
South+Pine American Eatery
A rustic bistro known for farm-to-table American fare, seasonal creativity, and a charming BYOB option. Chef Leia Gaccione's vision shines through.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries

South+Pine American Eatery

Highlights
Must-see attractions
A rustic bistro known for farm-to-table American fare, seasonal creativity, and a charming BYOB option. Chef Leia Gaccione's vision shines through.
Embrace the BYOB Option
Consider bringing your favorite bottle of wine as South+Pine is BYOB, enhancing your dining experience.
Patio Seating for Brunch
Visit during brunch for delightful outdoor seating on the patio, offering a pleasant ambiance.

Quick Facts
Cuisine
American
Price
Mid-range
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

Farm-to-Table Freshness
Experience well-presented farm-to-table dishes with unique flavors, showcasing seasonal ingredients.

Charming BYOB Experience
Bring your favorite bottle of wine to complement your meal, adding a personal touch to your dining.

Rustic Bistro Ambiance
Enjoy a cozy, rustic bistro atmosphere with a pleasant outdoor patio, perfect for any occasion.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Embrace the BYOB Option
Consider bringing your favorite bottle of wine as South+Pine is BYOB, enhancing your dining experience.
Patio Seating for Brunch
Visit during brunch for delightful outdoor seating on the patio, offering a pleasant ambiance.
Ask About Vegan Options
For vegan preferences, inquire with your server about accommodating substitutions; they are flavorful.
Explore Diverse Starters
Try various starters like lamb meatballs or black kale salad for delicious and unique appetizer options.
Tips
from all over the internet
Embrace the BYOB Option
Consider bringing your favorite bottle of wine as South+Pine is BYOB, enhancing your dining experience.
Patio Seating for Brunch
Visit during brunch for delightful outdoor seating on the patio, offering a pleasant ambiance.
Ask About Vegan Options
For vegan preferences, inquire with your server about accommodating substitutions; they are flavorful.
Explore Diverse Starters
Try various starters like lamb meatballs or black kale salad for delicious and unique appetizer options.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
South+Pine American Eatery is praised for its fresh, well-presented farm-to-table dishes and attentive service, creating a welcoming atmosphere. While many rave about the quality and unique flavors, some diners have noted inconsistencies in service and occasional issues with spice levels or seasoning. The BYOB aspect and patio seating are also frequent highlights.
"Food was amazing, super fresh, and well crafted with a lot of attention before it gets served. The sous chef Amanda personally helped with recommendations and we were able to sit by the kitchen where we got to watch first hand the care that goes into every dish. Highly recommend the Polenta fries!"
cait hall
"My girlfriend and I visited South+Pine in Morristown for her birthday lunch on a Saturday afternoon. While we were excited to try the place based on its glowing reviews, our experience turned out to be a bit uneven.
Parking was a hassle, there's no dedicated lot, so we had to find street parking, which was metered and tough to come by on a weekend. We arrived around 3:00 p.m. and found the place nearly empty, with only one other table of diners inside. The space itself was cozy with a rustic charm, highlighted by unique wall decor made of old doors pieced together creatively. It had a quiet, relaxed vibe.
We started off with drinks, the toasted coconut latte and the vanilla bourbon latte. Both were delicious, not overly sweet, and offered a nice balance of flavor and coffee. However, by the end of the drinks, the syrup had settled at the bottom, making the last few sips overly sweet, so I didn’t finish mine completely.
For an appetizer, we shared the spicy lamb meatballs served over Greek yogurt and cucumber relish. They were flavorful, though definitely not spicy despite the name—barely a 1 out of 10 on the spice scale.
For our entrees, I had the short rib and winter veggie hash with poached eggs and chipotle hollandaise, which was pretty good in terms of taste, but I was disappointed by how little short rib was in the dish, it leaned heavily vegetarian. My girlfriend ordered the Fried Chix 2.0 (chicken and waffles), and unfortunately, it was a major letdown. The chicken was bland and lacked seasoning, and even the waffles didn’t impress, which was especially disappointing since she’s a big waffle fan and didn’t even finish it. She said it was bland and chewy. Probably an over mixed batter. We also got a side of Polenta fries, made out of corn meal. These were pretty good, crunchy outer shell with a mushy seasoned corn meal on the inside.
Service started out strong with a kind and attentive waitress who greeted us and brought our drinks. However, the second server who took our food order was less pleasant, her demeanor was curt and a bit rushed, despite the restaurant being nearly empty. At one point, she even pressured my girlfriend to order quickly, and I had to ask her to come back in a few minutes.
Meanwhile, we could see some staff casually chatting at another table, which didn’t make the rushed vibe feel very justified.
We decided to skip dessert and try another spot down the street instead. Overall, South+Pine had some highs, like the lattes and cozy atmosphere, but also several lows, particularly with the entrees and service. I suspect the rave reviews are more reflective of their dinner menu, which we didn’t get to try. I might consider coming back in the future for dinner, but as far as this birthday lunch went, it was just okay."
Jay M.
"If I could give over a 5 review for each category I would! First time here and was blown away by the service and had the pleasure of sitting right behind the kitchen and observing the owner and head chef running the place like a true BOSS! I heard her say at one point, “This dish isn’t pretty enough. Make it pretty.” She gave it back to the cook. She wiped every open area of the plates of prepared dishes that came out, making sure they were pretty. Top notch! The food was just as good."
Jason Branson
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, South+Pine American Eatery is a BYOB restaurant, allowing you to bring your own bottle of wine to enjoy with your meal.
Yes, the restaurant offers vegetarian and gluten-free options, and is accommodating to dietary needs.
Reviewers often praise dishes like lamb meatballs, hanger steak, chicken and waffles, and polenta fries.
Yes, outdoor seating is available on their patio, which is particularly pleasant during brunch and warm evenings.
Its location right next door to the Mayo Performing Arts Center (MPAC) makes it a very convenient choice for pre-show dining.
The restaurant is described as having a cozy, rustic bistro atmosphere, with some reviews noting a relaxed and welcoming vibe.
Some diners have mentioned that the 'spicy' dishes may not be very spicy, and there have been isolated reports of "split charges" not being disclosed.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
The 11 best Morristown restaurants, ranked for 2024
One line of Leia Gaccione’s resume is enough to garner a visit to South + Pine, but her list of impressive accolades goes on and on. The Passaic native has appeared on numerous television shows, including “Top Chef,” “Chopped,” “Beat Bobby Flay” and “Iron Chef America.” That experience, plus years of training at restaurants around New York, New Jersey and Las Vegas has helped her craft one of the best New American menus in a town full of them. Her creativity is on display with dishes like roasted scallops, grilled salmon with Korean barbecue glaze and kimchi fried rice, and New Jersey corn empanadas.
A Local's Guide to Morristown BYOB Restaurants (Complete With Wine Pairings) -
A neighborhood staple that brings every day dining to an entire new level, South + Pine is the vision and creation of Leia Gaccione, former Executive Chef and Chef de Cuisine for Bobby Flay. Gaccione gets your love of food as well as your need to enjoy it – not just on special occasions – which is why when you bring your bottle of 2016 Devaux Bourgogne Hautes Cotes de Beaune that pairs perfectly with the Local Crab Salad, you’ll get why this restaurant’s claim to pair food, peace, and love into one place is 100% accurate. 90 South Street, Morristown 862-260-9700 http://www.southandpine.com/
the best of outdoor dining: south and pine and more
While they all make my list when we get the urge to enjoy those gentle warm summer evenings, my favorite is South+Pine in Morristown, NJ. It almost has it all: excellent seasonal food, wonderful service, and a genuine, pleasantly appointed outdoor space on a street in Morristown just busy enough for some decent people watching. It is BYO, but my readers know I’ve come to embrace this particular feature of northern NJ dining read more about that here.
5 Great Dining Spots of a Date for in Morristown, NJ
While South + Pine has a casual feel to it, that may be exactly what you’re looking for. Serving American fare with vegetarian & gluten-free options, it’s the perfect choice for anyone looking to dine in a rustic chic atmosphere with beautiful outdoor patio seating options. Located in Morristown’s downtown area, it’s in walking distance to a variety of shops and right next door to the Mayo Performing Arts Center.
5 Family Restaurants Worth the Drive Near Morristown, NJ
The fresh, seasonal menu at South + Pine American Eatery will give your family some amazing dishes to share with one another. Their halibut platter is a seafood lover’s dream, served with fregola, artichokes, and a mushroom conserva to give everything a deliciously savory flavor. Come see what they’ve got cooking at 90 South Street.
6 Best Brunch Restaurants in Morristown, NJ
This charming, rustic bistro is another top pick for brunch, with its outdoor patio and allergy-friendly options. South+Pine American Eatery prides itself on using locally-sourced ingredients. When you stop by for brunch, start with an appetizer of avocado toast, spicy lamb meatballs, or corn and coconut chowder.
Exploring Morristown, New Jersey
If you’ve ever walked into a restaurant and felt like you were coming over to a friend or family member’s house, that’s the exact vibe at South + Pine. “The way I cook at home is the same way I cook here—just on a much larger scale!. ” says Leia Gaccione, chef and owner of South + Pine.
Best Restaurants in Morristown, NJ
South+Pine offers a variety of American dishes with options for vegetarians and those seeking gluten-free meals. The rustic bistro setting and patio seating make it an inviting spot for any occasion. Address: 90 South St, Morristown, NJ 07960 Phone: (862) 260-9700
The Best Restaurants in Morristown
A seasonal salmon dish at South + Pine makes for a tasty dinner option. Photo: Courtesy of South + Pine. This casual American eatery offers food that is relatable, affordable and always touched with imagination and detail that lifts it into super-deliciousness.
Morristown Holiday Shopping Guide: Gifts For Everyone On Your List
Present them with a gift card to local gems like Agrícola Eatery, South + Pine American Eatery, NOM Mexican Table & Tequila Bar, Roots Steakhouse, Stirling Tavern and an array of other establishments providing unique cuisines waiting to be savored.
The Best Restaurants in Morristown | Travel Maven
This popular BYOB is led by chef Leah Gaccione who's ran several of Bobby Flay's restaurants. Her jump into opening her own business has been a major success so far. Fresh, imaginative, and artistic, the plates at South + Pine are delicious.
A GUIDE TO MORRISTOWN AND MADISON, NJ
The chef was Bobby Flay’s sous chef and happens to be a Morristown native, she decided to return to her hometown to bring something different to the restaurant landscape. It’s BYO and a cozy experience with unique decor and great service.
10 Best Restaurants in Morristown NJ You Must Try
Chef Leia Gaccione, a Bobby Flay protégé, brings creative American cuisine to South + Pine in Morristown. The restaurant offers a menu of relatable and affordable dishes, such as their seasonal salmon dish, all crafted with imagination.
These 10 Morris County restaurants have outdoor areas
Type of food: A casual and inviting environment with a focus on using fresh seasonal ingredients to create artistic dishes. Staples include spicy lamb meatballs, burgers, hanger steaks and grilled salmon over coconut quinoa.
11 Best Restaurants in Morristown, NJ for 2025 (Top Eats!)
90 South StMorristown, NJ 07960(862) 260-9700 Visit Website See Menu Open in Google Maps. Helmed by Chef Leia Gaccione, this eatery on South Street beckons with its filling and creative American fare.
Rehearsal Dinner + Bridal Showers in Morris Plains, NJ
Los Cuernos is a deluxe Mexican eatery and wedding festivities venue in Jersey City, NJ. Celebrate your rehearsal dinner or engagement party in this trendy restaurant, which serves up authentic Mexica
5 Lunch Spots To Try In The Morristown Area, According To Yelp
South + Pine American Eatery: "Had a nice brunch here on a Saturday morning. We were seated quickly and served our coffee. We ordered a seasonal omelette and chicken & waffles."-- Pat G.
The 7 Best Gluten-Free American Restaurants in Morristown
Food was so fresh and the items were a perfect pair to the season. Service was wonderful and everything was very clean!. I love the extensive options for vegan and gluten-free.
Favorite Restaurants in Morris County
South and Pine is a newbie but already has a cult following. Perfect for lunch or dinner, with or without kids. If your kids aren’t too picky, they will love it.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit