Settler
Settler offers elevated New American cuisine with Mediterranean influences in a rustic-chic Salem setting, focusing on scratch-made dishes and local i...
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Settler
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Settler offers elevated New American cuisine with Mediterranean influences in a rustic-chic Salem setting, focusing on scratch-made dishes and local ingredients.
"A true hidden gem in Salem with phenomenal food and an intimate, welcoming atmosphere."
Try Unique House-Made Items
Don't miss the house-made sourdough bread and the chocolate tort for a truly special treat.
Explore Recommended Dishes
Opt for highlighted dishes like hot apple cider, or explore seasonal specials with confidence.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
New American / Mediterranean
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Handmade Pasta Creations
Experience unique, fresh, house-made pastas like Mafalde Cacio e Pepe and Ricotta Gnocchi, crafted with Mediterranean-inspired flair.
Mediterranean-Inspired Delights
Savor elevated New American dishes with strong Mediterranean influences, using fresh, local ingredients.
Cozy & Chic Atmosphere
Enjoy an intimate dining experience in a rustic-chic venue, perfect for dates or special occasions.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try Unique House-Made Items
Don't miss the house-made sourdough bread and the chocolate tort for a truly special treat.
Explore Recommended Dishes
Opt for highlighted dishes like hot apple cider, or explore seasonal specials with confidence.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To avoid crowds and enjoy a more relaxed meal, consider visiting during non-peak times.
Savor the Pasta
The handmade pasta dishes are a standout, praised for their freshness and delicious flavors.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try Unique House-Made Items
Don't miss the house-made sourdough bread and the chocolate tort for a truly special treat.
Explore Recommended Dishes
Opt for highlighted dishes like hot apple cider, or explore seasonal specials with confidence.
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
To avoid crowds and enjoy a more relaxed meal, consider visiting during non-peak times.
Savor the Pasta
The handmade pasta dishes are a standout, praised for their freshness and delicious flavors.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Settler receives high praise for its creative, high-quality Mediterranean-inspired New American cuisine and impeccable service. Diners consistently rave about the fresh, house-made pastas and unique flavor combinations. While many find the ambiance intimate and chic, a few mention that pricing can feel a bit high, and one reviewer had a particularly disappointing experience with hosting and table availability during a busy season.
"Ross was an amazing server. Honestly all the staff was very service oriented. I love the hot cider service, that's a nice touch. I had the grilled octopus, beef duo, chocolate cheesecake and a shot of espresso. Everything was very amazing. The Octopus was slightly over seasoned but cooked to perfection, the beef duo was a rare treat as it came with a strip and short rip on polenta. I WILL BE BACK. Me ordering the cheesecake was overkill as I was full. I also need to acknowledge the 50 year sourdough bread 🤌"
Ryan Brown
"A very intimate and cozy place with really phenomenal food choices. We absolutely loved everything that was served. This restaurant offers an ideal environment for a date, but it is also very kid-friendly. I would definitely return…"
Oksana Buttita
"A true Hidden Gen in Salem!
We had such a great time at Settler. From the moment we arrived, we felt welcomed — the host even opened the door for us with a smile and walked us straight to our table. Our server was super friendly and explained the menu in detail, which we really appreciated.
We started with three small plates: the Meze (falafel, hummus with pomegranate, and a cucumber-orange salad) was super fresh and flavorful. The local mushrooms with a soft egg in the center were my wife’s favorite — rich, earthy, and perfectly cooked. And the charred Spanish octopus was tender and full of flavor, paired nicely with gigante beans and preserved lemon.
Our main dish was a special handmade pasta (not on the menu) with fennel, crispy jamón serrano, and Parmesan — so delicious and well balanced. We also had a side of charred brassicas with an amazing dressing — perfectly cooked and packed with flavor.
Dessert was next level: handmade baklava with hazelnuts and tajín ice cream — such a unique combo and really tasty.
This place is a hidden gem in Salem. You can tell the food is made with care and attention to detail. We’ll definitely be back!"
Juan Salcedo
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Settler serves elevated New American dishes with Mediterranean influences, emphasizing fresh, local, and scratch-made ingredients.
Yes, reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak seasons, as the restaurant is popular and intimate.
Standout dishes include the handmade pastas, fresh oysters, baba ganoush, and desserts like the chocolate tort.
In October, Settler offers a prix fixe menu, and a la carte dining may not be available. The menu can change daily.
Yes, Settler is described as an intimate and cozy place, ideal for a date night or a special occasion.
The restaurant has a rustic-chic ambiance, suggesting smart casual attire is appropriate.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The 52 Best Restaurants, Cafes, and More in Salem Right Now
Chef Aaron Chambers—a longtime alum of restaurants by acclaimed chef Daniel Boulud, including Boston’s now-closed Bar Boulud—has struck out on his own to open a destination-worthy, fancy-but-not-unfriendly restaurant in Salem with his wife Shanna. Settler is all about local sourcing, scratch-made food, and Mediterranean influences, which results in dishes like local clams with Calabrian chili and fennel; kofta spiced lamb ragu with pumpkin hummus; and Hudson Valley chicken with freekeh and smoked eggplant. (Note: In October, à la carte dining is not available; all diners will get the $75 prix fixe menu.) Stay tuned: The Chambers are opening a French bistro-inspired restaurant, Bernadette, nearby around November 2024.
Salem Restaurants - Where To Eat and Drink in Salem
2 Lynde St. 978-744-2094.With a long history working at Michelin-starred restaurants across the UK, Dubai, and US, Chef Aaron introduces a simple and approachable Mediterranean menu to Salem’s culinary scene. From the small family-run farm’s produce to the halibut off Marblehead docks, Chef’s food represents our community, building connection across farmers, fishers, cooks, and locals through food.
All Restaurants in Salem, Massachusetts, United States
Nestled in the heart of Salem, our cozy and chic neighborhood spot is where nearly everything you enjoy is made in-house—from our distinctly sour sourdough bread to our hand-shaped agnolotti. We’re deeply dedicated to our culinary craft, and we’re equally passionate about extending the warmth and familiarity of our family to every guest who walks through our doors. Our menu
10 Best Restaurants To Visit In Salem With Themed Seasonal Menus
Shops and historic buildings surrounded by fall foliage in the autumn on High Street in Harper's Ferry, West Virginia, USA, an underrated US mountain town. Settler of Salem, Massachusets, is an idyllic chic cafe and restaurant located on Lynde Street. Its prime location in a quiet and pretty part of town only adds to the overall calming and welcoming environment of the place.
10 Best Restaurants in Salem, MA 2023
Settler is an eclectic approach to rustic dining, inspired by french cuisine and New England flavors. They easily combine fine-dining and family values, making Settler an extension of the owners’ traits and traditions. They use high-quality ingredients sourced locally and as fresh as they can get.
SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS TRAVEL GUIDE - A “LOCALS” GUIDE FOR TOP FOOD, SHOPS AND ATTRACTIONS
Settler - This is a wonderful spot to go with a friend or your partner. Small, and cozy with delicious comfort meals. The menu is “small” compared to other larger restaurants, but you can tell every dish is carefully crafted to be absolutely amazing.
7 Delicious Restaurants To Try In Salem, Massachusetts
Settler is a “New American restaurant inspired by the rustic and handmade approach to french cookery.” The restaurant features a smaller, more focused menu that changes on a daily basis, making every visit a new food experience.
Salem for Dinner's Best Restaurants [Updated 2025]
Let me start by saying, my visit to Settler was absolutely incredible!. From the moment I stepped through the doors, I knew I was in for a treat. Firstly, I must rave about their delicious cocktails.
Hallowed Ground (Speakeasy
Settler is a New American restaurant inspired by the rustic and handmade approach to french cookery. It is a New American restaurant inspired by the rustic and handmade approach to […]
What to eat in Salem Massachusetts
I’d give it second place after Settler for amazing fine dining. Get the popovers and squash bisque for sure. Brunch is my favorite.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit