McCurdy Hotel (Historic) - Image 1
1 / 3

Historic McCurdy Hotel

4
·56 reviews·Evansville, United States

A historic downtown gem blending old-world charm with modern apartment living, featuring unique architecture and convenient amenities.

Highlights

Must-see attractions

Social content

Social

From TikTok & Reddit

Best Time

Weekday afternoons

Fewer crowds, easier access

CrowdLow
Loading map...
McCurdy Hotel (Historic) - Image 1

Historic McCurdy Hotel

Best Time

Weekday afternoons

Fewer crowds, easier access

CrowdLow

Highlights

Must-see attractions

A historic downtown gem blending old-world charm with modern apartment living, featuring unique architecture and convenient amenities.

4
(56 reviews)

"A dream building full of character and charm, offering downtown convenience and historic appeal."

Vertical photo
TIP

✨ Embrace the History

Appreciate the building's unique character and historic charm; it's part of the McCurdy experience!

☀️ Request a River View

Units with river views offer stunning sunsets and a more serene atmosphere.

Third hero image

Highlights

Discover the most iconic attractions and experiences

River View Sunsets

River View Sunsets

River-facing units

Breathtaking sunsets over the river paint the sky, offering a serene and picturesque backdrop to your stay.

Downtown Convenience

Downtown Convenience

Ground floor and surrounding area

Enjoy the ease of city living with shops, dining, and amenities just steps away, plus included parking.

Myriad Brewery & Food Trucks

Myriad Brewery & Food Trucks

Main floor

A vibrant brewery on-site often hosts food trucks, creating a lively social hub with diverse culinary options.

Historic Architecture

Historic Architecture

Throughout the building

Experience the grandeur of a building on the National Register of Historic Places, blending old-world charm with modern updates.

Your AI travel agent

Plans like a pro.
Thinks like you

Start Chatting

Planning Your Visit

Embrace the Historic Charm

The McCurdy Hotel is a historic gem, offering unique character and modern amenities. While some areas show wear, the building's rich past and prime downtown location are major draws. Be prepared for potential maintenance quirks, but the overall experience is often praised for its charm and convenience.

Navigating Property Management

Reviews for property management are mixed. While some residents find the process easy and communication thorough, others report unprofessional interactions. It's advisable to manage expectations and document any concerns, as experiences with staff can vary significantly.

Best Times

When
Weekday afternoons
Why
Fewer crowds, easier access
Crowd
Low
When
Evenings with food trucks
Why
Lively atmosphere
Crowd
Medium

Insider Tips

from TikTok, Instagram & Reddit

✨ Embrace the History

Appreciate the building's unique character and historic charm; it's part of the McCurdy experience! Reddit

☀️ Request a River View

Units with river views offer stunning sunsets and a more serene atmosphere. Reddit

🚗 Utilize Free Parking

The convenience of free parking in a downtown location is a significant perk. Reddit

🍻 Check Brewery Events

Myriad Brewery on the main floor often hosts food trucks and events. Reddit

Tips

from all over the internet

✨ Embrace the History

Appreciate the building's unique character and historic charm; it's part of the McCurdy experience! Reddit

☀️ Request a River View

Units with river views offer stunning sunsets and a more serene atmosphere. Reddit

🚗 Utilize Free Parking

The convenience of free parking in a downtown location is a significant perk. Reddit

🍻 Check Brewery Events

Myriad Brewery on the main floor often hosts food trucks and events. Reddit

🛠️ Report Maintenance Needs

While some maintenance issues exist, prompt reporting can lead to efficient resolutions. Reddit

What Travellers Say

4
(56 reviews)

Reviews Summary

The Historic McCurdy Hotel is lauded for its incredible historic charm, prime downtown location, and modern apartment features like in-unit laundry and updated kitchens. Residents appreciate the convenience of free parking and the lively atmosphere created by the on-site brewery and frequent food trucks. However, consistent maintenance issues, particularly with elevators and common area upkeep, along with mixed experiences with property management, detract from its potential as a luxury living space.

"The McCurdy is a dream building, full of character and charm! Working with Amanda was so easy - she took time to answer my questions and was thorough during the application and move-in process. The neighborhood feels safe and friendly! Can’t say enough about my experience so far!"

Jamie Slaton

"Amanda the property management!
Is just a rude unprofessional and a very unpleasant person to speak with!

Pretty sure she drinks on the job! She seemed very drunk! Made my children very uncomfortable"

Anna Ylimaf

"The convenience of downtown living, plus amenities such as free parking and internet are what drew me to the McCurdy. Add to that the rich history of a building that is on the National Register of Historic Places and has modern touches like stainless steal appliances, granite countertops, a washer and dryer in each unit and a brewery on the main floor that often hosts food trucks and this place really has a lot of potential.

But it falls short at just that. A place full of potential. Several of the hallways on the various floors need repairs to baseboards and fresh paint on the baseboards and walls. On the fifth floor, they have had paint swatches painted on the wall for about 2 years as if they are actually ever going to repaint (I’m not holding my breath, those swatches will probably still be there in another 2 years). The stairways never get cleaned. They did finally repaint the stairways but they painted it bright white which makes it even more obvious how dirty the stairs are since they NEVER get cleaned! The service elevator has been broken for several years and they refuse to fix it making moving larger items in or out of the building very difficult. The elevators only work part of the time. One of the two has been broken for about 3 weeks now (the other one actually wasn’t working one night too meaning tenants had to use the stairs). And this is a non-smoking building but there is constantly an odor of weed in many of the hallways.

The river view units have amazing views and beautiful sunsets! And Myriad on the main floor is a huge bonus to living in the McCurdy. So you have to weigh the pros and cons if you’re considering living in the McCurdy. It’s a nice enough place to live but there are so many improvements that need to be made in order for the McCurdy to actually be what it’s advertised as, “Luxury Apartments.”"

Amanda C

What People Like

Historic charm and character
Downtown convenience
Modern apartment amenities

What People Dislike

Elevator maintenance issues
Common area upkeep
Inconsistent management

Frequently Asked Questions

🚇 🗺️ Getting There

The Historic McCurdy Hotel is conveniently located downtown. Public transportation options are available, and driving is also feasible with included parking for residents and visitors. Reddit

Yes, free parking is a significant amenity offered at the McCurdy Hotel, which is a major draw for its downtown location. Reddit

The neighborhood is described as safe and friendly, offering the convenience of downtown living with easy access to shops and dining. Reddit

🎫 🎫 Tickets & Entry

The Historic McCurdy Hotel primarily functions as a residential building with commercial spaces like the brewery. General visits to admire the architecture or visit the brewery do not require tickets. Reddit

As a residential building, there are no set visitor hours. However, the on-site brewery, Myriad, will have its own operating hours. Reddit

While the building is on the National Register of Historic Places, tours are not typically offered. You can experience its historic charm by visiting the common areas or the brewery. Reddit

🎫 🧭 Onsite Experience

Amenities include modern touches like stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, in-unit washers and dryers, free parking, and internet. The building also features a brewery on the main floor. Reddit

Some residents have noted that certain hallways and stairways could use repairs and fresh paint. The service elevator has been out of order for years, and one of the main elevators is frequently broken. Reddit

Information regarding pet policies is not explicitly detailed in the provided reviews, but it's a common query for apartment buildings. Reddit

The atmosphere is a blend of historic charm and modern living. While some areas need upkeep, the building offers a unique living experience with its rich history and downtown convenience. Reddit

While not explicitly mentioned, living in a downtown historic building can sometimes come with ambient city noise. The presence of a brewery might also contribute to evening activity. Reddit

🍽️ 🍽️ Food & Dining

Myriad, a brewery, is located on the main floor and often hosts food trucks, providing diverse and convenient dining options. Reddit

Being in the downtown area, there are numerous restaurants and eateries within walking distance, offering a wide variety of cuisines. Reddit

Yes, units are equipped with modern kitchens featuring stainless steel appliances and granite countertops, allowing for in-unit cooking. Reddit

📸 📸 Photography

The river-facing units offer stunning sunset views. The historic architecture throughout the building, including hallways and common areas, also provides unique photographic opportunities. Reddit

Visitors are generally welcome to take photos in common areas and the brewery. If you are a resident, you have more freedom to photograph your living space. Reddit

While not explicitly stated, it's always good practice to be mindful of residents' privacy if photographing common areas. Reddit

For Different Travelers

Tailored advice for your travel style

👨‍👩‍👧 Families with Kids

The Historic McCurdy Hotel offers a unique living experience with its blend of history and modern amenities. For families, the convenience of downtown living is a major plus, with shops and dining easily accessible. The in-unit washers and dryers are a significant convenience for households with children. Reddit

However, families should be aware of the reported maintenance issues, particularly with elevators, which could pose challenges when navigating with strollers or young children. The presence of a brewery on the main floor might also mean more activity in common areas during evenings. It's worth inquiring about specific family-friendly policies and the current status of elevator repairs before committing to a stay or residency. Reddit

💰 Budget Travelers

The McCurdy Hotel can be an attractive option for budget-conscious travelers looking for a unique stay, especially if they can leverage the free parking amenity in a downtown area. The in-unit kitchens with modern appliances also offer the potential to save money by preparing some meals instead of dining out for every meal. Reddit

While the building has historic charm, potential renters or guests should weigh the cost against the reported maintenance issues and inconsistent property management experiences. The brewery and potential food truck events offer affordable dining options on-site. It's advisable to thoroughly research current conditions and management responsiveness to ensure the value aligns with expectations. Reddit

Deep Dives

In-depth insights and expert knowledge

The Historic Significance of the McCurdy Hotel

The Historic McCurdy Hotel is more than just an apartment building; it's a piece of local history, listed on the National Register of Historic Places. This designation signifies its architectural and historical importance, offering residents and visitors a chance to live or stay within a structure that has witnessed decades of change. The building's grandeur is evident in its design, blending classic aesthetics with the modern updates that have been incorporated over time. Experiencing the McCurdy is like stepping back in time while enjoying contemporary comforts. Reddit

Despite its historic status, the McCurdy has been adapted for modern living, featuring units with stainless steel appliances and granite countertops. This juxtaposition of old and new is a key part of its appeal. However, the maintenance of these historic elements, alongside the modern amenities, presents ongoing challenges. Some areas, like hallways and stairways, show signs of wear and could benefit from updates, reflecting the complexities of preserving a historic building while ensuring it meets contemporary standards. Reddit

The building's location in the heart of downtown further enhances its appeal, offering unparalleled convenience and access to city life. This prime spot, combined with its historical significance, makes the McCurdy a unique and desirable place. Understanding its history provides a deeper appreciation for the building's character and the efforts involved in its preservation and modernization. Reddit

Navigating Maintenance and Management

Living in a historic building like the McCurdy Hotel comes with its own set of challenges, particularly concerning maintenance and property management. While some residents have had positive experiences, with prompt and friendly service for issues like appliance repairs, others have encountered difficulties. Reddit The reviews highlight a recurring concern with the upkeep of common areas, such as hallways and stairways, which are noted as needing repairs and fresh paint. The prolonged disrepair of the service elevator and frequent issues with the main elevators also present significant inconveniences for residents, especially when moving large items. Reddit

The property management itself has received mixed feedback. While one reviewer praised the ease of working with Amanda and her thoroughness, another described her as rude and unprofessional, even suggesting she might have been intoxicated on the job. This disparity in experiences suggests that interactions with management can be unpredictable. Reddit Furthermore, despite being a non-smoking building, some residents report a persistent odor of marijuana in the hallways, indicating potential issues with enforcing building policies. These factors contribute to a perception that the building, while having great potential, falls short of advertised 'luxury apartment' standards due to these operational and maintenance shortcomings. Reddit

You may also like

1 of 2