Lesters Taco shop & Pizzaria
Authentic Mexican food with Nicaraguan roots and customizable burritos in a lively sports bar setting.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Lesters Taco shop & Pizzaria
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Authentic Mexican food with Nicaraguan roots and customizable burritos in a lively sports bar setting.
Try the Soft Tacos
Regular customers highly recommend the soft tacos for an excellent and authentic Mexican food experience.
Build Your Own Burrito
Opt for the customizable breakfast burritos, offering a delicious and affordable way to start your day.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Mexican
Price
Mid-range
Address
266 Delaware Ave Suite 916, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Nicaraguan Recipes
Experience genuine Mexican food crafted from original family Nicaraguan recipes, offering a unique culinary journey.
Build-Your-Own Breakfast Burritos
Customize your morning meal with a variety of meats and toppings, just like Subway, at an affordable price.
Vibrant Sports Bar Ambiance
A comfortable atmosphere and a cool bar area, perfect for watching sports games and enjoying drinks with friends.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Soft Tacos
Regular customers highly recommend the soft tacos for an excellent and authentic Mexican food experience.
Build Your Own Burrito
Opt for the customizable breakfast burritos, offering a delicious and affordable way to start your day.
Mindful of Pricing
Some items may be perceived as pricier compared to other island options. Consider value for money.
Avoid Peak Hours
Visit during off-peak times to circumvent potential slow service, even if lines appear short.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Soft Tacos
Regular customers highly recommend the soft tacos for an excellent and authentic Mexican food experience.
Build Your Own Burrito
Opt for the customizable breakfast burritos, offering a delicious and affordable way to start your day.
Mindful of Pricing
Some items may be perceived as pricier compared to other island options. Consider value for money.
Avoid Peak Hours
Visit during off-peak times to circumvent potential slow service, even if lines appear short.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners praise Lesters Taco shop for its authentic Nicaraguan recipes and the unique build-your-own breakfast burrito option. While the food is often described as delicious and the atmosphere is great for sports fans, some reviews mention slow service and concerns about value for money. Cleanliness of restrooms has also been a point of concern for some.
"Fantastic authentic Mexican food. The soft tacos were excellent and we eat there EVERY time we come to the island. I love it and wish there was one in southern Ohio where I live!!"
Steven Hoover
"Stopped to try a quick snack at this taco stand. Had plenty of different choices of meats and toppings. Just okay and $5 each Taco."
Jeff W
"The best burritos I’ve ever had in my life. My husband and I have been going to PIB once a year and we always get the burrito each night"
Tricia Zavala
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The restaurant prides itself on serving authentic Mexican food made from original family Nicaraguan recipes. They emphasize fresh ingredients, even stating they don't use a freezer.
The soft tacos are highly recommended by regular customers. Additionally, the build-your-own breakfast burritos are a popular and customizable choice.
The restaurant offers a comfortable atmosphere and a variety of food options that can appeal to families. However, some reviews note potential issues with service speed and restroom cleanliness.
While some items are considered affordable, particularly the breakfast burritos, other dishes might be perceived as pricier compared to similar options elsewhere.
To avoid potential slow service, it's recommended to visit during off-peak hours, even if the lines do not appear long.
While specific vegetarian options are not detailed, the build-your-own burrito style may allow for customization with vegetable-based fillings.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Put-in-Bay Restaurants | 30+ Delicious Fun Filled Choices
Lesters Taco Shop is Put-in-Bay’s newest restaurant, and wow, has it ever been a sensation!. Food made from original family Nicaraguan recipes!. The ingredients are so fresh they don’t even have a freezer!
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit