Dark Horse Restaurant
1 / 3

Dark Horse Restaurant

,

Eclectic American fare with farm-to-table freshness in a charming art deco setting. Known for accommodating dietary needs.

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Wed/Fri 18-21h

Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

CrowdLow
Dark Horse Restaurant

Dark Horse Restaurant

Highlights

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Eclectic American fare with farm-to-table freshness in a charming art deco setting. Known for accommodating dietary needs.

"The food was phenomenal. Crab cakes were insanely good, and an absolutely perfect Bloody Mary."

TIP

Reserve in Advance

Secure your table by booking ahead, especially on weekends.

Weekday Visits

Opt for weekdays for a more relaxed and quieter dining experience.

Third hero image

Quick Facts

Closed·Opens 12PM

Cuisine

American

Price

Mid-range

Phone

(631) 727-7606

Address

1 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901, USA

Insta-Factor

High

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Eclectic American Fare

Eclectic American Fare

Farm-to-table freshness meets art deco charm in this Riverhead gem.

A Foodie's Guide to the Best Restaurants in Riverhead, New YorkExperience Riverhead: 8 Iconic American Cuisine to Try | EmpireStateExplorerRiverhead Dining, LI Restaurant Week Deals & More
Renowned Gluten-Free Options

Renowned Gluten-Free Options

Accommodating staff and a dedicated menu make dining stress-free.

Riverhead Dining, LI Restaurant Week Deals & MoreGoogle Review+1
Farm-to-Table Excellence

Farm-to-Table Excellence

Experience high-quality ingredients and chef-driven dishes.

A Foodie's Guide to the Best Restaurants in Riverhead, New YorkGoogle Review+1
Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

Reserve in Advance

Secure your table by booking ahead, especially on weekends.

Weekday Visits

Opt for weekdays for a more relaxed and quieter dining experience.

Dietary Needs

They excel at catering to dietary restrictions, including gluten-free.

Parking

Convenient parking is available behind the building.

Tips

from all over the internet

Reserve in Advance

Secure your table by booking ahead, especially on weekends.

Weekday Visits

Opt for weekdays for a more relaxed and quieter dining experience.

Dietary Needs

They excel at catering to dietary restrictions, including gluten-free.

Parking

Convenient parking is available behind the building.

What Travellers Say

4.6
(491k reviews)

Reviews Summary

Dark Horse Restaurant is praised for its delicious eclectic American fare, particularly burgers and fries, and its exceptional ability to cater to dietary restrictions, especially gluten-free needs. While many commend the warm, knowledgeable staff and lively atmosphere, a few diners found the menu lacking or the prices a bit high for the perceived value.

"What a wonderful place for a family get together! Food was fantastic, everyone was fabulous! Will be back again!"

Joshua Holten

"Not sure why someone would come here. It’s not fancy enough to be a romantic restaurant. But it’s not cheap enough to be a dinner. Dark Horse is lost in a gray area of meaningless with over priced food and a small menu. The large booths are well suited for a large crowd, but the restaurant is small which sort of defeats the purpose. Even the service leans on cheap dinner dive."

SpyPilot

"A great little place to eat. I have been there twice, leaving happy both times. It is right on Main Street. Parking is behind the building. The wait staff is fun and
knowledgeable. My waiter last visit was extra funny and helped make our time there more fun. The food is farm to table. At first, I thought the prices were a little high, I was wrong. Once I tasted the food, it was clear how much effort and talent went into making me happy. Delicious to say the least. Beautiful decor and very clean. If you're in Riverhead, make this a stop for sure."

Ben The Handyman

What People Like

Phenomenal food, especially burgers and crab cakes
Accommodating gluten-free options
Warm and knowledgeable staff

What People Dislike

Menu perceived as limited or not to everyone's taste
Occasional price concerns

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, Dark Horse Restaurant is renowned for its excellent gluten-free options and is very accommodating to various dietary restrictions.

Riverhead Dining, LI Restaurant Week Deals & MoreGoogle Review

It is highly recommended to make reservations in advance, especially during busy times and weekends, to ensure a table.

Google Review

Dark Horse Restaurant serves eclectic American fare with a focus on farm-to-table fresh meals.

A Foodie's Guide to the Best Restaurants in Riverhead, New YorkExperience Riverhead: 8 Iconic American Cuisine to Try | EmpireStateExplorer

Popular dishes include burgers, crab cakes, Merlot beef, and French onion soup.

A Foodie's Guide to the Best Restaurants in Riverhead, New YorkGoogle Review+2

Yes, parking is available behind the building.

Visiting on weekdays is recommended for a quieter dining experience compared to the busier weekends.

Mentioned in

Featured in these publications

The New York Times

Dark Horse - Review

The restaurant’s owner, Dee Muma, is the woman behind the project. Ms. Muma is also an owner, with her husband, Ed Tuccio, of nearby Tweed’s. The décor at the Dark Horse includes Art Deco posters on the butter-yellow walls, an industrial-looking black ceiling with heat ducts and pipes, wraparound windows, silvery chairs, a room-encircling black banquette and wood tables with paper placemats and cloth napkins.

Visit Source →
jcmsu.shopgregorythomas.com

47 epuni street The 10 Best Vegan Restaurants in Riverhead (Updated … The Dimon Estate Restaurant - Riverhead, NY OpenTable WebVegetarian. $ 23.00 Chicken Marsala Pizza $ 27.00 Meat Lover Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon on a round crispy crust. $ 26.00 Penne Alla Vodka Pizza $ 26.00 House Special Pie Pizza topped with your choice of 3 toppings. $ 25.00 Veggie Pizza Square thin crust with broccoli, zucchini, peppers cooked to perfection. $ 23.00 Everything Pie 47 erindale dr WebFine food and hearty meals. We serve them all at Dark Horse. Locate the atmosphere and enjoy such items as salads in Riverhead. Featuring eclectic food and a pleasant atmosphere we know you'll want to come back. Call us … The 10 Best Riverhead Vegetarian Restaurants Dark Horse Restaurant menu in Riverhead, New York, USA - Sirved Vegan and Vegetarian options, Riverside... - Turkuaz Grill WebBest vegetarian restaurants in Riverhead Steaks Best steak restaurants in Riverhead Pizza Best pizza restaurants in Riverhead Seafood Best seafood restaurants in … The Birchwood of Polish Town menu in Riverhead, New York, USA - Sirved WebRiverhead, NY Tweeds Restaurant & Buffalo Bar Riverhead, NY Roadhouse Brick Oven Pizza Riverhead, NY Jerry and the Mermaid Riverhead, NY Jamesport Farm Brewery Riverhead, NY Buoy One Riverhead, NY Ralph's Famous Italian Ices Riverhead, NY Stonewalls Restaurant Riverhead, NY Panera Bread Riverhead, NY Funcho's … WebWhen you're in Riverhead and you're looking for a great place for american food drop by Farm Country Kitchen for the best meal in town. Find our varied menu and select salads for example, you'll be glad you did. Call us at (631) 369-6311 and then join us for a fine dining experience. Restaurants near Farm Country Kitchen in Riverhead 47 erindale drive erin WebWe're proud to be from Riverhead and our american is what makes The Birchwood of Polish Town so great. If you want to try delicious chicken then our restaurant is the place for you.

Visit Source →
Hometown Plate

A Foodie's Guide to the Best Restaurants in Riverhead, New York

Nestled amidst the bustling vibe of Riverhead’s Main Street, with its art deco flair and towering high ceilings, this eclectic American gem offers a culinary adventure that’s not to be missed. From my first step inside, I was greeted with a warmth that only a knowledgeable and, dare I say, humor-infused wait staff can provide, setting the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The farm-to-table offerings, from the tender Merlot beef to crispy duck and creamy mashed potatoes, left no doubt that the attention to detail here borders on the obsessive, with a clear focus on quality and a knack for making even those with dietary restrictions feel thoroughly pampered.

Visit Source →
theknot.com

Rehearsal Dinner + Bridal Showers in Riverhead, NY

Claudio's Restaurant Group is a historic waterfront restaurant and wedding venue sitting in the heart of Greenport, NY. Presenting over a century of history blended with a modern rejuvenation, this venue offers a charming, charismatic setting. With a range of event spaces, all with their own unique quality, this venue can help you celebrate your special day your way. Claudio's has a long history, filled with excitement and character.

Visit Source →
NewsBreak Original

Experience Riverhead: 8 Iconic American Cuisine to Try | EmpireStateExplorer

The owner/chef started Tweeds Restaurant with her husband 13 years ago and ran the off premise catering for it as Dark Horse. It became evident that there was a place in Riverhead for another restaurant with a little different feel than Tweeds. Tweeds is lovely and delicious- just different.In our first year at Dark Horse we have had good reviews and been named one of the top new restaurants in the tri-state area.

Visit Source →
atly.com

The 17 Best Gluten-Free Spots in Riverhead

My family and I had a great experience at Dark Horse Tavern!. They offer amazing gluten-free options, which is such a rare find. Although there was only one server on the floor, which slowed things down a little, he did an incredible job of keeping up with all the tables and making sure everyone was taken care of.

Visit Source →
web.atly.com

The 12 Best Gluten-Free Dinner Spots in Riverhead

Visit Source →
fusion84sayville.com

The Best Vegetarian Fine Dining Restaurants in Suffolk County, NY

This Long Island vegetarian restaurant is open daily from 11:00 to 17:00 and offers a variety of starters and pizzas that can be shared tapas-style. For dessert, try their vegan carrot cake – it's one of the best around!. Turkuaz Grill is another great option for vegetarians and vegans.

Visit Source →
Dan’s Papers

Riverhead Dining, LI Restaurant Week Deals & More

Check out Riverhead’s first Brasserie, Dark Horse Restaurant, open seven days a week, serving farm-to-table fresh meals and catering to those with dietary restrictions with their renowned gluten-free menu!

Visit Source →
Dark Horse Restaurant (2026) – Best of TikTok, Instagram & Reddit Food Guide