’s - Giant, ooey and gooey warm cookies served late nights and on the weekends. The menu is always changing between different fun flavors. Can be hard to miss as it’s located behind a wall but there is a giant red food truck to signal your way.

Goodnight Fatty ($): A MUST go for any sweet tooth sufferer out there. Open only on the weekends, Goodnight Fatty serves up freshly baked, warm cookies, what they call ‘fatty’s’, along with milk and games to keep us all feeling like children at heart.

For romantics with a sweet tooth, Goodnight Fatty is not to be missed. Founded by a couple intending to raise money for their wedding, this weekend cookie pop-up is now a local staple. Look for it in the alley behind Rockafellas.

End your day in Salem with an indulgent treat at Goodnight Fatty, which is open late. They are well known for their ‘fatties,’ which are thick, juicy cookies. The flavors change weekly and are kept secret.

For treats Goodnight Fatty has amazing cookies - they are only open at night until 10 pm and their cookie menu drops just before opening. Really inventive combos. Best ice cream is Holy Cow or E.W.

Goodnight Fatty slings some of the best cookies you’ll have, so I highly suggest swinging by. They operate on Friday and Saturday nights only so be sure to schedule them in during your visit.

For a night cap, we headed to Goodnight Fatty and grabbed their warm cookies and they were amazing!!. Add this to your must-do list!