The Godfather of Morristown
A casual Italian eatery famous for its brick-oven pizzas, fresh mozzarella, and a surprisingly diverse seafood menu.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
The Godfather of Morristown
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A casual Italian eatery famous for its brick-oven pizzas, fresh mozzarella, and a surprisingly diverse seafood menu.
Try the Chicken Bacon Ranch
Reviewers highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch slice for a unique and flavorful option.
Consider Takeout
If you prefer to avoid potential service inconsistencies, ordering takeout is a good alternative.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian, Pizza, Seafood
Price
Mid-range
Phone
(862) 260-9500
Address
10 Lafayette Ave, Morristown, NJ 07960, USA
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Authentic Brick-Oven Pizza
Experience delicious, thin, crispy brick-oven pizzas with fresh mozzarella and exceptional tomato sauce.
Unique Italian & Seafood Menu
Beyond pizza, discover flavorful Italian dishes and surprisingly good seafood options, including lobster and shrimp.
Cozy Outdoor Seating
Enjoy socializing with friends in the nice outdoor seating area, perfect for warmer days.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Try the Chicken Bacon Ranch
Reviewers highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch slice for a unique and flavorful option.
Consider Takeout
If you prefer to avoid potential service inconsistencies, ordering takeout is a good alternative.
BYOB
The restaurant is BYOB, so remember to bring your own beverages. A liquor store is conveniently located next door.
Tips
from all over the internet
Try the Chicken Bacon Ranch
Reviewers highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch slice for a unique and flavorful option.
Consider Takeout
If you prefer to avoid potential service inconsistencies, ordering takeout is a good alternative.
BYOB
The restaurant is BYOB, so remember to bring your own beverages. A liquor store is conveniently located next door.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
The Godfather of Morristown offers a varied Italian and pizza experience, with many praising the brick-oven pizzas and fresh mozzarella. However, some diners have noted a decline in food quality and consistency over time, with specific complaints about pizza crusts, pasta dishes, and seafood. The ambiance and friendly service are often highlighted as positives, but value for money can be a concern for some.
"The food is delicious here! First time and will come back again many more times. The menu is amazing. Great choices, so many. We settled on a few pasta dishes and a white pizza for apps. It was perfect! Can’t wait to try other things on this beautiful menu! Great ambiance too. I love this place!"
Rania Naporlee
"No longer the best pizza in Morristown. Maybe the worst. Prices were high and have gone up while portions and quality have gone way down. So sad. Godfathers used to be THE best pizza and reliable takeout Italian in Morristown. I know times are tough post Covid but I can no longer recommend it. I've heard similar from friends and neighbors. I am on the hunt for their replacement."
Alexander Kontoleon
"We’ve been going here for years. Unfortunately, it’s went way downhill. The crust and crust/sauce/toppings ratio has been off.
Tonight the buffalo chicken had too much cheese, it lacked flavor. The cheese pie was just off.
I’ll be buying pizza from a different restaurant going forward."
Roderick Fiske
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Highly recommended are the brick-oven pizzas, especially those featuring fresh mozzarella. The chicken bacon ranch slice is also a popular choice.
Yes, the restaurant is BYOB. You should plan to bring your own beverages, though there is a liquor store located next door.
There is convenient parking available directly under the building for easy access.
Yes, they have a nice outdoor seating area that is perfect for socializing, especially during warmer days.
Some diners have reported issues with tough pizza crusts, overcooked or tasteless meats, and a perceived decline in overall food quality and consistency.
Yes, takeout is available. Some guests suggest ordering takeout if you prefer to dine-in due to potential service inconsistencies.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Morristown Restaurant Week: April 15-19, 2024
Once again, the event will coincide with a month-long Morristown Partnership Gift Certificate Giveaway that will kick off Monday, April 1st and run throughout April. All are welcome to enter for a chance to win!. Each week, 5 winners will be announced via social media, to receive $100 in Morristown Partnership Gift Certificates, as well as varying bonus gift certificates from Morristown businesses.
Best Restaurants in Morristown, NJ
Known for its brick-oven pizza and Italian favorites, The Godfather of Morristown provides a stylish yet approachable setting for dining. Address: 10 Lafayette Ave, Morristown, NJ 07960 Phone: (862) 260-9500
Top Local Restaurants and Eateries
The Godfather (East Hanover) A staple in town and good pizza!. They also opened a seafood restaurant attached that I haven’t tried yet!
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit