If you want an all-you-can-eat buffet for breakfast in Sarasota, Der Dutchman is where it’s at!. This Amish restaurant has every breakfast comfort food you can imagine and it’s the perfect place for a large family gathering which is why we typically visit them at least once a year with Logan’s family while they are in Sarasota during the winter. Aside from the breakfast buffet, let’s talk about donuts… you need to try the orange frosted cake donut.

There’s no better place to sample that than at Der Dutchman, which serves strips of crispy bacon, magnificent hash browns and big, doughy biscuits. You’ll see plenty of beards and bonnets here, of course, but along with Pinecraft neighbors, the eatery also attracts working-class people filling up before a day spent repairing roofs and pouring concrete. 3713 Bahia Vista St., Sarasota, (941) 955-8007, dhgroup.com

Known for its hearty and traditional Amish family meals, Der Dutchman is home to one of the biggest buffets in town. In addition to their staggering buffet options, the restaurant also features a sizable bakery complete with cakes, pies, and our favorite, donuts!. Their donut assortment features cake and yeast donuts as well as apple fritters and long Johns the length of your forearm.

Der Dutchman is a casual Amish kitchen with a wonderful bakery of classic donuts, pies, and other treats!. If you have a spare morning, we’d recommend grabbing breakfast here at their incredible breakfast buffet, but you have to remember to save room for a few donuts before you leave!. Their donuts are homemade and always warm from coming right out of the oven!

Last but certainly not least, Der Dutchman Restaurant will transport you to a world of nostalgia with its traditional Amish-style breakfast dishes and baked goods. Immerse yourself in the flavors of bygone days with their homemade cinnamon rolls, farm-fresh eggs, and comforting breakfast casseroles. The experience at Der Dutchman is a true breakfast revelation.

Giant pies, cinnamon rolls bigger than your head, fry pies filled with every fruity goodness imaginable — Der Dutchman is a must-visit (and you’ll leave with a bag full of goodies). Pet-friendly: Sadly, no — but their food is so good, you’ll forgive them. Neighborhood Vibes: Pinecraft is famous for its Amish and Mennonite community.

Dutchman Hospitality, Der Dutchman's parent company, headquartered in Walnut Creek, Ohio, opened its first Der Dutchman Restaurant 54 years ago. The restaurant features foods that pay homage to the Midwest Amish and Mennonite traditions, a press release states, including chicken, noodles, dressing and mashed potatoes.

Der Dutchman in Sarasota is a haven for those seeking a taste of Amish Country hospitality. While their menu features everything from hearty meals to fresh-baked pies, one delightful treat stands out – their legendary Red Velvet Donut. A Red Velvet Dream: Der Dutchman’s Red Velvet Donut isn’t your average donut.

Der Dutchman on Bahia Vista Street is one of the most well-known of these establishments. Their ample dining areas can accommodate large parties easily, so if you have a sizable group going out together this is a good place to go. Their menu contains a tasty variety of home-style dishes from which to choose.

And at Yoder's Restaurant and Der Dutchman Restaurant, which reside in the city's Pinecraft neighborhood, diners can sample traditional Amish and Mennonite items, including pecan sticky buns, potato cakes and shoofly pie (a dessert with a coffee cake topping and a molasses bottom).

If you're down in the Sarasota area, there are a handful of Amish restaurants that don't exactly fry chicken "southern" style, but they do make very, very good fried chicken. Yoders and Der Dutchman come to mind (as I've eaten at both in the last week!).

Savor hearty, homestyle flavors at Der Dutchman, a beloved Amish kitchen known for its comforting dishes and enticing bakery. You’ll find something indulgent and delicious at Der Dutchman, whether sweet or savory.