Tutoni's Restaurant
A contemporary farm-to-table Italian restaurant in York, offering rustic eats, a robust wine list, and a cozy neighborhood vibe.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
Tutoni's Restaurant
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A contemporary farm-to-table Italian restaurant in York, offering rustic eats, a robust wine list, and a cozy neighborhood vibe.
Make Reservations
Book in advance for special occasions or opt for a chef's pick dinner for a curated experience.
Whiskey Selection
Explore unique whiskey options like Stagg and Old Forester Birthday.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Italian
Price
$$$
Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Duck Ravioli
Indulge in the exquisite duck ravioli, a signature dish praised for its exceptional flavor and preparation.
Braised Beef Gnocchi
Savor the rich and decadent braised beef gnocchi, a culinary delight that's a must-try for pasta lovers.
Fine Dining Atmosphere
Experience an upscale dining atmosphere, particularly noted in the beautiful upstairs seating area.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Make Reservations
Book in advance for special occasions or opt for a chef's pick dinner for a curated experience.
Whiskey Selection
Explore unique whiskey options like Stagg and Old Forester Birthday.
Avoid Crowds
Visit during off-peak hours or weekdays for a potentially more personalized service.
Tips
from all over the internet
Make Reservations
Book in advance for special occasions or opt for a chef's pick dinner for a curated experience.
Whiskey Selection
Explore unique whiskey options like Stagg and Old Forester Birthday.
Avoid Crowds
Visit during off-peak hours or weekdays for a potentially more personalized service.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
Tutoni's Restaurant is celebrated for its fine dining experience, exceptional service, and delicious, scratch-made Italian cuisine. Diners rave about signature dishes like duck ravioli and braised beef gnocchi, and appreciate the upscale atmosphere. However, some patrons have noted issues with billing accuracy, perceived value, and management's response to criticism regarding food quality.
"This place is awesome. I visited for the first time before a YSO concert, and had an amazing time. I believe it will be my new favorite restaurant in York.
It’s a truly fine dining experience. The service is fantastic, but the food is even better.
My wife is still talking about the duck ravioli she had. I appreciated that they had some specialty Whiskey options like Stagg, Old Forester Birthday, Russell 13yr, etc."
Ben Burkhart
"I’ve been meaning to write a review for a while now! I went to visit family in Harrisburg for Father’s Day, and we decided to try Tutoni’s in York! It was beyond perfect, from beginning to end! We sat upstairs, which was such a beautiful space, and our waitress/bartender (I think her name was Ashley) was absolutely amazing! She suggested the best drinks, everything she recommended was delicious! My younger sister has autism, (so she’s super particular with taste and texture) and Ashley made a special sangria for her that she ended up loving, so her kindness and patience was truly appreciated! The food was beyond delicious, I could drink the sauce of the braised beef gnocchi like juice it’s that dang good! And of course, the espresso martinis and dessert, are absolutely superb! I highly recommend Tutoni’s for their stellar service, and phenomenal food!"
Nicole C
"Came here for our 6th wedding anniversary. The night started out on a high note with complimentary glasses of wine for our anniversary and a friendly server. The quail appetizer was very good and both pasta entrees were delicious. The entree portions were very filling but not overly large. Dessert and drinks were also great along with the French-press coffee. The perfect cherry on top was an anniversary card at the end. Great spot for a nice dinner, highly recommend."
Brandon Doyle
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Tutoni's is highly recommended for special occasions like anniversaries, with many reviewers highlighting complimentary wine and anniversary cards.
Popular dishes include duck ravioli, braised beef gnocchi, Bucatini and Meatballs, and the chef's specials.
Yes, the restaurant offers specialty whiskey options and creative cocktails, including unique mocktails.
It is advisable to make reservations, especially for peak times or special occasions, as recommended by reviewers and the restaurant's tips.
Some reviews mention a 'processing fee' and automatic gratuity, advising diners to check their bills carefully.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
7 Best Restaurants in York Pennsylvania
Tutoni's Restaurant in York provides an upscale Italian dining experience emphasizing quality ingredients and excellent service. With a carefully curated wine list and a stylish ambiance, Tutoni's is an excellent choice for a special occasion. Explore York County's Diverse Culinary Scene: These seven restaurants represent a taste of the diverse culinary offerings in York County, PA. There's something for everyone, from American classics to seafood, Mexican/Italian fusion, Mediterranean flavors, and Italian fine dining.
8 Cocktails to Help You Beat the Summer Heat in York County
Tutoni’s Restaurant in downtown York is all about scratch-made everything, from its soups and sauces, to its pasta and entrees. This ethos extends to the extensive and exciting cocktail list, which ranges from standards (gin and tonic, old fashioned) to the new school, like the Purple Rain, with genever, creme de violette and lavender bitters. Just like “historically edgy” downtown York, the Tutoni’s menu seamlessly blends classic and modern elements to create thrilling new experiences.
11 romantic restaurants perfect for Valentine's Day
At Tutoni's, there's no need to feel rushed – just a need to take in the experience. The restaurant's interior is full of texture – from columns adding to its Mediterranean feel, to ceiling panels and iron chandeliers, to a wall of wood illuminated by candles. But another big draw is the locally sourced food.
York County restaurants that rank high, according to Yelp reviews
Popular Dishes: Sweet Onion Ravioli, Rigatoni Bolognese, Crab and Corn Fettuccini. Sometimes, you just need some really good Italian food, and Tutoni's is where it's at. With over 230 reviews and a 4.1 rating, this is clearly a local favorite.
How to Explore Downtown York, PA: The Hippest Small Town You’ve Never Heard Of
Our list of recommendations could go on forever, but we also have to mention The Fig & Barrel Pub, Tutoni’s Restaurant, The Handsome Cab (wine bar), and Iron Horse York to round out our top picks.
Outdoor Dining Returns to George Street This Summer
Patrons will be able to enjoy dining al fresco at The Handsome Cab, Tutoni’s, Rockfish Public House, and Gift Horse Brewing Company.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit