Jimmy's Neighborhood Restaurant
A hidden gem in Tarpon Springs, Jimmy's offers a delightful mix of Greek and American comfort food with a focus on fresh seafood and homemade pizzas.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Jimmy's Neighborhood Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A hidden gem in Tarpon Springs, Jimmy's offers a delightful mix of Greek and American comfort food with a focus on fresh seafood and homemade pizzas.
"Jimmy's is a delightful hidden gem with amazing food and fantastic service – a true local favorite!"
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid crowds by dining during non-peak times for a more relaxed experience.
Outdoor Seating Recommended
Enjoy a pleasant meal al fresco; outdoor seating is available and recommended.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Greek, American
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(727) 935-4864
Address
1203 Gulf Rd, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Legendary Grilled Octopus
Savor the highly acclaimed whole grilled octopus, perfectly tender and flavorful. A must-try for seafood lovers!
Authentic Homemade Pizzas
Indulge in pizzas made from scratch with fresh ingredients, praised for their delicious taste and generous toppings.
Warm & Welcoming Atmosphere
Experience a cozy, diner-like ambiance with friendly service that makes you feel right at home. Perfect for families.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Menu
Most Popular Items
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid crowds by dining during non-peak times for a more relaxed experience.
Outdoor Seating Recommended
Enjoy a pleasant meal al fresco; outdoor seating is available and recommended.
Chop Your Greek Salad
Consider getting your Greek salad chopped for enhanced flavor and easier enjoyment.
Don't Miss the Calzone
The calzones are a standout dish, with some diners calling them the best they've ever had.
Tips
from all over the internet
Visit During Off-Peak Hours
Avoid crowds by dining during non-peak times for a more relaxed experience.
Outdoor Seating Recommended
Enjoy a pleasant meal al fresco; outdoor seating is available and recommended.
Chop Your Greek Salad
Consider getting your Greek salad chopped for enhanced flavor and easier enjoyment.
Don't Miss the Calzone
The calzones are a standout dish, with some diners calling them the best they've ever had.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Diners consistently praise Jimmy's Neighborhood Restaurant for its exceptional food, particularly the grilled octopus and homemade pizzas. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly, attentive service create a delightful dining experience, making it a beloved local spot.
"I am 6 decades old & had THE BEST CALZONE I have ever eaten in my lifetime! It was INCREDIBLE, & the side sauce was as well. Pepperoni, green pepper, & extra cheese inside the most delicious pizza dough! See pic! And what was also great was that two calzone sizes were available! My partner in crime had fried cod, & loved it. It had been dipped in cornmeal-- see pic. This is a diner that is away from the hustle & hustle of the main coastal street. We selected it because it had just under a 5-star rating & had its own parking lot. Greek & America food are also on the menu. We will definitely return!"
Nancy
"If you are looking for a quiet place to eat.
This is it. Sit outside or inside.
The Greek potato salad is unbelievable.
The saganaki flaming cheese is incredible.
Top it off with some great draft beers on tap
And a chicken philly sandwich that's out of this world.
This is the place for you.
The service is amazing 😍"
Daniel
"Jimmy is a delightful hidden gem in Tarpon Springs Florida. Tonight was my third time there. Autumn was our waitress. She was friendly and outgoing and gave us excellent service. I ordered the cheeseburger medium rare and it was cooked to perfection full of flavor. The fries were nice and crisp. My two friends both ordered the house special pizza made all from scratch. Full of flavor and fresh ingredients making the pizza top notch. The menu consists of Greek and American food. Always pleased with the service and food, this spot has become a regular stop for me and my friends. I highly recommend it if your in the area. Outside seating is also available. Best Key Lime pie ever."
Daddy Danny
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
The grilled octopus and homemade pizzas are highly recommended, along with the calzones and stuffed grouper.
Yes, Jimmy's Neighborhood Restaurant offers outdoor seating, which is a pleasant option for diners.
It's described as a warm, welcoming, diner-like atmosphere with a casual and family-friendly vibe.
Jimmy's serves a blend of Greek and American cuisine, offering a diverse menu.
While not explicitly stated, given its popularity and 'hidden gem' status, arriving during off-peak hours is advised to avoid waits.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The Best 5 Grilled Octopus Dishes in Tarpon Springs
Jimmy’s on Gulf Rd is not to be missed on a visit to Tarpon Springs. Their whole octopus is broiled and served with a fresh greek salad as a starter or with potatoes and veggies as a main. Jimmy’s also offers a large assortment of calzones, pizza, and signature entrees that are a mixture of the Greek culture in Tarpon Springs and traditional Italian cuisine.
The 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Tarpon Springs, FL
According to the reviews and ratings of former diners, the best seafood restaurant in Tarpon Springs is Jimmy’s Neighborhood Restaurant. The highlight of the menu is the seafood dishes as there is a good selection of grilled fishes along with dishes such as New England chowder. There are also pizzas, sandwiches, pasta options, and some meat dishes.
48 hours in Tarpon Springs, Florida's own little Greece
Treat yourself to some of the best comfort eats and seafood in Tarpon Springs at Jimmy’s Neighborhood Restaurant (1203 Gulf Road). Signature dishes include seafood fra diavolo, a melty spinach pizza, and fresh Ipswich clam strips. It’s a casual atmosphere that lets you kick your feet back while enjoying fresh Florida flavors.
20 Best Tarpon Springs Restaurants For A Drool-Worthy Meal
Jimmy’s Neighborhood Restaurant is truly one of those restaurants in Tarpon Springs that only the locals know. It’s not in either of the two main public areas – historic downtown or the Sponge Docks. Rather, Jimmy’s occupies an unassuming spot in a residential area near the elementary and high schools.
15 Best Restaurants in Tarpon Springs, FL [2023 Updated]
Fine American food and beverages are served in this family-friendly restaurant. They feature plenty of space, large televisions, and delicious food. The service here is also fantastic.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit