TuscNY Pizza
TuscNY Pizza is a beloved Tuscaloosa spot offering scratch-made New York, Detroit, and Sicilian style pizzas with fresh ingredients.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
TuscNY Pizza
Highlights
Must-see attractions
TuscNY Pizza is a beloved Tuscaloosa spot offering scratch-made New York, Detroit, and Sicilian style pizzas with fresh ingredients.
Crispier Crust Request
Ask for your pizza to be well done for an extra crispy crust.
Generous Leftovers
Pizzas are large and can easily provide multiple meals, offering great value.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Pizza
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(205) 248-2149
Address
229 McFarland Cir N, Tuscaloosa, AL 35406, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic New York-Style Pizza
Experience the taste, texture, and foldability of a perfect New York slice, praised by locals and visitors alike.
Unique Detroit & Sicilian Styles
Beyond NY style, explore creative options like Sausage, Peppers, and Onions Detroit Style with Pesto drizzle.
Delectable House-Made Desserts
Don't skip the sweet endings! Indulge in treats like perfectly crafted cannolis and rich tiramisu.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Crispier Crust Request
Ask for your pizza to be well done for an extra crispy crust.
Generous Leftovers
Pizzas are large and can easily provide multiple meals, offering great value.
Don't Miss the Ranch
Highly recommended by reviewers, their Ranch dressing is a must-try for fans.
Ask for Recommendations
Staff is helpful with portion sizes and menu item selections.
Tips
from all over the internet
Crispier Crust Request
Ask for your pizza to be well done for an extra crispy crust.
Generous Leftovers
Pizzas are large and can easily provide multiple meals, offering great value.
Don't Miss the Ranch
Highly recommended by reviewers, their Ranch dressing is a must-try for fans.
Ask for Recommendations
Staff is helpful with portion sizes and menu item selections.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
TuscNY Pizza garners praise for its authentic New York-style pizza and unique Detroit and Sicilian options, with many highlighting fresh ingredients and delicious desserts. However, some diners have noted inconsistencies in pricing and perceived quality compared to expectations.
"i've had this pizza twice in less than a week because i loved it so much the first time and i usually hate pizza. i LOVE this place. the staff is cool, the paintings on the walls are cool, they even have black toilets. yeah there's so dark parts on the crusts but that's the way it's cooked, and it's cooked divinely. this is REAL pizza. don't come here if you're wanting some cici/domino bs."
Britney Johnson
"I wanted to try this new place and stopped by for lunch. We were the only customers there. I didn't know what to expect since I had no knowledge of the place. If you want to know the menu and prices, go to DoorDash. We walked in and saw the deal on the chalkboard that said, 2 slices and two drinks for $13. So we ordered our preference and also chose two Caesar salads. We should have split it. The salad was large. It was fresh romaine lettuce, hard and crunchy croutons, pecorino romano cheese, and caesar dressing. I don't know, but it seemed very plain. Maybe the dressing was missing something. I had a slice of cheese pizza. There wasn't much sauce or cheese on it. The crust was as thin as a piece of cardboard. It tasted like toast. The edge of the crust was plain and dry. No sauce, oil, cheese, nothing. After I had finished eating, I saw them put up another chalkboard. This one offered hand-tossed and thick-crust pizza slices. Had I known, I would have chosen differently. Our server answered my questions about the pizza and their sizes. She showed me the 20" pizza box which feeds a crowd, mostly Friday and Saturday nights. The long rectangular box was for the thick crust pizza which has square slices. The smaller box was for their 12" pizzas. The slices are priced according to the deal of the day, how many toppings, and the choice of crust. I hope you will visit them for lunch based on this knowledge you have been given. The menu is also included in the pics below."
Lorraine Price
"So very disappointed , the pizza had barely any cheese at all !!! I paid $45 for 2 , 12 inch puzzas one cheese and one pepperoni , and a cheese bread . I don't mind paying more money for good homemade authentic pizza but this was ridiculous. I will post pictures. So dry !!! Will not be back !"
Suzanne Barnette
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
TuscNY specializes in New York-style pizza, but also offers Detroit and Sicilian styles, with a variety of unique topping combinations.
Yes, TuscNY emphasizes using fresh, high-quality ingredients and makes many items, including sauces and pesto, from scratch.
Reviewers highly recommend the cannolis and tiramisu, often calling them the best they've ever had.
The atmosphere is described as welcoming and unpretentious, making it suitable for family meals. Pizzas are large and can feed a crowd.
Unique options include the Sausage, Peppers, and Onions Detroit Style with Pesto drizzle and a well-regarded Ranch dressing.
Yes, for a crispier crust, you can request your pizza to be well done.
Some reviewers have noted discrepancies between menu prices online and the final cost at checkout, so it's wise to confirm.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Tuscaloosa Restaurants: New and Coming Soon
This New York-style pepperoni pizza is one of many varieties found at TuscNY. Recently opened at 229 McFarland Circle North, TuscNY Pizza, offers specialty pizzas and freshly made pasta dishes in a great atmosphere. TuscNY hopes to serve a diverse clientele, both permanent residents of Tuscaloosa as well as students.
13 Best Places To Eat in Tuscaloosa | Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner
TuscNY is a Tuscaloosa staple, consistently ranked as one of the top restaurants in the city. With its focus on fresh, all-natural ingredients and hand-built pizzas and pasta, it’s no surprise that this spot is a local favorite. TuscNY uses only the best ingredients in their dishes, and it shows.
Highest-rated Restaurants in Tuscaloosa by Diners
- Rating: 4.3/5 (40 reviews)- Price level: $$- Address: 229 McFarland Cir North Tuscaloosa, Alabama - Categories: Pizza, Desserts, Salad- Read more on Yelp. You may also like: Homes for sale in Tuscaloosa at every price point
25 Best Restaurants in Tuscaloosa, AL for 2024 (Top Eats!)
229 McFarland Cir NTuscaloosa, AL 35406(205) 248-2149 Open in Google Maps. Located in the heart of Tuscaloosa, TuscNY is a pizza and pasta restaurant specializing in making its products from scratch.
Open restaurants Tuscaloosa
Hand built Detroit, Sicilian and NY Pizza, Caesar Salads and more. For more info visit the website or checkout Google Maps.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit