Hinkle's Sandwich Shop
A historic Madison diner since 1933, serving up classic, craveable sliders, milkshakes, and comfort food with a friendly, retro vibe.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Hinkle's Sandwich Shop
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A historic Madison diner since 1933, serving up classic, craveable sliders, milkshakes, and comfort food with a friendly, retro vibe.
Visit during off-peak
Avoid waiting by visiting during quieter times. Tables and counter seats can fill up quickly!
Try more than burgers
Don't overlook other delicious options like their fish sandwich or hearty chili.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
American Diner
Price
$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Iconic Sliders
Taste history with Hinkle's slider-sized burgers, a beloved Madison tradition since 1933. Juicy and flavorful!
Nostalgic Diner Vibe
Step back in time at this classic brick-lined diner, offering a warm, friendly atmosphere and authentic vintage charm.
Spectacular Milkshakes
Don't leave without trying one of their famous milkshakes, a sweet and creamy treat that perfectly caps off any meal.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit during off-peak
Avoid waiting by visiting during quieter times. Tables and counter seats can fill up quickly!
Try more than burgers
Don't overlook other delicious options like their fish sandwich or hearty chili.
Plan restroom breaks
If seated at the counter without indoor restroom access, be mindful of planning your breaks.
Don't skip the sides
The funnel fries are a must-try! Crispy onion rings are also a popular and delicious choice.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit during off-peak
Avoid waiting by visiting during quieter times. Tables and counter seats can fill up quickly!
Try more than burgers
Don't overlook other delicious options like their fish sandwich or hearty chili.
Plan restroom breaks
If seated at the counter without indoor restroom access, be mindful of planning your breaks.
Don't skip the sides
The funnel fries are a must-try! Crispy onion rings are also a popular and delicious choice.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Hinkle's Sandwich Shop is celebrated for its authentic, nostalgic diner experience and consistently delicious, no-frills food, particularly its iconic sliders and creamy milkshakes. While some find the portion sizes modest, the overwhelmingly positive reviews highlight friendly service, great value, and a charming hometown atmosphere that keeps customers returning.
"We always seek out the mom and pop restaurants and this one did not disappoint. I had the chilli and grilled cheese. My wife had the cheese burger and fries. The chilli was thick and hardy. Very good flavor too . My wife enjoyed the cheese burger and fries too . The lady who was our server was very friendly and professional."
shawn donathan
"This was our first time to Hinkle's as we live two hours from Madison, but it was a great experience. We had cheeseburger sliders and onion rings. The sliders were twice the size of White Castle's and three times better. The onion rings were cooked perfectly and were crispy. The server was fast, and our server Shandi was incredible. We went to see a show at Ohio Theater and came back for a shake. Whenever we come back to Madison, we'll visit Hinkle's. We already miss the burgers."
Chris
"We stopped by Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop in Madison and were seriously impressed! It’s one of those places that nails the basics — cheap, fast, and really good.
I ordered the BLT with onion rings and both were perfect — crispy, flavorful, and just the right amount of greasy comfort. My husband got a cheeseburger and absolutely devoured it before I could ask for a bite (which is probably the best review in itself!).
It’s classic diner-style food done right, with no frills and no long wait. Definitely a spot we’ll keep coming back to whenever we’re in the area!"
Heather Frazier
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Hinkle's is best known for its slider-sized burgers, milkshakes, and classic diner sides like onion rings and fries. Many also enjoy their fish sandwich and chili.
Yes, Hinkle's offers a casual, family-friendly atmosphere with affordable options that appeal to all ages. They do not serve alcohol.
To avoid long waits, it's recommended to visit during off-peak hours. The diner can get busy, especially during lunch and dinner rushes.
While primarily known for burgers, vegetarian options like the fish sandwich (though not meat-free) and sides are available. Reviewers have noted enjoyment of non-meat options.
Yes, there is a menu available online and images of the menu boards can be found, showcasing their classic offerings.
Hinkle's offers a nostalgic, hometown diner experience with a friendly vibe. It features a counter for watching cooks and a separate dining area.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Restaurants in Madison
A true throwback eatery, this place remains largely unchanged since Winfred Hinkle founded the malts-and-burgers spot in 1933. That includes the prices, which remain incredibly low—the weekday lunch special is (at the time of writing) $5.89. Sides include Tater Tots and onion rings.
Great Places to Eat and Drink in Madison, Indiana
Since 1933, locals and tourists have enjoyed classic burgers, fries, shakes, and more at Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop. The burgers are slider size, made to order on the grill, and reminiscent of White Castle for many guests. You can dine at the counter or at the dining area next door.
Things to Do in Madison, Indiana Weekend Trip Ideas & Itinerary
Hinkle's Sandwich Shop, 204 W Main St, Madison, IN 47250, USA. TripAdvisor/Porthos7. For one of the best sandwiches in downtown Madison, head over to Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop, a local favorite since 1933.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit