Maroni's Pizza
A beloved family-run pizzeria renowned for its distinctive pizza, featuring a unique cheese blend and generous toppings.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Maroni's Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved family-run pizzeria renowned for its distinctive pizza, featuring a unique cheese blend and generous toppings.
Cash is King
Maroni's is a cash-only establishment, so be sure to bring bills to avoid any payment issues.
Order Ahead or Be Patient
Pizzas are made to order, so expect a wait, especially on weekends. Consider ordering ahead or visiting on a weekday.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Unique "Other" Cheese
Experience a unique cheese blend, described as a creamy spaghetti sauce mixed with cheese. A must-try for adventurous pizza lovers!
Thick Cut Pepperoni & House Sausage
Indulge in generously sized pepperoni slices and flavorful, house-made sausage, making for a truly satisfying pizza experience.
Family-Operated Charm
Enjoy friendly service from a longtime family-run establishment that makes every diner feel welcome and informed.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Cash is King
Maroni's is a cash-only establishment, so be sure to bring bills to avoid any payment issues.
Order Ahead or Be Patient
Pizzas are made to order, so expect a wait, especially on weekends. Consider ordering ahead or visiting on a weekday.
Explore the 'Other' Cheese
Don't miss the signature 'other' cheese, a creamy, unique blend that sets their pizzas apart.
Weekday Visits Recommended
To minimize wait times, try to visit during weekdays when the restaurant is typically less crowded.
Tips
from all over the internet
Cash is King
Maroni's is a cash-only establishment, so be sure to bring bills to avoid any payment issues.
Order Ahead or Be Patient
Pizzas are made to order, so expect a wait, especially on weekends. Consider ordering ahead or visiting on a weekday.
Explore the 'Other' Cheese
Don't miss the signature 'other' cheese, a creamy, unique blend that sets their pizzas apart.
Weekday Visits Recommended
To minimize wait times, try to visit during weekdays when the restaurant is typically less crowded.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Maroni's Pizza offers a distinct pizza experience that divides diners: some rave about the unique cheese blend, house-made sausage, and thick pepperoni, while others find the 'Velveeta-like' cheese and crust to be unappealing. The family-run atmosphere and friendly service are often praised, though some note the building could use updating. Expect a wait, especially on weekends, and remember it's cash-only.
"I don't care what ANYONE says! This is the absolute best pizza in the world! I have been eating Andy's and Lous since the 90s! This is a perfect marriage of both! 🤤🤤🤤
I wish they were open later! I could eat this every single day of the week if I could afford it! 😅🤣 but it is a very decent price compared to other 12 cut trays in the area!
Now I want some!! 😩"
SAS Photography
"The staff is nice, and this place is hopping. Be prepared to eat pizza made with Velveeta cheese; not mozzarella. We ate one slice because we were starving and ended up ordering steak and cheese hoagies instead. The cheese was, you guessed it…Velveeta!
The “Italian food is now made with Velveeta” phenomenon of Pennsylvania and upstate New York is really bizarre."
Jennifer Ete
"Take out... have not been here in several years due to our last few visits ...when pizza was disappointing. We heard the pizza was back to it's old greatness so thought we would give it another try. The pizza was perfect.. purchased both round and square (wished we ordered pepperoni when we saw that coming out of the oven, it looked delicious) both were just like we remembered!"
Janice Bevacqua
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
No, Maroni's Pizza is strictly a cash-only establishment. Please be sure to bring cash for your order.
Maroni's is known for its distinctive pizza style, including a unique cheese blend often described as creamy, and toppings like thick-cut pepperoni and house-made sausage.
The "other" cheese is a signature blend that diners describe as a creamy, savory mixture, almost like a cheesy sauce. It's a popular choice for those seeking a unique flavor.
Since pizzas are made to order, especially during busy periods like weekends, be prepared for a wait. Ordering ahead or visiting on a weekday can help reduce wait times.
Parking can be limited, with only a few dedicated spots. Street parking nearby is often an option, so arriving early is recommended.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit