The Fish Trap Restaurant & Seafood Market
A beloved family-owned seafood market and restaurant in Cruz Bay, known for its incredibly fresh fish and welcoming local vibe.
Highlights
Must-see attractions
Social
From TikTok & Reddit
Best Time
Blue hour photography, calmer galleries
The Fish Trap Restaurant & Seafood Market
Highlights
Must-see attractions
A beloved family-owned seafood market and restaurant in Cruz Bay, known for its incredibly fresh fish and welcoming local vibe.
Seasonal Availability
Visit during the season for the freshest fish; the restaurant closes during the off-season.
Try the Blackened Wahoo
This dish is a visitor favorite and highly recommended for its delicious flavor.
Quick Facts
Cuisine
Seafood
Price
Mid-range
Phone
+1 340-693-9994
Address
5A Cruz Bay Quarter, Cruz Bay, St John 00831, U.S. Virgin Islands
Website
thefishtrap.com/Highlights
Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences
Outstanding Fresh Seafood
Savor the freshest catch of the day, with standout dishes like Shrimp Scampi, Mussels, Salmon, and Swordfish & shrimp.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere
Experience a welcoming, home-like vibe that makes everyone feel like part of the family, perfect for a comfortable dining experience.
Local Vibe & Post-Dinner Fun
Enjoy a great local atmosphere and consider heading to Fred's backyard for live reggae music after your meal.
Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you
Insider Tips
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit
Seasonal Availability
Visit during the season for the freshest fish; the restaurant closes during the off-season.
Try the Blackened Wahoo
This dish is a visitor favorite and highly recommended for its delicious flavor.
Post-Dinner Entertainment
Enjoy dinner then head to Fred's backyard for live reggae or steel drum music.
Beer Selection Update
Check if the beer selection has been updated, as changes were expected.
Tips
from all over the internet
Seasonal Availability
Visit during the season for the freshest fish; the restaurant closes during the off-season.
Try the Blackened Wahoo
This dish is a visitor favorite and highly recommended for its delicious flavor.
Post-Dinner Entertainment
Enjoy dinner then head to Fred's backyard for live reggae or steel drum music.
Beer Selection Update
Check if the beer selection has been updated, as changes were expected.
What Travellers Say
Reviews Summary
The Fish Trap Restaurant & Seafood Market is celebrated for its exceptionally fresh seafood and warm, family-friendly atmosphere, making diners feel right at home. While many praise dishes like Shrimp Scampi, Mussels, Salmon, and blackened Wahoo, some reviews mention issues with noise levels, potentially small appetizer portions, and a dismissive management response to seating concerns. Despite these occasional drawbacks, the fresh taste and local vibe remain strong draws for visitors and locals alike.
"The Fish Trap us awesome. Having tried multiple places downtown, it was refreshing to find a place that was family friendly, able to accommodate my pregnant wife's dinner requests, and also made is feel at home and a part of the family. We ended up coming twice and both times were outstanding. I definitely recommend the Shrimp Scampi or the Mussels."
Ruben Noel
"Great food. Today is their last day for the season, we went last night. Fish was fresh, atmosphere was great. We had a great time with a couple friends we met on an excursion earlier in the week. Def have a late dinner and head over to the beach bar after a block over. Had an awesome time"
Nick Rossi
"By far, the BEST dinner we had in St. John/ Cruz Bay... Salmon was melt in your mouth delicious!!! Swordfish & shrimp was seasoned so well! Fresh fresh fresh! Amazing! Servers were also so kind and welcoming!"
Peggy Andrews
What People Like
What People Dislike
Frequently Asked Questions
Visitors highly recommend the Shrimp Scampi, Mussels, melt-in-your-mouth Salmon, well-seasoned Swordfish & shrimp, and the blackened Wahoo.
Yes, it's known for a family-friendly atmosphere that makes guests feel at home.
Yes, the restaurant offers both outdoor seating and an air-conditioned indoor dining area.
It's best to visit during their operating season for the freshest fish, as they close during the off-season.
Many diners suggest heading to Fred's backyard after dinner for live reggae or steel drum music.
Prices are generally consistent with other restaurants in Cruz Bay, placing it in the mid-range category.
Mentioned in
Featured in these publications
Good Restaurants in St. John
Unique: Vie's Chicken Shack, Skinny Legs and Miss Lucys.Seafood: Lime Inn and Fish TrapOther Favorites: Morgan Mangos.....also after a week of seafood, last time we went to Margaritas for Mexican and it was great
cruz bay, st. john restaurants
We also enjoy the Banana Deck and think it is very reasonable. You can go very expensive (Zozo's, Asolare) or you can eat bar food at the Beach Bar. Many people love the foods at the stands too.
St John and Vieques US Virgin Islands
We ended most beach days sipping Presidente beers and Margaritas as we watched the ferry from St. Thomas come and go from the porch at Spyglass restaurant; dinners – local mahi at Fish Trap, Asian-inflected dishes with a postcard-worthy at Asolare and Thai at Rhumb Lines – were fresh, delicious and casual. We weren’t sure about getting carry out ribs from Candi’s BBQ and Grill – the not-mobile food truck is located next to a gas station near the car ferry – until we spotted Candi in the back chopping cabbage for cole slaw. “I make everything here, including the come-back sauce for the ribs,” she said.
St John Resturant Recommendations – Travel Message Board – U.S
The Lime Inn, Morgan's Mango, The Fish Trap, Roma Cafe for pizza and pasta (lots of people ordering for pick up to take back to their hotels) Woody's for good bar food and people watching and Chilly Billy's for breakfast. For our next trip, we'll probably try the BBQ place, Miss Lucy's and Las Tapas. My husband isn't much of a foodie so a good restaurant is pretty much lost on him 🙂
Restaurants Archives
Our casual, comfortable, covered patio setting allows you to enjoy the outdoors and cool tropical breezes while you dine, or you can eat in our air-conditioned bar. Enjoy the mahogany wood bar with its hand painted tiles, our unique works of art on the walls and our flat-screen TV showing sports and other specials.
restaurants st john usvi
340-776-0580 | www.thefishtrap.com The Fish Trap is quintessential Cruz Bay. ST. JOHN USVI 00831 340-693-8688 . Find the best restaurants, food, and dining in St. John, Virgin Islands, make a reservation, or order delivery on Yelp: search reviews of 302 St. John restaurants by price, type, or location.
Visitor Guide – Villa Agel Vacation Rental
The Fish Trap – is a restaurant and fish market that serves high quality, delicious, and fresh fish (Caribbean lobster, wahoo, swordfish, salmon, ahi tuna, crab cakes, mussels, clams and more!) perfectly cooked pasta, crispy salads, tender and juicy meats, award winning desserts and more.
St. John's Best Restaurants in U.S. Virgin Islands
As the name suggests, this family-owned restaurant is one of the best places in Cruz Bay for fresh fish. At least six fresh fish specials are offered each night. The list is drawn up just before opening to ensure diners receive the day's freshest catch.
Bars and Restaurants
He spent almost 15 years in the Trap’s kitchen before launching the upscale Stone Terrace, making the Fish Trap a favorite for locals and visitors. Then he went to St. Thomas to head up a restaurant at the new Yacht Haven.
restaurants st john usvi
340-776-0580 | www.thefishtrap.com The Fish Trap is quintessential Cruz Bay. Please be advised the average dining time is . Seatings are at 6:00, 6:30, 7:00 and 7:30 P.M.
Social
from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit