Flavio’s Bar
1 / 10

Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar Siesta Key

,

Authentic Italian dining with wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas in a warm, rustic setting with an extensive wine and cocktail selection.

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Flavio’s Bar

Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar Siesta Key

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Authentic Italian dining with wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas in a warm, rustic setting with an extensive wine and cocktail selection.

"Best food we have had here, so fresh, so much flavor!"

TIP

Reservations Recommended

Make reservations in advance, especially during peak times or weekends, to ensure a table.

Try Specialty Pizzas

Don't miss specialty pizzas like prosciutto e arugola or the pizza del giorno for unique flavor combinations.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens 4PM

Cuisine

Italian

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(941) 349-0995

Address

5239 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, USA

Insta-Factor

Medium

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Authentic Neapolitan Pizza

Authentic Neapolitan Pizza

Indulge in authentic Neapolitan pizza crafted with care and baked to perfection in a brick oven, boasting a crispy yet chewy crust.

Siesta Key Restaurants Guide: Discovering Dining Delights!!Best Pizza on Siesta Key
Handmade Pasta Dishes

Handmade Pasta Dishes

Savor delicious Italian cuisine including handmade pasta dishes like fettuccine carbonara and ricotta and spinach ravioli.

Delicious Italian Restaurants in Sarasota, FLGoogle Review
Extensive Wine & Martini Selection

Extensive Wine & Martini Selection

Explore an extensive wine selection to perfectly pair with your meal, or enjoy a handcrafted martini from their dedicated bar.

15 great Siesta Key Village restaurants, bars and nightclubsGoogle Review
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Reservations Recommended

Make reservations in advance, especially during peak times or weekends, to ensure a table.

Try Specialty Pizzas

Don't miss specialty pizzas like prosciutto e arugola or the pizza del giorno for unique flavor combinations.

Savor the Martinis

Martini enthusiasts should try the lemondrop martini, expertly made by their bartenders.

Choose Your Ambiance

Dine indoors near the wood-fired oven for an authentic ambiance or enjoy the charming outdoor patio.

Tips

from all over the internet

Reservations Recommended

Make reservations in advance, especially during peak times or weekends, to ensure a table.

Try Specialty Pizzas

Don't miss specialty pizzas like prosciutto e arugola or the pizza del giorno for unique flavor combinations.

Savor the Martinis

Martini enthusiasts should try the lemondrop martini, expertly made by their bartenders.

Choose Your Ambiance

Dine indoors near the wood-fired oven for an authentic ambiance or enjoy the charming outdoor patio.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar is lauded for its authentic Italian cuisine, particularly its delicious brick oven pizzas and handmade pasta dishes. Diners appreciate the warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly service, with many highlighting the extensive wine selection and expertly made martinis. While most reviews are glowing, a few patrons have noted instances of slow service.

"We recently got takeout from this lovely restaurant, and even though we didn't dine in this time, we were so impressed that we're excited to come back soon! The place has a beautiful, classy vibe, and the staff seems super professional and friendly. My husband and I have had their pizza a few times and is absolutely delicious—so authentically Italian! I can’t wait to dine in and explore more of their menu. They’re located in Siesta Key Village and offer both indoor and outdoor dining options, plus valet service, which is such a nice perk. We can’t wait to go back!"

Aida B.

"If you are looking for authentic Italian food with a great atmosphere this is the place! We stumbled upon Flavio’s after the sunset in siesta key and were so glad we did. Scratch made dishes, indoor or outdoor dinning, authentic charm."

zachary abrams

"Wow! We've been coming to siesta key for years and years, and never stopped at Flavio's. It is a new must for us, and we will be back regularly. Lucy, the bartender, did an excellent job. The food was great and the service was wonderful."

Michele Maas

What People Like

Authentic brick oven pizza
Delicious handmade pasta
Friendly and attentive service

What People Dislike

Occasional slow service

Frequently Asked Questions

Flavio's is famous for its authentic Neapolitan brick oven pizzas and handmade pasta dishes like fettuccine carbonara and ravioli.

Siesta Key Restaurants Guide: Discovering Dining Delights!!Google Review

Yes, they boast an extensive wine selection, perfect for pairing with any of their Italian specialties.

15 great Siesta Key Village restaurants, bars and nightclubsGoogle Review

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak times or on weekends, to ensure you get a table.

The restaurant offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with options to dine indoors near the wood-fired oven or on a charming patio.

Google Review

Absolutely! Flavio's has a dedicated bar and is known for making excellent martinis, including a popular lemondrop martini.

Google Review

While specific details are not provided, they offer a variety of classic Italian dishes. It's best to inquire directly about dietary accommodations.

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

The Culture Trip

Siesta Key's Best Restaurants You Should Try, Florida

Flavio’s Brick Oven Pizza is an authentic Italian restaurant featuring made-from-scratch brick oven pizza and other Italian cuisine. The restaurant has been around for more than 20 years and owner/chef Flavio Cristofoli, hails straight from Italy. Pair any dish here with the perfect glass of wine from the extensive wine selection.

Visit Source →
Rent Premier SIR

Delicious Italian Restaurants in Sarasota, FL

Another popular restaurant for those who want to leave their Sarasota condo rentals to explore the city is Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar. As they put it, this restaurant offers “a fresh, casual approach to classic Italian elegance.” You’ll find a welcoming atmosphere with some of the friendliest people you could hope to meet on your trip, and of course, the food is simply mouthwatering. Some of their most popular menu options include fettuccine carbonara, handmade ravioli, pollo piccata, and seafood piadina.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Beach Resort and Suites

Siesta Key Restaurants Guide: Discovering Dining Delights!!

Treat your taste buds to Italy at Flavio’s Brick Oven & Bar, where authentic Neapolitan pizza and Italian specialties reign supreme. Each pizza is crafted with care and baked to perfection in the brick oven, resulting in a crispy yet chewy crust that is the hallmark of Neapolitan pizza. Whether you’re dining indoors amid the warm glow of the wood-fired oven or alfresco on the charming patio, Flavio’s promises an authentic and irresistible culinary experience.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Magazine

The Best Italian Restaurants in Sarasota

Take an instant Siesta Key vacay while enjoying great pizza and Italian favorites. The vibe: Larger than it looks from the strip-mall storefront, with a big bar and comfortable, casually elegant dining rooms buzzing with festive regulars and tourists—many with kids. What to order: Authentic pizza from wood-burning brick ovens, as well as Torino-born Flavio Cristofoli’s from-scratch pasta and Italian specialties like veal saltimbocca.

Visit Source →
The Cottages on the Key | Luxury Siesta Key Vacation Rentals

10 Family Friendly Siesta Key Restaurants

Their Pizza Burrata is a crowd favorite, topped with tomato sauce, burrata, arugula, prosciutto, cherry tomatoes, and a drizzle of balsamic reduction. The combination of fresh ingredients and the brick oven crust will transport you straight to pizza heaven. Sit back, relax, and enjoy a delightful meal with your family at this cozy pizzeria in Siesta Key Village.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Island Rentals

Best Pizza on Siesta Key

In addition to some of the best pizza in the city, Flavios also has a great menu of classic Italian cuisine. However, once you taste their brick oven pizza, you will understand why returning vacationers continue to come back to Flavios, year after year. It’s good to know that you can still find great comfort food like pizza when on vacation.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Dumpster Rental

Check Out the 6 Best Restaurants in Siesta Key, FL

For a taste of Italy in Siesta Key, Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar is the place to go. This cozy restaurant brings authentic Italian cuisine to the heart of Florida, specializing in brick oven pizzas, handmade pasta, and exquisite seafood dishes. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes Flavio’s ideal for a family dinner or a romantic night out.

Visit Source →
The Founders Club

Top Places to Recharge with a Cocktail in Sarasota, Florida

For over 20 years, Flavio’s Brick Oven and Bar has been serving delicious Italian classics and handcrafted cocktails. Come in for a large glass of Pinot Noir or a delicious specialty cocktail and pair it with an authentic pizza. Nothing satisfies quite like a glass of wine and a slice of pizza while enjoying a stunning Florida sunset.

Visit Source →
Inn on Siesta Key

Best Restaurants in Siesta Key Village – Must-Try Eats!

If you're looking for authentic Italian in the Village, this is the place for you!. Serving Sarasota since 1991, Flavio's is a local favorite, with everything on their menu being absolutely delectable. Also on the nicer side, the restaurant and bar is the perfect place for a nice dinner with your loved one without breaking the bank.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Herald-Tribune

15 great Siesta Key Village restaurants, bars and nightclubs

Flavio’s Brick Oven Pizza: Discerning pizza eaters have been frequenting Flavio’s since the early 1990s. Seriously, if you want quality, thin-crust, made-from-scratch brick oven pizza —or even an elegant dinner of, say, braised short ribs over pasta — here’s your place. Plus, there’s a full liquor bar and impressive wine list.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key - Parkbench

Top 5 Bars In Siesta Key, Florida

One thing I love about this bar is how delicately they mix their drinks. Wines and beers are great, but let the bartenders at Flavios mix a drink for you, and you’ll be mind-blown. Their premium, well-mixed drinks cost 7 dollars.The food menu contains light delicacies like pizza, pasta, salads, and much more.

Visit Source →
Tropical Breeze Inn

Best Valentine's Restaurants | Tropical Breeze Resort

If you’ve been with your significant other long enough, you probably know that a great pizza is one true way to their heart. Flavio’s serves up the best brick oven pies on Siesta Key, so you don’t want to miss this spot. Its rustic, laid-back atmosphere complements its menu of traditional Italian dishes.

Visit Source →
beachyep.com

15 Best Siesta Key Italian Restaurants

At the heart of Siesta Key, you can find Flavio’s Brick Oven & Bar. When it comes to brick oven pizza and classic Italian cuisines no one can beat Flavio’s Brick Oven & Bar. The place is very casual where you can spend hours enjoying pizza with your friends.

Visit Source →
Crystal Sands on Siesta Key

Grab a Slice at the Best Pizza Restaurants on Siesta Key!

If you’re looking for more of a nighttime dining experience, Flavio’s on Siesta is the place. They have an excellent dining ambiance that is perfect for date night. They serve several amazing brick-over pizzas that satisfy everyone’s taste buds.

Visit Source →
Restaurant Clicks

11 Best Restaurants in Siesta Key

5239 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242Phone: 941-349-0995 Visit Website. A post shared by SOPHIA (@goodeatsbyslv). When you’re in the mood for some of Siesta Key’s best pizza, there’s only one place to go: Flavio’s Brick Oven Pizza & Bar.

Visit Source →
TheExtraCheese

Top 28 Pizzerias for the Ultimate Pizza Sarasota Experience

Experience the ultimate comfort food at Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar Siesta Key. Our family-owned pizzeria in Sarasota offers a cozy ambiance, standout menu items, and exceptional service. Come join us for a slice of pizza heaven!

Visit Source →
Sea Shell Condos

Dining and Shopping in Siesta Key

Flavio’s on Siesta: No restaurant round-up would be complete without a great Italian/pizza place. A favorite of the locals, Flavio’s focuses on authentic Italian food and brick-oven pizzas. The large bar is warm and welcoming.

Visit Source →
Sarasota Experts

23 Best Pizza Places in Sarasota, FL [2022]

This is one of those gourmet pizza places in Sarasota that you absolutely have to try at some point. They use high heat ovens to make slightly crispy crust. The crust is crispy on the outside, but chewy on the inside.

Visit Source →
Siesta Key Luxury Rental Properties

Area Activities

There’s no shortage of solid pizza places on and around Siesta Key. But what is the point of a “good” pizza when you can get an exceptional pizza?. This is the kind of question Chef Flavio would ask you.

Visit Source →
Salt Family Travels

15 Best Restaurants in Siesta Key Village

The Neapolitan pizza is cooked in a brick oven that delivers a crunchy yet chewy crust. They also craft pastas and authentic Italian fish and meat entrees. https://www.flaviosbrickovenandbar.com/

Visit Source →
Kidmoto

Siesta Key Vacation with Kids

Flavio’s Brick Oven is considered one of the best spots for pizza and other authentic Italian fares in Siesta Key. Families will enjoy the variety of pizza available – even gluten-free options!

Visit Source →
Explore Suncoast

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Siesta Key

Sarasota offers a wide range of stylish pizza dining spots to out-of-the-way places with some of the best slices in the south. Check out a few of the best pizzas in Siesta Key.

Visit Source →
Roelens Vacation Rentals

Sarasota Bars & Restaurants

Stop here to enjoy the best Brick Oven Pizza served in Siesta Key. A long list of pizzas with a variety of options means everyone in your group will find one they enjoy!

Visit Source →
Toddling Traveler

8 Awesome Things to Do at Siesta Key, FL

Visit Source →
Flavio's Brick Oven Pizza & Bar Siesta Key (2026) – Best of TikTok, Instagram & Reddit Food Guide